50 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Islip

“So my girlfriend and I recently moved in the area. Now though there’s a pizzeria closer to my apartment but this pizzeria is worth the drive.

This pizzeria has much more variety and the owners and pizza makers are very friendly and they work very hard. Even though they didn’t have any Caesar salad slices and they still made us Caesar slices and it came out very well. The pasta slices are out of this world. Very well done. Top tier customer service and pizza slices. This place is definitely underrated! Thank you for such a good Sunday dinner!! Will definitely return soon!“

“es un lugar muy agradable familiar los niños selapasan de lo mejor felises“

“I had the Bella Salad with grilled chicken, fresh lettuce nicely seasoned chicken. The marinara sauce was very tasty. I did have this rolls, I forgot the name. The little rolls were made with lots cheese not heavy dough, one with pepperoni the other with spinach. It was difficult sharing.“

“On March 10th 2024, Myself and My Father went to your restaurant and we got two slices of pizza for $10 and meanwhile once we had finished our slices of pizzas and once we got home from your restaurant we started to get serious sick that led to be we got food poison and trust me I would never go to your restaurant ever again after last night“

“Great food, friendly atmosphere!!“

“The food never disappoints. The staff is friendly and professional. You won’t be disappointed.“

“As the official pizza judge of Long Island I like this place. Small shop but power taste. No happy hello but I respect the confidence. Tough crowd but, the grandma slice was loud. Place is to the point. No sugar coating. I didnt find the regular slice appealing. I settled for a grandma slice. Solid 4 outta 5. Slightly sweet , crunchy and the dough is flavorful. Spanish speaking is a plus.“

“I can’t even begin to express how happy we are to have this place in Babylon village. We have been here numerous times since they opened.
Who even came up with the vodka fritters ?? He deserves an award!! They are amazing!! The meatballs are sooooo freeken good … my favorite has to be the garlic knots. They deserve a Michelin star .. especially when they don’t overcook them and they are drenched in garlic and oil ..
pizza selections are many and delicious, my personal favorite is the chicken Marsala pizza slice !!
Today we can and actually sat instead of taking out, the server Samantha was such a pleasure. She was helpful, kind , funny and so good with our questions. Hers smile killed!!
The people behind the pizza counter are so nice also !!!
The seasonal drink menu needs some tweaking, but no one comes to a pizzeria for the craft cocktails ..
well done to the owners who run such a great ship!! Thank you for serving us ..
-Maria Rizzuto … babylon resident“

“Carissa is an amazing bartender! The staff is very inviting and makes you feel like part of the family. The food is absolutely not what you would expect from a “pizza place.” Everything we have had has been nothing short of incredible. 10/10“

“I went to dinner with my son last and there was a bit of misunderstanding staff fixed the problem Food is great the atmosphere is great I’d like to think the management to straighten out the problem I’ve been eating there in Islip that pizza place for a while great food“

“Best pizza hands down..I ordered birthday dinner for my twin boys..from the PIZZAS to the wings and salad and dessert...my family all enjoyed every bite..thank you for opening in Holtsville..congratulations and I'll be back“

“best pizza in Huntington“

“Great selection at all times, just walk in and pick something OR order ahead and be amazed“

“Visiting back up from Florida.
Yes most pizza in NY is better than FL.
But this place is insane!!!
The grandma pie is without a doubt the best I’ve ever had in my 57 years!!!
So good, we’re heading there right now to get more!
Chicken bacon ranch is on point as well!“

“A big Shout out to GUSTOSO’s Pizzeria for hosting my sister’s 29th birthday celebration. I absolutely adored the family vibe that you feel as soon as you walk in. This is my absolute favorite restaurant in Huntington now :blush:. Owners allowed us to bring our own décor. The food was fantastic and no matter what we ordered we were delighted with our meal! But if you ask me the Chicken Alla Vodka was DELICIOUS! Special thanks to Jasmine our server, she was such a pleasure to be around, very efficient, happy, and polite. Can’t wait to return and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend to anyone looking for a small friendly place that will make it a memorable experience to the ones you love.“

“Even though I have to travel from 5 towns over, I will do it time and again because I LOVE everything about Mama's. Their Chicken a la Mama, as well as their Granma Vodka pizza brings me to my knees without fail. I'm a bit picky (like extra lemon butter sauce and garlic knots please) but the staff always gets it right. You KNOW a restaurant is top notch when the staff smiles from the moment you walk through the door until you leave. Thank you for everything Mama's. I'll see you again VERY soon. Dont change a thing....“

“Pizza is great. We had pepperoni with hot honey. Definitely one of the better pizzas in the area. We went there on Saturday afternoon and we had to wait about 45 minutes for one pie. They only have 1 small oven, but there is bar so you can enjoy couple of beers while you wait. Even though the pizza is good, you don't get a lot of it for your money. We paid $30 for the pie, which is 6 small slices.“

“Very good!! My favorite Pizzeria I will not order from anywhere else“

“Mike put on a great show for our scouts and then we enjoyed amazing pizza. I highly recommend them!“

