13 Best Italian Restaurants in Bay Shore

Butera's - Bay Shore Italian • $$
8 Third Avenue, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Penne Vodka with Chicken and Chicken Meatballs
Butera’S Cauliflower Gluten Free Crust Pizza
Rare Seared Sesame Crusted Tuna Salad
Double Cut Pork Chop Scarpariello
Fettuccine Lump Crab Bay Scallop
Pistachio Encrusted Salmon
Rainbow Cookie Cheesecake
Chocolate Brownie Sundae
Linguine Seafood Scoglio
Pistachio Crusted Salmon

“I grew up in a 100 percent Italian family and I have to say Nona’s lasagna was the best I’ve ever had in my life. At 58 years old I have had plenty of lasagna. This is my new go to spot for Italian fare.“

4.6 Superb447 Reviews
Bella Mia Cafe - Restaurant Italian • $$
134 West Main Street, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Fried Risotto Balls with Marinara
Margherita

“Must try the fall cocktails and the gelato cocktails! Ask Brad to whip you up a special pumpkin gelato cocktail! And the blueberry gelato is out of this world! Celiac and gluten friendly restaurant! Oh the gelato is gluten free btw so don’t be scared to have dessert 🍨!!!“

4.8 Superb58 Reviews
Frank & Maria's Italian Market Italian • $$
10 W Main St, Bay Shore

“The food is incredible (oh the meats!), the service is fantastic (go have a conversation with Frank or anyone from his team), and there are great options for pastas, desserts and other things.“

4.7 Superb96 Reviews
Bella Vie Italian • $$$
240 W Main St, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Medium Rare Steak Dinner
Baked Clams Oreganata
Stuffed Veal Chop
Gnocchi Alla Bava
Stuffed Mushrooms
Gnocchi Ala Bava
Arancini Bella
Grilled Salmon
Banana Foster
Burrata Salad

“Bella Vie restaurant is such a gem! Wonderful ownership. Mike is amazing and the views are to die for. The food is exquisite. If you haven’t been, it’s a must try on Long Island“

4.3 Superb308 Reviews
Amore Pizza Italian • $
2110 Union Blvd, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheese Steak Pizza
Six Feet Italian Sandwich
Sicilian Cheese Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Eggplant Parmigiana
Extra Cheese Pizza
Extra Large Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Piccata
Chicken Tenders

“Great selection and great food“

4.2 Good198 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
1715 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana a Classic with Our Homemade Marinara and a Side of Spaghetti
Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Sautéed Shrimp
Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Saut
Giant Meatball with Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
Chicken Parmigiana with Spaghetti
Tour of Italy Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken \u0026 Shrimp Carbonara
Fettucini Alfredo with Broccoli
Chicken and Shrimp Alfredo
Chicken Marsala Fettuccine

“Breadsticks. Breadsticks. Breadsticks. I can’t express enough how good the breadsticks are. Server is always attentive to the basket and replenishes them fast. The pasta and salads are always delicious, though I tend to focus on the breadsticks!“

4.1 Good381 Reviews
Mulberry Street Bay Shore Italian • $
192 Howells Rd, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Special
Seafood Stuffed
Baked Manicotti
Minestrone Soup
Grilled Chicken
Chicken Caesar
Broccoli Rabe
Grandma Pizza
Veal Marsala

“I had Mulberry accommodate my daughter’s birthday party yesterday after being recommended by someone from the area! Received a number of compliments on the pizza. Now being a Pizza lover myself and having this slice for the first time yesterday. It was a great slice! Cooked just the way I like it. Would recommend them to anybody hosting in the area. Zeppoli’s were excellent as well! Great service friendly people as well. Thank you again!“

3.9 Good155 Reviews
8

Sbarro

Sbarro Pizza • $
1701 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore

“Yummy Hawaiian pizza style I’ll buy more soon“

4.9 Superb13 Reviews
Victorio II Pizza Pizza • $
20 Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Square Pizza - Sicilian with Cheese
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Chicken Pizza with Ricotta
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Pizza and Garlic Knots
Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Mozzarella Sticks
Zucchini Sticks
Chicken Rolls

“Service, pizza and staff are simply awesome. Pizza is always hot, ready and fresh. Their Wednesday special is so great I try to get it weekly!! They also offer dessert, Italian ice, drinks and pizza by the slice. Their location even has a few booths in case you want to eat there“

4.4 Superb124 Reviews
Fratelli Pizzeria Pizza • $
553 E Main St, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Shrimp Salad with Our Home Made Salad Dressing
Pepperoni Broccoli and Spinach Pinwheels
Saute Broccoli with Garlic and Olive Oil
Chicken Sorrentino over Spaghetti
Sausage Peppers and Onions Pizza
Chicken Francese over Spaghetti
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Sausage and Peppers
Grilled Vegetables
Shrimp Oreganata

“The best food and most wonderful family!“

4.3 Superb155 Reviews
ITA Kitchen Italian • $$$
69 East Main Street, Patchogue

Customers` Favorites

Rabe and Sausage Egg Rolls
Penne Vodka with Pancetta
Linguini Clams and Shrimp
Sals Mac and Cheese Side
Homemade Burrata Ravioli
Chicken Burrata Caprese
Fried Rainbow Cookies
Buffalo Mac & Cheese
Burrata Avocado Toast
Tommy's Chicken Parm

“This place is for the foodies! We dinned at the Patchogue Location on a Saturday 4pm and had the place to ourselves which was nice. We ordered The Sals fried chicken bowl with caesar salad, it was so good! we also ordered the mac & cheese and this was probably one of the best i’ve ever had, 10/10 must try. The parmesan truffle fries are perfectly crisp and delicious. The risotto balls were also very good! Our server Gianna R was so sweet and attentive. Highly recommended this place. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️e“

3.8 Good464 Reviews
Buseto Pizza Pizza • $
1851 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Chicken Parmigiana
Linguine Garlic & Oil
Chicken Ceasars Slice
Mediterranean Salad
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Francese
Chicken Marsala
Brooklyn Pizza
Brooklyn Slice

“2 👍🏼 👍🏼!s up. I saw a puppy in there while it’s owner was eating and nobody said anything 🐾🐾❤️.“

3.9 Good182 Reviews
Chubby Deli Deli • $
630 Pine Aire Dr, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Gourmet Hero Per Foot
Roast Beef Sandwich
Mashed Potatoes
Grilled Chicken
Grilled Cheese
Home Fries
Roll

“One of the best deli’s in the deer park area. Food is great. The amounts they give are perfect and loaded and they NEVER mess up on orders. We switched here from the deli up the road and they even deliver to us. Worth every bite! Thankyou guys/gals!

-DSS Security Workers“

3.7 Good116 Reviews

You May Also Like