Browse menus, reviews and photos of Italian Restaurants near West Babylon.
Italian · $$
69 Bergen Avenue Suite 1, West Babylon
“Just like the golf course this venue is one of the best hidden gems on Long Island! Beautiful room. Great staff. Amazing food. What more could you ask for?”
Italian · $$
761 Sunrise Highway, West Babylon
Customers’ favorites
“If you’re craving an Italian dining experience that transports you straight to the heart of your Nonna’s kitchen, look no further than Cafe Gio in the Lidl Shopping Center, West Babylon, NY! From the moment we stepped into this unassuming gem tucked off Sunrise Highway, we were enveloped in an atmosphere that exuded authenticity, warmth, and culinary passion. This is not “just a meal”—it’s a direct love letter to true Italian cuisine (and I’m still swooning over every bite). Let’s start with the menu (!), a veritable symphony of Italian classics and innovative dishes that could satisfy even the most discerning appetite. The selection is vast, offering everything from Neapolitan and artisan pizzas to seafood, pastas, and entrees that make you feel like you’re dining in a rustic trattoria in Italy. The diversity is staggering, yet every dish feels crafted with precision and heart. We were a party of five, each with our own cravings, and Cafe Gio delivered beyond our wildest expectations! First up, the Roma Chicken. Oh, where do I begin? This dish was a revelation—tender chicken breast sautéed to perfection, crowned with spinach, melted mozzarella, and bathed in a delicate light pink brandy sauce. Next, the Chicken Parmigiana. This is not your run-of-the-mill parm. The chicken cutlet was impeccably crispy yet juicy, blanketed in a vibrant, house-made tomato sauce that had just the right balance of tang and sweetness. Topped with a generous layer of bubbling mozzarella, it was served with a side of perfectly al dente pasta. This dish alone is worth the trip to West Babylon—it’s comfort food elevated to an art form. The Shrimp Parmigiana was another showstopper. Golden-fried shrimp, plump and succulent, were nestled under that same glorious tomato sauce and mozzarella. Paired with a side of linguine, it was a plate of pure indulgence. And then, the Chicken Francese. This dish was a masterclass in elegance. The chicken, lightly battered and sautéed in a lemony white wine sauce, was bright, zesty, and melt-in-your-mouth tender. Now, let’s talk about Jill, our server, who was nothing short of a superstar. She was the epitome of salt-of-the-earth—warm, genuine, and attentive without ever being overbearing. Jill’s infectious enthusiasm for the menu made us feel like we were dining at her own table. She checked in just enough to ensure our glasses were filled and our needs were met, all while sharing a smile that made the experience feel personal and heartfelt. Her knowledge of the menu was spot-on, and her recommendations were pure gold. Jill is the kind of server who turns a great meal into an unforgettable experience. The ambiance at Cafe Gio strikes a perfect balance between casual and inviting. Located in a strip mall, you might not expect the cozy, family-owned vibe that greets you inside. The dining room is spacious yet intimate, with a clean, welcoming aesthetic that makes it ideal for everything from a quick lunch to a celebratory dinner. Once you enter the door, prepare for the magic to unfold. Buon appetito!”
Pizza · $
999 Montauk Highway, West Babylon
Customers’ favorites
“Our family had a gathering at Alitalia, we had a wonderful experience, our server was attentive, our food served reasonably on time and we didn't think the prices were out of hand. Fast paced yes. We got there early and made a reservation almost a month in advance.”
Pizza · $
1030 Little East Neck Road, West Babylon
Customers’ favorites
“Always such a great experience. The owner Frank always is accommodating. It’s a family owned business and the food is phenomenal!”
Pizza · $
929 Little East Neck Road, West Babylon
Customers’ favorites
“I love this place! I’ve been going here for years! My favorite thing about this place is the portions are AWESOME! Worth the money.. an insane amount of pizza choices as well which is always a plus; and awesome deals. My favorite is the Monday specials deals!!”
Pizza · $
90 NY-109, West Babylon
Customers’ favorites
“The food is awesome and everyone is so kind and patient.Pete treats you like Family.”
Pizza · $
419 Great East Neck Road, West Babylon
Customers’ favorites
“Love this place! I have been going here for many years. The pies with the sauce on top are amazing and all the food that I get from there is good especially the chicken wings oh my God amazing! All the staff is nice helpful and friendly would definitely recommend to all.”
