Browse menus, reviews and photos of Delis near West Islip.
Deli · $
434 Montauk Highway, West Islip
Customers’ favorites
“Great people, good food. The chicken wings are amazing! Chicken cutlets too. Recommend stopping by and seeing Jay or Vinnie -- they rock.”
Deli
793 Udall Road, West Islip
“I’m writing this review because places like this genuinely deserve recognition, and I want more people to support a business that clearly cares about its customers. For about a year now, I’ve been going to the West Islip library to study (I’m a student at Suffolk County Community College). I live in Deer Park, and the Deer Park library just doesn’t compare—it’s not a great environment. West Islip is quiet, comfortable, and actually lets me focus. On the way there, I’ve passed this deli countless times and never bothered going in. A couple months ago, I noticed they had burgers on the sign, which made me think they probably had more variety than just typical deli sandwiches. Today, after class, I was craving a bacon, egg, and cheese and decided—on a whim at a red light—to finally stop in instead of going somewhere else. Right away, I could tell this place was different. They had CALPICO and RAMUNE in multiple flavors, plus a variety of ramen and Asian snacks. That’s not something you usually see in a deli, and it immediately stood out to me. But what really made this place unforgettable was the service. It’s run by what seems like an older Korean couple, and they were some of the kindest, most welcoming people I’ve ever met in any food spot. Not the usual rushed, impatient “what do you want?” kind of interaction you sometimes get at delis. They greeted me warmly and made me feel completely comfortable—like I was being welcomed into someone’s home. When I grabbed a room-temperature drink, they immediately told me they had cold ones, walked me over to the fridge, and helped me pick a flavor. They even took the warm one from my hand to put it back for me. It was such a simple moment, but it showed how much they genuinely care. For context, I study culinary arts and I’m currently trying to get into the food industry, so I pay attention to service and how businesses are run. This is exactly how it should be done. You can tell they care about their customers and take pride in their business. The food was great too. I got a bacon, egg, and cheese with hot sauce and ketchup, and the hot sauce was different from the usual—in a really good way. It wasn’t just thrown together; it felt like they actually cared about making it right. I walked in feeling kind of down—it was just one of those Mondays—but I left in a completely different mood. Hours later, I’m still thinking about how kind they were. I’m not even exaggerating when I say this—I would take a bullet for these people. That’s how genuinely good they were to me. If they were hiring, I would work for them in a heartbeat and stay there as long as the place exists. I truly want nothing but success for them. The total came out to about $17, but that included two imported drinks, so it makes sense. And honestly, I don’t regret it at all. I’d gladly spend my money here again. This is officially my new go-to spot every time I go to the library. I’d rather come here than go to Dunkin’, 7-Eleven, or anywhere else. I love this place. I mean that seriously. Even if I’m not getting a full meal, I’d go out of my way just to grab a drink or a bag of chips to support them. If you’re anywhere near West Islip, do yourself a favor and check this place out. Businesses like this deserve to succeed.”
Deli · $
462 Union Blvd, West Islip
Customers’ favorites
“I have eaten food from Captree Deli on various occasions through the years. Always very good, fresh food. Yesterday, 8/3/24, I catered a small hero, salads and pickles for a small group of friends. I was very happy with everything! The food was fresh and delicious, they did a beautiful presentation and provided great serving utensils with the order. Made it all that much easier. They are seasoned at this. It was an easy, seamless process. Thank you Captree Deli!!! You get high marks from me!!!”
Deli · $
17 Udall Rd, West Islip
Customers’ favorites
“The SPK deli has a fantastic selection of foods. Katya is adorable, she's an amazing Baker and cook. She can cook anything so delicious soups sandwiches great hot lunches. Pete is a great guy who works there .also. totally pleasant atmosphere. You go there once and you will go back again.”
Deli · $
117 West Main Street, East Islip · 5.99 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I have been getting egg sandwiches from 117 for a couple of years now. We already know that no one makes a better egg sandwich for multiple reasons BUT LET ME TELL YOU. I just got a chicken cutlet sandwich for the first time from them and i feel obligated to let everyone know it was HANDS DOWN THE BEST CHICKEN CUTLET SANDWICH I HAVE EVER ATE IN MY LIFE. This whole time i always got egg sandwiches and today for lunch i went with the cutlet sandwich. I still can’t believe how good this was, and i have tried almost every egg sandwich and chicken cutlet in the islips. I promise you there’s no one that makes them better.”
Deli · $
1975 New Highway, Farmingdale · 6.55 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Super fresh, great variety and helpful, friendly staff! This was my first time there and I'll be back. The owner and I had a lovely chat, and he gave me a fresh piece of fruit along with my tuna sandwich!”
