Explore Bay Shore's Mexican food scene with our favorite restaurants.
Mexican · $
1654 5th Avenue, Bay Shore
Customers’ favorites
“10/10! 😍 The food was absolutely delicious, fresh, hot, and full of flavor! Everything was seasoned perfectly, the portions were great, and the service was amazing. Definitely one of the best Mexican food spots I’ve tried in a while. I’ll absolutely be coming back!”
Mexican · $$$
49 West Main Street, Bay Shore
Customers’ favorites
“excelente servicio...la comida riquísima....ambiente muy cálido...buena música. en fin todo es excelente”
Mexican · $
331 East Main Street, Bay Shore
Customers’ favorites
“This place is absolutely amazing!!!!! Jim the manager was such a nice guy and made me feel so welcomed. The food is absolutely delicious!!!!!! 10/10 recommend! The store is very clean and professional! All employees here deserve a pat on the back for making this experience so perfect! Thanks again!!”
Mexican · $$
70 East Main Street, Bay Shore
Customers’ favorites
“Amazing food great service”
American · $$
999 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore
Customers’ favorites
“There are diners and there is Peter Pan in Bay Shore at a level of great heights. My wife and I patiently waited for its reopening and our expectations were above and beyond what we expected. The decor is modern and beautiful, yet it has that warm at-home feel. The Menu consists of a variation of eclectic items that greatly touches the culinary senses with delight. Owners Nick and Peter are often present to greet the customers like old friends and the staff are very friendly, professional and thorough. From breakfast to lunch and dinner we have always enjoyed. And to boot, there is wide variety of beverages to meet all tastes. Thank you for being a part of of our lives, Peter Pan. Looking forward to partaking in your delicious meals for years to come!”
Mexican · $
2042 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore
Customers’ favorites
“Checked them out today. I tried the steak taco...it was absolutely delicious ! Staff was friendly, restaurant is clean everything's was fresh . Definitely worth checking out”
Burrito · $$
631 East Main Street, Bay Shore
Customers’ favorites
“Best burritos and quesadillas I’ve had around the island. Always consistently delicious. However, tonight as I bit into my steak and fajita burrito, I thought I cracked my tooth on something. Was able to spit out what looks like a hard piece of plastic that broke off of something. Be extra cautious when preparing all your food please”
Deli · $
147 East Main Street, Bay Shore
“Tacos de birria, delicious 😋 I order 3 tacos good price good flavor.”
Fast Food · $
490 East Main Street, Bay Shore
Customers’ favorites
“It's a newly remodeled place looks very nice. Placed our order on the touch computer was easy to use and paid for with debit card. The wait for the food was a little long for 2:30 in the afternoon. Food was cook properly and hot tasted good too. Parking: New parking lot. It now has a double drive through to service cars faster I assume. Kid-friendliness: What kid doesn't like Taco's at Taco Bell. Wheelchair accessibility: Has handicap ♿ parking. Not sure how many spots didn't count them.”
El Pollo Loco is betting that loyalty members want more than discounts. The fire-grilled chicken chain rolled out a refreshed Loco Rewards program earlier this year, pairing exclusive experiences with app-driven promotions as part of a broader turnaround that's already delivering results. The centerpiece of the relaunch: a partnership with Coca-Cola for a "soccer challenge" giving members a shot at a VIP trip to the 2026 Major League Soccer All-Star Game in Charlotte, N.C., on July 29. The grand prize includes two game tickets, hotel accommodations, flight vouchers, and a $300 Visa gift card. A hundred runner-up winners each receive a $25 El Pollo Loco gift card.
Qdoba Mexican Eats is speeding up its growth across the nation, adding 33 new locations to its plans and bringing total restaurant commitments to more than 500 across the United States. The fast-casual Mexican chain is growing through key franchise partnerships in many regions. In the Northeast, PFGS, LLC will build 15 locations across Springfield, Mass., and Hartford, Conn. Meanwhile, Empire Inc. has agreed to open 10 restaurants in the Columbus, Ohio area, using their experience running over 100 restaurants including Subway and Dunkin' stores.