Italian · $$
8 Third Avenue, Bay Shore · 5.61 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I grew up in a 100 percent Italian family and I have to say Nona’s lasagna was the best I’ve ever had in my life. At 58 years old I have had plenty of lasagna. This is my new go to spot for Italian fare.”
Italian · $$
141 Woodbury Road, Woodbury · 9.57 miles
Customers’ favorites
“pass it every night on my way home from work. and decided to meet a friend there sat night. my parents come from Italy and I spent all my summers there as a kid. it is the closes I have ever had to pizza in Italy, my only very small complain is. I wish maybe a few more choices for apps.”
Italian · $$
10 Allen Boulevard, Farmingdale · 3.77 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Once again a wonderful anniversary dinner. For the past 4 years we have celebrated our anniversary here. The food, service and attention were once again top notch. The prices are reasonable considering the quality provided. Just enough time between courses, no rush, no push. I cannot recommend this place enough.”
Italian · $$
7903 Jericho Turnpike, Woodbury · 9.38 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Food and the service was awesome. Reasonably priced. Relaxing atmosphere. Highly recommend.”
Italian · $$
169 Commack Road, Commack · 8.87 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Delicious home cooked Italian food. Relaxing warm and cosy atmosphere.”
Italian · $$$
1870 East Jericho Turnpike, Huntington · 8.24 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Amazing baked clams!!! Amazing Drinks!!”
Italian · $$$
6300 Jericho Turnpike, Commack · 9.1 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The food is out of this world. The servers are professional and patient. My husband and I felt great, relaxed and we were able to talk unlike other restaurants that you can't hear people on your table.”
Italian · $$
3982 Jerusalem Avenue, Seaford · 7.16 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Went in with a party of 10. 4 of us eat gluten free. The owner came over and explained everything we could have, which was a lot. They have gf pasta. And said that if we call ahead they will make custom meals like gluten free chicken parmigiana. Joe took our order and remembered everything perfectly. We will definitely be back!”
Italian · $$
485 West Montauk Highway, Lindenhurst · 3.27 miles
Customers’ favorites
“They always have great bands.”
Italian · $$
968 Fulton Street, Farmingdale · 4.31 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Fun time with friends! Our waiter Puma was excellent!”
Italian · $$$
696 Motor Parkway, Hauppauge · 8.7 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Always the best, food is delicious and very consistent, the staff is exceptional.”
Italian · $$$
7725 Jericho Turnpike, Woodbury · 9.53 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Such a beautiful venue. Our dinner was excellent from service to food. I highly recommend.”
Italian · $$
3935 Merrick Road, Seaford · 7.77 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Don't add salt or sauce. Try the food first. Then you will realize you don't need to add anything. Everything on the menu is cooked to perfection. If this restaurant was in Pretoria we would be locals. The staff and hands on owners are amazing. The service was fantastic and the food next level. In all our travels this was the best destination by far. We hope to see you again soon. Thank you for taking care of us. Ps the guesthouse is just as fantastic. Charlene and Sheriden”
Italian · $$$
376 Deer Park Avenue, Babylon · 2.01 miles
Customers’ favorites
“What a great night at Talina! The food was phenomenal, the atmosphere was perfect, and Max our bartender was awesome—he really elevated the whole experience. We had an amazing time and will definitely be back.”
Italian · $$
238 Deer Park Avenue, Babylon · 2.08 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great food ! Great atmosphere …. Nice little cozy spot my new fav !!!!!”
Italian · $$
196 Main Street, Farmingdale · 4.95 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Want to thank the folks at Tre Scalini for helping me organize a funeral luncheon for my brother in law’s mom. They are not from the area and tasked us with finding a place near Pine Lawn. The team was easy to work with, accommodated all of the family’s allergies and was affordable. We can’t thank them enough! Highly recommend.”
Italian · $$
313 Main Street, Farmingdale · 5 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Went to the Farmingdale location last night, service was fast and great, drinks were tasty, food was excellent!”
Italian · $$
452 West Jericho Turnpike, Huntington · 8.65 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We moved off Long Island over 8 years ago and always loved la Parma when we lived here even though it was an hour drive for us to enjoy the amazing food. This time when we came up to visit for Christmas we knew we had to get there for a great dinner. I can easily say it still is one of the best places to get amazing Italian food around. The Chicken Napoli was phenomenal and there is nothing like their penne à la vodka! The drinks were great and service was top notch. We also happened to go the day after Christmas when we got lots of snow and the car valet even brushed off our car! We were so happy to not feel rushed because we were there with great friends and just really enjoying ourselves! We can’t wait to come back and visit from Georgia to have their food again!”
