Restaurants in West Islip

Classico Pizzeria 5 Udall Rd, West Islip Pizza • $
5 Udall Rd, West Islip

Customers` Favorites

Peppers
Garlic Knots
Grandma Pie
Chicken Francese
Vodka Sauce
Grandma Pizza
White Pizza
Classico Hero
Grilled Chicken
Tricolor Grandma Slice

“I've only order twice from here so far but, I will say the food that I ordered was great! I can't say much for atmosphere or service because it was quick takeout transactions, not much to base an opinion from. I will say the place appeared to be clean and inviting. On Valentine's Day I ordered a heart shaped cheese pie for the kids and they loved it. Pizza had great flavor, quality cheese as well. Garlic knots were perfect with a ton of flavor. We ordered a couple of vodka slices and I will say certainly the best vodka slice I've had yet ! They have a bunch of other pies that look not only interesting but delicious. Check out the website and social media pages to see the line up, they even have personal pies! This review was not paid for, I don't know them, I'm not affiliated in any way. Just go try the pizza it speaks for itself!”

4.6 Superb49 Reviews
Primi Italian Steakhouse 999 Montauk Hwy, West Islip Italian • $$$
999 Montauk Hwy, West Islip

Customers` Favorites

Steak
Beef Wellington
Grilled Octopus
Cheesecake
Calamari
Creamed Spinach
Tiramisu
Chicken Francese
Clams Oreganata
Porterhouse for Two

“Our Valentine's Day dinner at Primi Italian Steakhouse was exceptional. The eggplant rollatini and clams oreganata appetizers were flavorful starters to our meal. The porterhouse steak for two was divine, paired with creamy mashed potatoes and crisp broccoli. Service was outstanding, making our experience memorable. Everything was so good we returned a few days later for drinks. Highly recommend for a special occasion, but coming for dinner for no occasion is excellent as well!Parking: The parking at Primi is valet. Make sure you bring a few dollars to tip.”

4.3 Superb186 Reviews
Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta 636 Union Blvd #3113, West Islip European • $$
636 Union Blvd #3113, West Islip

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Knots
Mac
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Chicken Parmigiana
Margarita Pizza
Chicken Parm Slice
Slice of Pizza
Baked Ziti
Meatball
Grandma

“This was my first eatery I tried when stopping in Bay Shore for work. I ended up going here a lot. The options are great and it's quick and easy. If it isn't broke, don't fix it.”

4.4 Superb67 Reviews
Farrell's of Brooklyn 263 Higbie Ln, West Islip Bar & Grill • $$
263 Higbie Ln, West Islip

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Pot Pie
Zucchini Sticks with Cajun Mayo
Nachos Grande
Onion Rings

“The food was amazing, the bartender himself took the tip from our change lying next to the drinks... he gave it back because we pointed it out to him. The atmosphere was ok... there was a live band playing... it was nice to listen and dance a ”

4.4 Superb64 Reviews
Chiddy's Cheesesteaks of West Islip 510 Union Blvd, West Islip Fast Food • $
510 Union Blvd, West Islip

Customers` Favorites

Chiddy
Tacos
Onion Rings
Homemade Empanadas
Cheesesteak Fries

“"This meal was a real surprise. The presentation was beautiful and the taste was incredible. The main course was very tasty and the cheese was divine. Overall, an exceptional meal that I will definitely order again. Recommended!"”

4.4 Superb61 Reviews
1683 Sports Bar & Grille 401 Sunrise Hwy, West Islip Bar & Grill
401 Sunrise Hwy, West Islip

Customers` Favorites

Burger
Sunrise Chicken Salad
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Wings
French Fries
1683 Nachos
Baked Clams
Steak Toast

“Came in for an open jam session, first time here. Haven’t been here in years. This place has changed so much for the better! Comfortable, almost homey vibe. Great fresh tasting food, and drinks. Amazing service as well. We were always checked on by staff. They have a cocktail menu too. Just wish they had a larger variety of wine, but spoke with maybe the manager/owner and he said he will be adding that as he is finishing renovations. Will definitely be back!”

4.6 Superb29 Reviews
Besito Mexican Restaurant 399 Montauk Hwy, West Islip Mexican • $$
399 Montauk Hwy, West Islip

Customers` Favorites

Skirt Steak
Tortilla Soup
Sonora Ribs
Enchilada Mixtas
Street Corn
Rice and Beans
Queso Fundido
Besito's Famous Guacamole - Fresh & Made-To-Order
Grilled Chicken Quesadilla
Tableside Guacamole

“Came here for my birthday and was pleasantly surprised. I have to say our servers Christian and Ivan were amazing and so personable. We enjoyed the food from appetizer to dessert! Highly recommend very nice ambiance to enjoy a beautiful meal with your loved ones.”

