Italian Restaurants near Wantagh

1
Toto's

Toto's Steak House • $$$
3275 Byron St, Wantagh

Customers` Favorites

Prime Steak and Sides
American Cheesecake
Mussels Marinara
Grilled Octopus
Creamed Spinach
Mashed Potatoes
Caprese Salad
Broccoli Rabe
Caesar Salad
Carrot Cake

“Here to celebrate a birthday. What a hidden gem! The ambiance was beautiful and intimate, the food absolutely delicious and the service was attentive without being intrusive. Everyone was sooo nice. Although we were the last ones to leave on a Thursday evening we were never pressured in any way. Thank you for a lovely evening. We will definitely be back!“

4.6 Superb127 Reviews
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings Pizza • $$
3430 Sunrise Hwy, Wantagh

Customers` Favorites

Coal Oven Roasted Chicken Wings
Sausage and Broccoli Rabe Pizza
Lunch Size Specialty Pizza
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage
Small Margherita Pizza
Roasted Cauliflower
Grill Chicken Wings
And Meatballs
Eggplant Pizza
Garlic Knots

“Always enjoy their specials! Pizza has been consistently good and prepared perfect! Salad is always good and fresh, love that the house salad has celery, and eggs too!!This location is my favorite! Servers are nice and fast and listen to the customer! Jeff isa great waiter very nice guy too“

3.9 Good65 Reviews
Umberto's Restaurant & Pizzeria Pizza • $$
1180 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Marsala
Sicilian Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Buffalo Slice
Caesar Salad
Cheese Pizza
White Pizza
Deep Dish
Marinara

“Just went there today with some coworkers for sit down lunch in the back. It was clean and looked very nice. Our waiter was super friendly and brought us water and bread and some garlic knots!!! We had fried calamari which was light and crispy, mozzarella sticks (cheese was soft and melted on the inside) and the bruschetta (fresh and tasted ok). I ordered the chicken marsala which was very tasty. Several people ordered salads which looked very large and good as well. Definitely would consider returning with my family one day when we're craving Italian“

3.8 Good95 Reviews
Per Un Angelo Bar • $$
3275 Byron St, Wantagh

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Salmon

“We arrived at this place for lunch. This place was recommended to us by a friend. Well, it was very nice. we were warmly welcomed by the staff and we felt good. The meal was great. We had a great time and we shall definitely come back again. We recommend this place to all.“

3.5 Good2 Reviews
Prince Umberto Pizzeria Pizza • $
1910 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Knots
Regular
Pie

“Excellent local pizza/italian food . Take out or table service available . Casual vibe . The servers and bartenders are friendly and happy to offer suggestions . My favorite hero's are meatball parmigiana and potatoe , peppers and egg. My mom always made potatoe peppers and eggs , Umbertos tastes like home. Try it !“

3.6 Good13 Reviews
Phil's Pizzeria & Restaurant Pizza • $
1378 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh

Customers` Favorites

Sicilian Slice
Pie

“I ordered a pizza for delivery and they forgot to put the plastic structure on top of the pie. The delivery guy put the soda on top of the box causing it to cave in. All the cheese got stuck to the top of the box. I’ve complained about this before but apparently it fell on deaf ears.“

3.3 Good36 Reviews
Pietro's of East Meadow Pizza • $$
476 E Meadow Ave, East Meadow

Customers` Favorites

Pietro's 9 Inch Round Sicilian Pizza
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
Pistachio Ricotta Cake
Sweet Chili Calamari
Rigatoni Alla Vodka
Drunken Shrimp Parm
Extra Cheese Pizza
Nutella Empanadas
Stuffed Artichoke
Margherita Pizza

