8 Best Ice Cream Shops in Bay Shore

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Ice Cream Shops in Bay Shore.

Showing 8 of 28 restaurants

  • Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream 75 Howells Road, Bay Shore Ice Cream Shop · $$

    1 Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream

    4.5 Superb 246 Reviews

    75 Howells Road, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Peanut Butter Fudge Chunk
    • Waffle Bowl Sundae
    • Mint Oreo Cookie
    • Monster Crunch

    “Best ice cream I ever had visited from NC!”

  • Ralphs Italian Ices of Bayshore 71 East Main Street, Bay Shore Ice Cream Shop · $

    2 Ralphs Italian Ices of Bayshore

    4.5 Superb 104 Reviews

    71 East Main Street, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Peanut Butter Doughnado
    • Birthday Cake Doughnado
    • Small Ice Cream 6 Oz
    • Straw Banana Mango

    “Always love going to Ralph’s. It’s my favorite dessert shop when I want something light. Been going here for over a decade. Glad it’s still around even after so long. I usually get the strawberry, cotton candy, or recently the green apple flavor! The large is more than enough but medium is perfectly fine.”

  • Carvel 188 Howells Road, Bay Shore Ice Cream Shop · $

    3 Carvel

    4.3 Superb 85 Reviews

    188 Howells Road, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery
    • Drive-Through

    Customers’ favorites

    • Soft Serve Ice Cream
    • Ice Cream Sundae
    • Birthday Cake

    “Went to get some ice-cream after dinner. The staff greeted us as we walked in the door. They were quick and efficient. They double checked that certain ice-cream were okay to have with my food allergy. They have a freezer full of premade ice-creams and cakes or you can pick from different size cones or cups. They have different flavors of soft serve or hard ice-cream and many different toppings to choose from. They don't have any seating so we had to take it to go. I was so intent on eating my ice-cream I forgot to take pictures.”

  • Baskin-Robbins 529 East Main Street, Bay Shore Ice Cream Shop · $

    4 Baskin-Robbins

    3.8 Good 17 Reviews

    529 East Main Street, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “Visited at almost midnight for an after dinner desert and the employee was very nice!! I feel bad bc it’s a 24/7 Baskin Robins, I can’t imagine working these hours for just ice cream… she doesn’t deserve that :( regardless, Ice cream was very affordable and tasty! Thank you”

  • Sweet Licks 181 Bayview Walk, Cherry Grove Ice Cream Shop · $

    5 Sweet Licks

    3.6 Good 52 Reviews

    181 Bayview Walk, Cherry Grove

    • Take-Out

    “I love this place. The young woman who worked there was so sweet and wonderful and the ambiance is so zen. I had the caramel peanut butter ice cream and it was freaking amazing. I come here every year and love that they added cute merchandise like tshirts and hoodies this year!!”

  • Baskin-Robbins 19 Bay Shore Road, Bay Shore Ice Cream Shop · $

    6 Baskin-Robbins

    3.6 Good 16 Reviews

    19 Bay Shore Road, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery
  • Baskin-Robbins 1261 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore Ice Cream Shop · $

    7 Baskin-Robbins

    3.0 Average 19 Reviews

    1261 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “I visited this location tonight and Walter was so friendly and seemed genuinely happy with his job. He explained that every Tuesday Baskin Robbins offers buy one get one free, offered me samples when I asked his opinion on a flavor, and was overall very pleasant. It's not often that I leave a review, especially for a chain, but I just appreciated his service that much.”

Ice Cream Shops Nearby

You May Also Like

  • 10 Weirdest Ice Cream Flavors Worth Trying

    10 Weirdest Ice Cream Flavors Worth Trying

    Ice cream has always been a beloved treat, offering a wide array of flavors that cater to every taste. Lately, however, the spotlight has shifted to more unconventional flavors, making classic choices like vanilla and chocolate seem ordinary. From ketchup to oysters, here are ten of the most unusual ice cream flavors to try.

  • Chicago's Rainbow Cone Goes National After 98 Years

    Chicago's Rainbow Cone Goes National After 98 Years

    Rainbow Cone, a Chicago ice cream shop, is spreading its colorful layers across the country for the first time in its 98-year history. The shop is known for its unique five-flavor ice cream cone, which stacks chocolate, strawberry, Palmer House, pistachio, and orange sherbet in colorful "slices." Since announcing franchising two years ago, Rainbow Cone has grown to 21 locations, mostly around Chicago, but they're not stopping there. They've also opened a store in Indiana and recently made a deal to open 10 spots in Texas.