4.2 Good161 Reviews
Brownstones Coffee West Islip 306 Union Blvd, West Islip Breakfast • $$
306 Union Blvd, West Islip

Customers` Favorites

French Toast Bites
Potatoes
Crepes
Sausage
Chicken and Waffles
Breakfast Burrito
Home Fries
Traditional French Toast
Cinnamon Swirl Pancakes
Chocolate Mocha Latte

“Here's the Scoop!: Came for breakfast with my husband and son. Upon arriving it was packed as usual. Many customers were waiting in there cars to be called. The hostess said there was about 30 minute wait. So we stayed. Customers were constantly coming in. That's a sure sign that the food is delicious. This is the first time that I was at this location. The hostess was friendly and the seating was definitely different from the other location in the Centereach area. There's a small waiting area with a bench to the right as you enter that will hold 3 people. Service is quick once you're seated and your food is delivered very hot. I ordered the fratata with English muffin and potatoes. My husband and son ordered the big breakfast that came with eggs, sausage, bacon and pancakes. I also had a glass of orange juice. We enjoyed our breakfast immensely. It was simply delicious! I know for sure we'll come here again. If you haven't gone to a Brownstones yet my fellow Yelpers please do! You won't be sorry!”

4.3 Superb72 Reviews
Secatogue Brewing Company 375 Union Blvd, West Islip Brewery • $$
375 Union Blvd, West Islip

“Love the variety of drinks here. Nice vibe, not too loud, and they have food trucks here which is a nice touch! Sports on tv. Would deff come here for music bingo. I absolutely love the drink names here !”

4.5 Superb23 Reviews
Chuck E. Cheese 155 Sunrise Hwy, West Islip Pizza • $
155 Sunrise Hwy, West Islip

Customers` Favorites

Salad Bar
Pizza De Pepperoni

“I like the place, the people who run it are friendly, the guy who cleans is very kind, I asked him after eating the first kiss if he could clean the table so I could continue in the place and he was ”

4.2 Good52 Reviews
Best Kitchen 787 Udall Rd, West Islip Chinese • $
787 Udall Rd, West Islip

“Went there one evening for take out, was very pleased with the food. We tried other choices and have not been disappointed. The meals are fresh and taste . I recommend ? ?”

4.3 Superb33 Reviews
House Of Juice 187 Sunrise Hwy Suite C, West Islip Juice
187 Sunrise Hwy Suite C, West Islip

Customers` Favorites

Acai Bowl
Avocado Toast
Pesto
Peanut Butter Banana
Chicken Caesar
Green Veggies
Celery Juice
The Cure

“This place has the best açaí bowls around! The staff is always friendly and helpful. The bowls are always made the exact same way. My kids also love the açaí bowls that I have to get them their own bowl, otherwise there devour mine. The inside is always so clean. I highly recommend this place.”

4.3 Superb25 Reviews
iDelizia 793 Udall Rd, West Islip Deli • $
793 Udall Rd, West Islip

“This is my favorite deli! I like over-hard eggs and many other delis mess it up and give me over-easy. This deli never messes up my order and the staff are always kind and welcoming”

4.1 Good34 Reviews
Hometown Heroes 240 Higbie Ln, West Islip Sandwich Shop • $$
240 Higbie Ln, West Islip

Customers` Favorites

Sandwich
Chicken Cutlets
Italian Hero
Mac Attack
Chicken Tenders
Waffle Fries
Greek Salad
Manhattan Roast Beef with Mozzarella on Garlic Bread
Classic Hot Pastrami Hero
Italian with the Works

“Amazing heroes! I was so blown away how good they are, I’m glad I found a good hero place here in the islip area where I’m close by to, most good hero spots I have to travel throughout Suffolk county, i highly recommend hometown heroes most especially the Mac Attack or Good Sam hero’s!! Will be back again!”

4 Good53 Reviews
Bella Cucina 424 Montauk Hwy, West Islip Pizza • $$
424 Montauk Hwy, West Islip

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Knots
Alla Vodka
Mozzarella Sticks
Regular Slice
Cheese Pizza
Cannoli

“Bella Cucina is our favorite pizzeria...And we are pizza lovers with many choices in the area. The owners are amazing.They are super welcoming and treat everyone like family. We highly recommend !”

4 Good39 Reviews
map Map