“(Edited my og review because it was poorly written and rushed.)So there I was, on a spontaneous adventure, when suddenly, BAM! Google throws me a curveball - "Nutella Empanada." You bet I was intrigued. It was like the universe daring me, "Bet, let's go."Stumble into this place, and it's like I've walked into the heart of the local scene. This guy, just oozing neighborhood vibes, hits me with, "You're not from around here, huh? Welcome to the best Italian spot in town." And he didn't stop there - gave me the lowdown on all the hidden gems nearby. This dude was living and breathing local charm, and I was here for it. The lobby? Packed with the coolest cats you could meet.Turns out, snagging a table at this joint is usually like finding a unicorn - pretty darn rare. But guess what? They worked some magic and got us in... into an outdoor igloo, no less! Yeah, you read that right. An igloo! (Peep the pics for proof - it's as rad as it sounds.)Now, let's talk food. Holy smokes, it's delish. The staff? Angels in disguise, I swear. Super friendly, on-point, and ready to make your experience top-notch.Oh, and if you see anything with Vodka sauce on the menu, just do yourself a favor and order it. It's a solid 10/10. Trust.All in all, this spot isn't just a restaurant; it's a local legend. Do yourself a favor and drop by. You won't regret it.“

4.6 Superb310 Reviews
Chris & Tony’s Italian • $$$
352 Jericho Turnpike, Syosset

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Brownie with Vanilla Ice Cream
Shrimp Luciano over Spinach
Heroine Calamari Fritti
Skirt Steak with Fries
Chris & Tony's Salad
Eggplant Rollatini
Chicken Parmigiana
Stuffed Artichoke
Veal Parmigiana
Chicken Marsala

“Saturday evening dinner without a reservation. Walking in, my eyes immediately gravitated to the pictures of the owners and the many celebrities that have eaten and visited there before. The bar area is very nice and large, with TVs playing sports and news. We were greeted, welcomed and seated immediately. The dining area is very large and decorous. The tables large enough to sit us all. My cousin-in-law and his family frequent the restaurant and he practically knows everyone there, so as we sat, we were introduced to the owners and pretty much about a half dozen waiters and other staff members. All were extremely friendly and welcoming. As expected with all family style restaurants, the tables are very close to one another but positioned in a way that still allowed for ample space for you to move and sit comfortably. When we sat, there were hardly any people there, but within an hour it was full of patrons and large families. It was loud, but manageable. The food was unbelievably delicious. I haven't had true traditional family style Italian food in a long time. From the Fried Calamari and cold antipasto appetizers, to our Veal Parmigiana, Penne allá Vodka with Shrimp and prosciutto entrees. Paired with a Cabernet Sauvignon Palermo Napa, I truly enjoyed my meal. I haven't enjoyed food this good in a long time. My girls shared a huge plate of Chicken fingers and fries, and they loved it. I highly recommend anyone who's in the area to dine here. You won't regret it. Thank you for a great meal and patronage.“

4.7 Superb135 Reviews
Popei's Clam Bar Seafood • $$
384 N Wantagh Ave, Bethpage

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Tail & Shrimp Ala Vodka
Broiled Combination Platter
Grecian Stuffed Lobster
Mozzarella Garlic Bread
All You Can Eat Shrimp
Stuffed Maine Lobster
Chicken Parmigiana
Blue Point Oysters
Bucket of Mussels
Stuffed Mushrooms

“Very good food at Popei's starting with their garlic+ bread. I had the lobster and shrimp stuffed penne in vodka sauce - hearty, tender, perfectly cooked seafood without that rubbery feeling in a fantastically creamy sauce. I sliced my stuffed penne into diagonal strips and every bite was amazing. Others had the crab leg and steak special; crab wasn't as good as my shrimp and lobster being a little over-boiled perhaps but the skirt steak had great flavor and chew. Most entrées hovered around $30. Would absolutely return.Note they have valet parking due to its popularity and limited parking space - so bring some small bills.“

4.7 Superb135 Reviews
Flora’s Pizza Cafe Pizza •
637 Jericho Turnpike, Syosset

Customers` Favorites

Pappardelle Alla Bolognese
Roasted Mixed Vegetables
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Honey Pepperoni Pizza
Chocolate Ice Cream
Pellegrino Limonata
Pistachio Gelato
Chocolate Gelato
Luna Bianca Pizza
Margherita Pizza

“We hosted our daughter's first birthday here with 40 people on a Sunday afternoon. Working with Ervis and Gabriella was fantastic -- great communication and very flexible. The event turned out better than we could have expected. The food is AMAZING. Everybody is still raving about it and a few of our family members have already been back! Would definitely recommend hosting a small event here!“

4.8 Superb85 Reviews
Loading...
map Map