9 Best Mexican Restaurants in Bay Shore

Explore Bay Shore's Mexican food scene with our favorite restaurants.

Taquero mucho Mexican • $
1654 5th Ave, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Birria Tacos with Salsa and Lime
Quesadilla Steak Carne Asada
Tortas Sausage Chorizo
Taco Steak Carne Asada
Chicken Quesadilla
Beef Tongue Lengua
Steak Quesadillas
Mulitas Sausage
Side Guacamole
Al Pastor Taco

“I ordered from this place thinking it would be a one-time thing, and I was definitely wrong. This spot has, by far, the best tacos, bowls, Nachos and burritos I’ve ever tasted. Everything was packed with care, and the service was fast and friendly when I went to pay.
They do not have a place to sit and eat since it's a food truck not sure if they do in the summer time

Tip: Paying cash is cheaper than using a credit card since the card fees are added to your order. They do take Mastercard visa and Amex“

4.9 Superb128 Reviews
Pecado Mexican Mexican • $$$
49 W Main St, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Mexican Chocolate Pavlova
Coconut Tres Leches
Enchiladas De Mole
Chicken Quesadilla
Tostada De Ceviche
Tamal De Carnitas
Enchiladas Suizas
Tres Leches Cake
Huevos Benedict
Churros Waffle

“excelente servicio...la comida riquísima....ambiente muy cálido...buena música. en fin todo es excelente“

4.5 Superb372 Reviews
QDOBA Mexican Eats Mexican • $
331 E Main St, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Burritos Burrito Bowls
Side of Brown Rice
Chips & Guacamole
Tortilla Chips
Burritos Bowls
Chicken Bowl
Quesadilla
Vegetarian
Salad
Taco

“This place is absolutely amazing!!!!! Jim the manager was such a nice guy and made me feel so welcomed. The food is absolutely delicious!!!!!! 10/10 recommend! The store is very clean and professional! All employees here deserve a pat on the back for making this experience so perfect! Thanks again!!“

4.5 Superb103 Reviews
Verde Kitchen & Cocktails Mexican • $$
70 E Main St, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Seared Blackened Scallops MP
Tortillas and Toppings
Mexican Street Corn
Chips \u0026 Salsa
Taco Barbacoa Taco
Bandeja De Tacos
Pineapple Coconut
Pollo Mole Rojo
Chicken Flautas
Barbacoa Tacos

“Amazing food great service“

4.3 Superb163 Reviews
Tacos Guacamole Mexican • $
2042 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Quesadilla
Tropical Chicken Burrito
Chile Habanero Hot Sauce
Shredded Chicken Salad
Spicy Shrimp Burrito
Regular Quesadilla
Shrimp Quesadilla
Pollo Con Tajadas
Chips & Salsa
Latin Burrito

“Checked them out today. I tried the steak taco...it was absolutely delicious ! Staff was friendly, restaurant is clean everything's was fresh . Definitely worth checking out“

4 Good84 Reviews
Peter Pan Diner American • $$
999 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Western Omelet with Home Fries
The Breakfast Cheese Scramble
Black Forrest Cake Slice
Apple Cinnamon Pancakes
Chicken Noodle Soup
Sweet Potato Fries
Blueberry Pancakes
Grilled Cheese
Belgian Waffle
Chocolate Chip

“Today I came to visit and have a quick bite! The burger was phenomenal! And what made the burger even better was the outstanding service from Thomas! His energy and attentiveness makes me want to come back! I live in Huntington but would come back just for the service alone! Thank you Peter Pan for a great early dinner!“

4.4 Superb149 Reviews
Bang Bang Burritos Burrito • $
631 E Main St, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Specialty Taco
Chicken Buffarito Bowl
Guacamole
Jarritos
Chips

“Such lovely service! My first time coming here last night. I was in the mood for a burrito and I most certainly picked the right spot! It was clean and the service was impeccable! I ordered the all American burrito and it was so delicious and the steak was so tender. They even gave us a complimentary empanada which was so delicious. When I go back I will definitely be ordering a bunch of those. Thank you for a lovely experience, amazing customer service and food :)“

4.4 Superb66 Reviews
Deli La Bendicion Deli • $
147 E Main St, Bay Shore

“Tacos de birria, delicious 😋 I order 3 tacos good price good flavor.“

4.1 Good28 Reviews
Taco Bell Fast Food • $
490 E Main St, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Chips and Nacho Cheese Sauce
Ground Beef Burrito
Chicken Quesadilla
Nachos Bellgrande
Grilled Cheese
Mexican Pizza
Soft Taco
Taco Bell

“It's a newly remodeled place looks very nice. Placed our order on the touch computer was easy to use and paid for with debit card. The wait for the food was a little long for 2:30 in the afternoon. Food was cook properly and hot tasted good too.

Parking: New parking lot. It now has a double drive through to service cars faster I assume.

Kid-friendliness: What kid doesn't like Taco's at Taco Bell.

Wheelchair accessibility: Has handicap ♿ parking. Not sure how many spots didn't count them.“

3.1 Average99 Reviews

You May Also Like