Deli · $
306 Maple Ave, Smithtown · 10.77 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I stopped by this deli for the first time not knowing it was cash only. Without hesitation, Tammy kindly let me Venmo her, and on top of that, she welcomed me with free muffins. She was extremely generous and nice. Great food, great service. I’ll definitely be coming back. Thank you, Tammy!”
Deli · $
228 East Main Street, Bay Shore · 3.59 miles
Customers’ favorites
“So happy I discovered this place! Right across from the hospital and run by a really wonderful family, super quick and inexpensive too. I work down the block and have gotten breakfast and lunch here every day for the last few weeks and never been disappointed. One of the best bacon/sausage egg and cheeses i’ve had on long island. Chicken cutlets are made fresh and lots of good drink options and snacks as well.”
Deli · $
92 Mahan Street, West Babylon · 4.34 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Our Christmas Eve was catered by Anthony’s Deli and the food was delicious! Not a single thing left, amazing staff, logistics, price and most important quality of the food was more than we could have asked. I highly recommend them and will certainly be using them again and again!”
Deli · $
95 Unqua Road, Massapequa · 7.58 miles
Customers’ favorites
“SUPPORT YOUR LOCAL ITALIAN DELI”
Deli · $
136 Heyward Street, Brentwood · 7.02 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Absolutely amazing spot! The food here is authentic and delicious some of the best Dominican food around. Portions are great the flavors are on point and everything tastes homemade. The prices are very good especially for the quality and freshness you get. Service is friendly and the atmosphere feels welcoming. Definitely a go-to lunch and dinner spot for me. Highly recommend!”
Deli · $
9 Railroad Avenue, Babylon · 0.96 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Best Spanish food around...Always hot and fresh...The people working there are always so friendly..My favorite spot!!5 stars🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟”
Deli · $
902 Conklin Street, Farmingdale · 6.73 miles
Customers’ favorites
“GREAT DELI HAS BEEN HERE FOR YEARS.THEY TERAT EVERONE LIKE FAMILY THIS PLACE HAS GREAT CUTOMER SERVICE. AND BREAKFAST IS ALWAYS AMAZING.”
Deli · $
199 Maple St, Islip · 4.96 miles
Customers’ favorites
“A landmark in Islip! New owner John and staff are awesome. Kleibers Deli has improved in so many ways but still has that down home country charm. The food is amazing!! So happy to have them so close to home. Love walking there for breakfast with my dogs who are always welcome and treated to some bacon every time we go. From small snacks, sandwiches to catering Kleibers is a hidden gem you’ll definitely want to try!!”
Deli · $
1180 Sunrise Highway, Copiague · 5.09 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Very large variety of all kind of food to choose”
Deli · $
305 4th Ave, Bay Shore · 3.02 miles
“My friend s try the new leggios deli the new owner s are amazing they make a excellent Italian chicken bacon ranch hero and an amazing pastrami sandwich they also make egg sandwich s”
Deli · $
80 Montauk Hwy UNIT C, Copiague · 5.61 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Jamie n Herb and the staff are the best! The put some much effort into everything they make! You wont find a better deli n catered food then Reyes deli. If i had to pick one thing which is hard i wouldpick the yankee hero pressed!(italian hero) Its amazing!!Thanx guys your the best.❤️”
Deli · $
1548 New York Avenue, Huntington Station · 11.05 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Straight up excellent food. Get the oatmeal on the morning 2$ and also lunch rice beans and chicken/ beef/ pork is always delicious. Salads and sides as well. Always get coffee or coconut water. Well priced and delicious. Thank you to all the hard working people that help the community here !”
Deli · $
5089 Merrick Road, Massapequa Park · 8.02 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Burns Park Deli catered my event this weekend all the food was great (both hot and cold). My only issue was we had to much. 5 of 5 stars.”
Deli · $
1650 Great Neck Road, Copiague · 5.19 miles
“I wanted to be adventurous and try other types of cuisine. I saw the photos and read reviews before I stepped into Euro Deli. Now I have become a frequent customer. I can only imagine how good it feels for local polish people coming here. You see all these authentic items straight from the motherland. A one stop shop for authentic polish items. All kinds of meats are offered. They serve cookies and what pastries they made that day. Over by the entrance is their hot food and take out area. All kinds of fresh in house food is served there and side salads. I love the big dinner. For $12 you get to choose a starch with a gravy, then you pick what main dish you want. You can two proteins with your meal. Say a stuffed chicken cutlet and a kebob, or a beef patty and roast chicken. Plus a delicious salad. I love the carrots. Shredded carrots served in a dressing that is not overpowering and the carrots still have crunch. A beet salad, and more. All for $12 is a great deal this day and age. Plus fresh made soups are offered. So yummy. I wish I could converse in the workers native language especially to tell them how good everything is. The employees can communicate in English. Some not so much but they are patient and friendly. Definitely come for some good eats and a taste of Polish snacks and treats.”
