19 Best Italian Restaurants in Farmingdale

“At Vico, guests are warmly welcomed by friendly staff, including the owner. The restaurant offers a taste of the Amalfi coast with delicious pizza and croquet. Although the gnocchi sorrento could use more seasoning, the ingredients shine through. With attentive service and great advice on ordering, diners can enjoy a relaxed dining experience for any occasion.“

“Trento is a fantastic restaurant that never disappoints. The staff is great, the food is excellent, and it's perfect for a business lunch or time with family and friends. One standout server, Leo, adds an extra layer of enjoyment with his humor and excellent service. The food and drinks are amazing, and the overall experience is top-notch. Highly recommended for anyone visiting the area.“

“Absolutely Mario Italian Restaurant offers excellent service, a welcoming family ambiance, and stellar food. The staff is lovely, accommodating, and efficient, making it a great spot for events. The menu features dishes like Veal Sorrentino, and be sure to save room for dessert. Prices are reasonable, making it a great value for a delicious meal.“

“Laviletta Restaurant is an old-school Italian establishment offering a classic menu and exceptional service. The food is a highlight, with standout dishes including spaghetti with seafood, penne a la vodka, and shrimp Parmesan. While the mozzarella sticks were a slight letdown, the pistachio ricotta cake was a heavenly dessert option. The restaurant is a hidden gem, providing authentic Italian food at reasonable prices. Overall, Laviletta Restaurant delivers a delightful dining experience, earning high praise from its visitors.“

“La Villetta is a cozy restaurant with great service and delicious food. The Veal Sorrento and Chic Scaprilla are excellent choices. The atmosphere is always friendly and welcoming. The prix fixe lunch menu offers a great value at $21 for three courses. The Cabernet wine is very good, and the complimentary bruschetta is a nice touch. The Caesar salad is creamy and tasty, and the veal with Fontina cheese is delicious. The professional service adds to the upscale Italian dining experience. The restaurant is a bit loud when busy, and service can be slow during peak times, but overall, La Villetta is a great find with fair prices and a classy touch.“

“Nunzi’s offers amazing food and atmosphere. The spicy rigatoni is a highlight, along with other menu items like pizza, calamari, and tacos. The service is attentive, with special mention to Naz for exceptional service. The bar area and dining room provide a gorgeous ambiance. While there might be a wait for a table, the experience and food make it worth it. Overall, Nunzi’s is a top choice for a delicious meal and great drinks, with a welcoming and accommodating staff. Highly recommended for a memorable dining experience.“

“I was at 711 in Lindenhurst and the owner of kickn chicken was extremely drunk and being very racist towards me and my friend.. we were speaking in our native language Polish.. and he started saying you fn Russian need to leave and wanted to fight me..his girlfriend was extremely embarrassed of his actions. she had her head down... I wouldn't give this man any business.“

“Vespa Italian Kitchen & Bar is a popular spot for groups, with good appetizers and drinks. While dinners were just okay for some, others enjoyed the great food and attentive service. The bartender makes amazing cocktails, and the salmon is cooked perfectly. Sitting at the bar is recommended for excellent service and food recommendations.“

“Dalers Pizza Parlor, now known as Gino's, offers great food and fast, friendly service in a casual family-style atmosphere. The hot honey pepperoni pizza is a standout, and the thin-crust pizza is a local favorite. Though the parking machine can be difficult to see, this classic establishment is a must-try.“

“Tre Scalini Italian Restaurant offers a pleasant atmosphere and attentive service. The menu features delectable dishes such as risotto with shrimp and shrimp oreganata, which diners praise for their authenticity and generous portions. Reservations are easily made, and the prices are considered reasonable, making this establishment a gem for Italian food enthusiasts.“