Italian · $$$
1020 Park Boulevard, Massapequa Park · 5.98 miles
Customers’ favorites
“My wife and I recently hosted a baby shower for our daughter. To say the party was excellent wouldn’t be accurate. It was more than excellent. The food, the service, the staff could not have been better. All of the 55 guests raved about every aspect of the gathering. Many of these guests had never been to Bacaro before but now said they would definitely be coming back. If I had to come up with one negative… I couldn’t. Thanks for making a special day everything we could have hoped for.”
Italian · $$
1945 Deer Park Avenue, Deer Park · 3.41 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The food is amazing ,every dish. The portions from the appetizers to the meals are above the average restaurant.”
Steak House · $$$
184 Broadway, Amityville · 4.31 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Vittorios delivered many trays of food for a funeral gathering. Everyone was raving how delicious it was. Thank you so much. 😊”
Italian · $
640 North Wellwood Avenue, Lindenhurst · 1.89 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great people , awesome fresh food at a convenient location.”
Italian · $$
644 Vanderbilt Motor Parkway, Hauppauge · 8.28 miles
Customers’ favorites
“This place is amazing. The food is delicious. I enjoyed the crab cocktail and the lobster crêpes the people there are awesome and the place is nice fancy.”
Italian · $$$
4857 Merrick Road, Massapequa Park · 6.52 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Date night with my cousin at Mangia e Bevi in Massapequa Park, and it was such a good night. We did the Date Night Special for 2, $49.95 for any pizza, any pasta, and a bottle of wine to share. We got the San Gennaro flatbread with spicy and sweet sausage, peppers, onions, and olive oil, and the Bucatini with shrimp, calamari, mussels, and spicy tomato sauce, with Lagaria Pinot Grigio. We ended with pumpkin gelato served in an actual pumpkin, which was the perfect ending. Thank you for a delicious meal, we will be back.”
Italian · $$
134 West Main Street, Bay Shore · 5.41 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Must try the fall cocktails and the gelato cocktails! Ask Brad to whip you up a special pumpkin gelato cocktail! And the blueberry gelato is out of this world! Celiac and gluten friendly restaurant! Oh the gelato is gluten free btw so don’t be scared to have dessert 🍨!!!”
Italian · $$
385 Veterans Memorial Highway Suite 6, Smithtown · 9.4 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I have been ordering from them for years. They always deliver a tasty meal for a great price. Sandwiches, pasta or pizza, they have the best food in town!”
Italian · $$
4883 Merrick Road, Massapequa Park · 6.37 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I had my son's wedding rehearsal dinner at Zona last night. I was originally booked to have the party on Saturday, but the bride came down with the flu. Gianna was so helpful and accommodating. She was able to change the date for me without hesitation. The day of the affair, the staff was so helpful in getting the room set up for us. Our waitress, Jodi, was absolutely incredible. She made sure that our guests had a fresh drink before they even realized their drink was empty. The food was delicious and plentiful. But most of all, the service that Jodi provided to us was outstanding. I would book another event at Zona without hesitation.”
Italian · $$$
301 East Main Street, Islip · 7.14 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Service and staff are excellent. The dinners we had tonight were outstanding! Definitely will be returning for another great night out❤️”
Italian · $$
10 West Main Street, Bay Shore · 5.57 miles
“The food is incredible (oh the meats!), the service is fantastic (go have a conversation with Frank or anyone from his team), and there are great options for pastas, desserts and other things.”
Italian · $
877 E Jericho Turnpike, Huntington Station · 8.19 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Can I please give 20 Stars??? The food is amazing The service is amazing Andy is like the guru of this place every time I have yet to get anything here that wasn't other than terrific. On the Butcher items - am I that good a chef? Well according to family and friends yes!! But put that aside if the cuts are junk the result is too A&S Huntington is my go to always - I literally go there 3-4 times a month sometimes more”
Seafood · $$
384 North Wantagh Avenue, Bethpage · 7.48 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Yesterday was the first time I have been to Popei’s. What a great night! From the moment we walked in the owner/chef greeted us. We sat outside in the tent with the great musician. He was very interactive, took requests. People were singing along, It’s was very enjoyable. It was very clear our waitress, Janice was extremely busy but also very thorough careful and caring. It’s obvious she cares about what she is doing and works very hard. Upon my ordering, I mentioned a food allergy Janice double checked that things were OK before she submitted the order. 2 other people came to verify before cooking my meal. The food was SO GOOD! Big portion sizes. Gave my mother dessert to celebrate her birthday. Overall, it was an absolutely fantastic night. We will be back. My only suggestion would be when the musician is taking a break to lower the background music. When he wasn’t singing, the music was still incredibly loud and we had difficulty hearing each other at the table.”