Deli · $
515 Oak Street, Copiague · 5.16 miles
“If you do not speak Polish, hope you are up for a fun adventure. They wrote the names of what we ordered on the boxes and we goggled the translations as we were eating! The food was delicious!”
Deli · $
504 South Fire Island Avenue, Babylon · 1.55 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great”
Deli · $$
195 Commack Road, Commack · 9.12 miles
Customers’ favorites
“great food wife loves there chocolate and tea”
Deli · $
38 Deer Shore Square, North Babylon · 3.08 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We didn’t have the food long enough to take pictures 😅 but we are so happy we stoped at Salpino’s to try them out. We purchased three sandwiches 2 of “ the classic “ and 1 of “ the supreme “ . We also purchased the Farfalle pasta salad and chicken Caesar pasta salad. The chicken Caesar pasta salad is my new favorite thing in life… I want it every day 😂 We also purchased the prosciutto bread. Everything was amazing. Including the employees. It was an all around great experience and we cannot wait to take the 45 minute drive to go back!”
Sandwich Shop · $
302 35th Street, Lindenhurst · 4.4 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The best deli !!! & the people who work there are the best!!❤️ highly recommend 😊😊”
Deli · $
180 Howells Road, Bay Shore · 2.45 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Best deli in the area and even in these hard times theyve managed to keep my family fed, while still maintaining our safety, by offering curbside to go. Awesome food (gotta try their new soups!), awesome people, and just really appreciate them giving a little piece of normalcy during these trying times.”
Deli · $
900 Great Neck Rd, Copiague · 5.22 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I would travel miles ( and I have) to get their grated pecorino”
Deli · $
183 Bay Shore Road, Deer Park · 2.94 miles
Customers’ favorites
“**Rating: A+++** I had a fantastic experience at Deer Park Deli! From the moment I walked in, the **customer service** stood out—the staff was friendly, polite, and professional, making me feel welcome immediately. A special shout-out to **La Flaca**, Marcela and Monchy who was impressively quick and accurate with my order. The establishment itself is very **well-organized and clean**, which creates a great atmosphere for diners. As for the food, it was absolutely **delicious**. I highly recommend the **Mofongo**; it is easily one of the most authentic versions I’ve had, staying very true to traditional Puerto Rican flavors. I will definitely be coming back!”
Deli · $
297B Bay Shore Rd, Deer Park · 2.65 miles
“This is the best deli in town! I’ve been coming here for years and the staff and prices are completely fair and truly they put out amazing food! I love the lady who works the register she’s truly the best I highly recommend people to come by and check them out!”
Deli · $
197 Depot Road, Huntington Station · 10.79 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I am new to the neighborhood, found Danny's by luck. I ordered breakfast egg sandwiches, the food was very good, everyone liked the food. Friendly staff, and clean business, I will return and recommend Danny's to my friends and family.”
Deli · $
170 Bridge Rd, Islandia · 9.05 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I had a suprise 60 th and the Garage was excellent. Everyone loved the food and of course the main guy Big Frank Thank you again for everything”
Deli · $
364 Little E Neck Rd #7704, West Babylon · 1.91 miles
Customers’ favorites
“You just can’t beat Jessens Deli.”
Deli · $
155 Bay Shore Road, Deer Park · 2.99 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great deli, generous portions, quick service, awesome staff.”
Deli · $
936 Little East Neck Road, West Babylon · 2.77 miles
Customers’ favorites
“This is a great deli anf sandwich shop for me. They have a few things other deli don't have. The food is always good. Worth a stop if your coming in this direction. The inside is not large. They make the best of the space do you can eat here. I always take it to go”
Breakfast · $
669 East Jericho Turnpike, Huntington Station · 9.8 miles
Customers’ favorites
“So happy to have this deli open in our neighborhood. The staff is friendly, the place is very clean and the food is great. Great pleasure knowing the deli is owned and operated by a local family with young children in our school district.”
Deli · $
719 West Jericho Turnpike, Huntington · 10.84 miles
Customers’ favorites
“This was my initial visit to the Blue Line Deli, and I must express my admiration. I ordered two egg sandwiches, and they prepared both to perfection. Furthermore, they were delightful. The Deli is exceptionally clean and well-stocked. There is an abundance of salads and sandwich options available. For Islanders fans, the theme is represented in Blue and Orange. Additionally, there is impressive memorabilia adorning the walls. The Deli is family-owned, and the staff is remarkably friendly and accommodating.”