“Rosemarie's Pizzeria & Restaurant is a cozy spot where you can enjoy some delicious food. The workers are very nice and accommodating, creating a great atmosphere for diners. The parking situation is convenient, and the restaurant is kid-friendly with a good environment. Wheelchair accessibility is also not an issue, with staff treating all customers with care and respect. Whether dining in or taking out, the food is always outstanding, with dishes like penne shrimp and asparagus and broccoli bites standing out as must-tries. With friendly and helpful staff like Gianna, a visit to Rosemarie's is sure to leave you satisfied and coming back for more.“

“Verona Ristorante offers a wonderful dining experience with great food and the option of live music and singing, particularly by Louis Del Prete. While service can be hit or miss, the restaurant is worth visiting for the delicious food and holiday decorations. However, be aware of potential billing issues.“

“Papa's Pizza is a welcoming pizzeria known for its excellent service and delicious food. Popular menu items include the meatball hero, vodka slice, Sicilian, chicken bacon ranch slices, chicken francese, and chicken parm dinners. They offer numerous vegetarian options and are highly regarded for their kitchen fare and pizza on Long Island.“

“Talluci's Pizzeria is a hidden gem that serves delicious pizzas with a focus on quality ingredients. The calzones are amazing, and the eggplant parmigiana is a hit. The pizzas have a crispy crust and super tasty flavors, especially the sauce. The Buffalo Chicken and deep dish pepperoni are standout options.“

“Vincent's Pizza is a family favorite, offering a variety of delicious options like Tortellini Broccoli in Brodo Soup and Eggplant Parmigiana Pizza Pie. With plenty of parking available in a big strip mall, it's convenient for all. The restaurant is kid-friendly, with tasty, sizable portions. Vegetarian options are plentiful, including vegetarian pasta and a fantastic vegetarian pizza. The grandma pie is a standout, with sweet sauce and a perfectly crisp crust. Vincent's is a real Italian pizzeria, highly recommended for its consistently good food at great prices. The wheelchair-accessible entrance adds to the restaurant's accessibility.“

“Bellagio Pizzeria Restaurant & Catering is a welcoming spot for pizza enthusiasts, offering a variety of halal options. The staff ensures the halal status of their chicken and even provides halal pepperoni. With reasonable prices and a diverse menu, it's a great choice for the Muslim community. Customers enjoy the fresh salads, flavorful pizzas with generous toppings, and delicious cannoli. The restaurant is kid-friendly and has been a favorite for years.“

“3 Brothers Pizza Cafe is a restaurant that offers a wide variety of vegan options, making it a favorite spot for vegan diners on Long Island. The restaurant provides hot and fresh bread, which can be taken home and reheated for a delicious snack. The large party menu includes pizzas, soup, salads, and desserts, with the vegan tiramisu and cannoli being particular highlights. The bruschetta is praised for its freshness and flavor. The restaurant's staff is commended for their attentiveness and helpfulness, especially when handling large parties. The portion sizes are generous, and the restaurant is conveniently located in Farmingdale.“

“Piazzetta Of East Farmingdale is a highly-recommended restaurant serving delicious food, with highlights including their fried calamari Siciliano and fresh, high-quality pizza made with quality ingredients. Prices may be a bit high, and service can be inconsistent, but the pizza is solid and well-cooked. Specialty slices, such as the chicken Caesar salad and sweet chili, are also standout options.“

“Farmingdale Pizza & Pasta is a restaurant known for its vegan and vegetarian-friendly options. The staff is friendly and helpful, providing excellent service to customers. The menu includes a variety of Italian dishes made vegan, such as eggplant rollatini, stuffed shells, and mozzarella sticks. The cashew ricotta and oyster mushroom calamari are particularly impressive. For dessert, the death by chocolate cake is a standout. The restaurant also offers vegan Buffalo wings and a vegan Buffalo chicken pizza that are popular among vegans and non-vegans alike. The restaurant has a cozy atmosphere, reminiscent of a classic Italian restaurant, and offers a separate menu for vegan and non-vegan options. While parking can be challenging, the food and service make it worth the visit. Customers can dine in or take out, and many return frequently due to the high-quality food and welcoming environment.“