Italian · $$$$
1058 Broadhollow Road, Farmingdale · 3.76 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Note of Appreciation: Luncheon Service Jan 8, 2025 Dear Sean B & Trento Staff, I hope this message finds you well. I wanted to take a moment to express my heartfelt gratitude for the impeccable service and care your entire team provided during the recent funeral of my brother, Steven Blair. On what was undoubtedly a difficult day, your professionalism and attentiveness stood out, creating an environment that allowed our family to come together in remembrance and support. The timeliness of events, while never guaranteed, was handled with such grace and efficiency by your staff, which brought us immense comfort. I would especially like to commend Sean for the exceptional management of the logistics and preparation. The quality of the food and the attention to detail did not go unnoticed, and it sincerely exceeded our expectations. Your efforts contributed greatly to making a solemn occasion feel warm and inviting, allowing us to focus on celebrating Steven's life. Thank you once again for your unwavering commitment to excellence during such a challenging time. We are deeply appreciative of all that you have done. KMB”
Italian · $$
14 Broadhollow Road, Melville · 6.07 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Hubby and I really enjoyed the food. What a great place services was wonderful. The lady who is the host to the waitress. Thank you so much definitely a five star restaurant. The Abbates”
Italian · $$
282 Main Street, Farmingdale · 4.9 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Excellent food and Ashley was an amazing server”
Italian · $$$
1255 Melville Road, Farmingdale · 4.44 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Excelente restaurante, la comida exquisita y muy buen servicio. Lo recomiendo 100%”
Italian · $
30 East Main Street, Babylon · 2.25 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Good food excellent and attentive service generous portions Thank you for a great dining experience”
Italian
300 Main Street, Farmingdale · 4.9 miles
Customers’ favorites
“As a restaurant owner, I never go out and order chicken Parm probably had the best chicken Parm I ever had in my life. The atmosphere is great. The service is great. Just an all-around great place. The food was fantastic. Three times so far to try everything on the menu highly recommended referred by Mr. Michael.”
Italian · $$$
240 West Main Street, Bay Shore · 5.16 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Bella Vie restaurant is such a gem! Wonderful ownership. Mike is amazing and the views are to die for. The food is exquisite. If you haven’t been, it’s a must try on Long Island”
Italian · $$$
970 West Jericho Turnpike, Huntington · 8.59 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Friendly service Excellent food”
Italian · $$
90 West Main Street, Babylon · 2.21 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great food and friendly staff. Deceivingly spacious compared to other similar venues. While prices are really not unusual they could be seen as a bit on the higher side, but the portions are pretty tremendous so could easily be a second mail with take home.”
Pizza · $$
202 Main Street, Farmingdale · 4.94 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We had our wedding Rehearsal Dinner and Welcome party here. It was a great venue. The staff was excellent and Sofia & Olivia was great to work with. They helped us with the floor plan and gave us the best recommendations. We had a great time and everyone raved about the food!”
Italian · $$$
71 Merrick Road, Amityville · 4.73 miles
Customers’ favorites
“good food and good service i like this place alot”
Pizza · $
336 Depot Road, Huntington Station · 8.55 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great pizza and very hospitable! Sincerely, a Jersey girl.”
Una Pizza Napoletana, a popular spot in New York, has just been named the best pizza in the world by the 2024 Italian 50 Top Pizza ranking. This is a major victory for owner Anthony Mangieri, who has already earned the title of best pizza in the U.S. for three years in a row.
Naples-born Rosso Pomodoro has landed in Denver. The Italian pizza franchise just opened its first U.S. location in the city's Central Park neighborhood at 29th Ave Town Center. "It has long been a dream to introduce our brand of authentic Neapolitan-style pizza to every corner of America,” CEO Nicola Saraceno shared his excitement.
Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana, a 100-year-old Coney Island eatery, is looking for a buyer or partner to keep its legacy alive, but it has one important condition. Totonno's has made it through fires, floods, and even COVID, but there's one thing they'll never tolerate: pineapple on their pizza.