Deli · $
90 Broadhollow Road, Melville · 8.19 miles
Customers’ favorites
“My buddy and I flew to New York from Utah on a work trip. We asked the owner, Simon, what he would recommend, and he told us the X factor sandwich was their best one. So we tried it, and after eating it, we literally had to walk back inside and shake his hand because of how good the sandwich was. Seriously a 10 out of 10.”
Deli · $
1036 Little East Neck Road Apt 1, West Babylon · 3.08 miles
Customers’ favorites
“So authentic. Fresh ingredients! Amazing food. Loved everything...great homemade tacos and sauces✔️ Finally found my favorite spot.”
Deli · $$
1635 Great Neck Road Suite 4, Copiague · 5.2 miles
“Excellent stuffed cabbage”
Spanish · $
2116 Union Boulevard, Bay Shore · 4.01 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I love the food here omg I come here everyday”
Deli · $
1389 5th Avenue, Bay Shore · 3.3 miles
“This place is home to whoever comes here. The food is home to whoever tastes it. This place is whole heartedly the best place on the island. Everything in one. This place makes the spirit and the soul happy. Kid-friendliness: Family.”
Deli · $
1827 5th Avenue, Bay Shore · 5.36 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Went at 11AM on a Sunday. The parking lot was a puzzle of cars trying to get in and out and just parking anywhere they could. There was a minimal line inside. We had the steak, the chicken and the Cuban sandwiches. They were all AMAZING. The chicken and the Cuban melted my fat heart. I then ordered some to go for later on, since I live in Queens. I hope I'm out by this area again so I can order it again. Cash only, and don't look for cleanliness, just order and enjoy.”
Deli · $
1425 New York Ave A, Huntington Station · 11.26 miles
“Absolutely incredible food and even better people. I’ve been on the hunt for really good, flavorful food and especially a flavorful, comforting soup and I finally found exactly what I was looking for at Deli Yari’s 2. The steak was absolutely incredible: tender, juicy, perfectly seasoned, and packed with flavor. The soup was easily a 10/10—rich, comforting, and full of the homemade flavor I had been searching for. Everything tasted fresh and made with real care, and the hot-food selection had so many great options that it was hard to choose. What made the experience even better was the staff. Everyone was incredibly welcoming, patient, helpful, and genuinely kind. The gentleman at the front and the ladies behind the steam table all took the time to help me and made me feel appreciated from the moment I walked in. It’s rare to find food this delicious served by people who genuinely care about their customers. Thank you to everyone at Deli Yari’s 2 for the amazing food and hospitality. This place is a true hidden gem, and I’ll definitely be coming back and recommending it to my friends and family.”
Italian · $
640 North Wellwood Avenue, Lindenhurst · 4.06 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great people , awesome fresh food at a convenient location.”
Deli · $
10 Colonial Springs Road, Wyandanch · 5.02 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I got a sandwich with, turkey, cheddar cheese, extra mayo, lettuce, salt and pepper with jalapeños. It was very good stacked well with turkey and not cheap with the toppings. They do get very busy at times of the day so expect to wait for a few if it is. They sell hot food and soups and other things such as tuna,crab salad, egg salad and things. They are also EBT friendly. UPDATE!! 7/30/25 I went and the same thing GREAT FOOD AND SERVICE, check them out you won’t be disappointed. Btw it’s the second pic with the ribs.”
Deli · $
43 Milbar Blvd, Farmingdale · 6.74 miles
Customers’ favorites
“This deli is a gem! Really affordable food with amazing flavor… So much food variety. Restrooms are clean and there’s a lot of parking outside. Today I had the Roadhouse Panini along with a homemade lemonade and it was the perfect combo!”
Deli · $
280 East John Street, Lindenhurst · 3.03 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great food! Great personality! Very clean!”
Deli · $
1985 Great Neck Road, Copiague · 5.21 miles
“great traditional polish food”
Deli · $
975 West Jericho Turnpike, Smithtown · 10.33 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Easily one of my favorite deli’s in smithtown and all the surrounding areas. Been going almost every weekend for 1-2 years and haven't had one bad experience yet. The food is always amazing, fresh, and never small portions. Not to mention all the staff being very helpful and polite every time i come in, it really makes you feel appreciated as a customer ! Thank you for all the great food !”
Deli · $
571 Broadway, Amityville · 6.14 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Recently moved from Brooklyn to lindenhurst. Had the biggest craving for a classic Brooklyn bodega chopped Cheese!! A+!! The sandwich was fresh and delicious!!! I definitely found my spot to cure my bodega cravings!! Jeremy... Nice meeting you bro!!”