“Delicious food. Great service. We enjoyed the baked clams, the calamari, rice ball, and marina pizza, white pizza and spinach artichoke pizza!“

“I have had Isabella’s pizza and hero’s before but never a pasta dinner. Now I know why. I did not enjoy it at all. I ordered lasagne with chicken parmagian and meatballs. The lasagne was mostly chicken, hardly any lasagne. The meat balls were good. I was’nt to crazy about the sauce. I will still get pizza from there but not a dinner.“

“Francesco’s is our favorite Italian restaurant because the food is fresh and delicious. The staff are always friendly, and Frank the owner is always onsite with a warm welcome. This is a true family restaurant, with “old school” charm that reminds me of all the wonderful Italian restaurants I remember growing up in Staten Island. This place feels like home.
And their catering is also excellent.“

“Great customer service food was delicious 😋 love the pasta“

“AWESOME“

“First time trying for a birthday party nearby at the adventure park/ropes course. They said they would deliver at 7:15 pm and boy were they prompt. They remembered the extra utensils/plates etc. This place does not play around. You want it, you got it!“

“Food was great as usual. Live the food here. The last time I was here the server was fantastic. Tonight the serve was not attentive. I had to get up twice to get her attention. I really like this place. But this server should not be working there. I am not sure if I will be coming back.“

“Always such a great experience. The owner Frank always is accommodating. It’s a family owned business and the food is phenomenal!“

“On a Friday evening it’s usually Family Meal Deal from Pizza Parm!“

“friendly people excellent food“

“Beautiful owner absolutely hard waitresses. God Bless you all enjoyed very much. Crazy Linda Love ❤️ you guys.“

“First I wish I could leave a 100 star review. I have to follow a heart healthy diet. I first went to another place and ask the waiter what was heart healthy. She looked at the menu and said how would I know. And just shoved it back at me. So to Francesco we go. I walked in and ask the host a out heart healthy. She tells me that I can alter any item to eat...but she also double check. As soon as I looked at the menu I find 5 items that can be adjusted. When I order from my outstanding waiter TJ. he informed the chef to do low sodium. The chef actually made my dinner salt free an DELICIOUS. Francesco please reward these three for a job above and beyond. You have a forever customer. I did get the hostess name,so this happened on Sunday 9/8/24. Around 5pm. Sorry so long. God Bless you all for caring for a stranger.“

“Great family specials! Just used Memas for a small catering order for my daughters birthday this past Saturday and everyone LOVED the food , especially the rigatoni alla vodka!! Definitely going to be my new go to spot“

“I just had another amazing lunch at Zest. The portions are VERY generous and the food is always amazing. The chef is a culinary artist.“

“I'm going to give them 4 stars which is unfortunate because when they are on, they are very good. But I've noticed consistency issues at times. I tried their Margarita pie a few months ago and it was really excellent, I had it a few weeks after that and it was good but not as good, and then today it was average at best. Everyone there is very nice and it's a good spot, but it's disappointing not knowing which version of their pizza you are gonna get.“

“Just had amazing balsamic chicken pizza and delicious pasta ala vodka . Family loved it. Thanks you serious pizza guys. 👍“

“Great pizza and great staff I love Mary’s I’ve been going here for years“

“I will say one of the best Pizza and italian food in the area. If you like specialty pizza this is the place. I always order two slices of Palermo which is calamari slice with spicey. I usually have to wait as it is not always available, But definately worth the wait.The food is always good,The owner is always there and always friendly and is working just as hard as the other employees keeping things going.“

“Wondeeful experience patient kind staff very clean they cater to all needs!! This might be one of the best locations on the island !!!!!

Vegetarian options: Lots of veggie options

Dietary restrictions: You can get gluten free

Parking: Lots of space“

“I snowbird to and from Brentwood to PR and I meet all of my friends who I grew up with at Tony's. There is nothing more exciting than grabbing a slice of both pies, everything is good quality and delicious.“

“Went on a Tuesday night had delicious soup, spaghetti and clams glass of wine and an extra glass of wine because the dessert ran out. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone well worth going there sitting outside. What a great atmosphere can’t wait to go back.“

“Always great food and service. The wings, the clams, the garlic knots and of course the pizza always fresh and tastes great. Ordered food for a birthday party yesterday. Can’t say enough. The prices are great too! Try it you’ll love it!! Sorry no pictures they ate it too fast!“

“I the food is so awesome!!“

“Absolutely blown away by Juventus Pizza in Deer Park (located on 786 Grand Blvd, Deer Park near the outlets—across from Kohl’s). My partner and I were looking for a quick bite and were not disappointed. The pepperoni pizza was classic perfection, and the boom boom chicken slice was a flavor explosion! As for me, the chicken roll with boom sauce on the side was great and a must-try!

The owners are incredibly friendly and create such a welcoming atmosphere. The shop's decor is also fantastic – the art on the walls is really cool and the music is always on point.

It's amazing how much they give back to the Deer Park community. From their ongoing support to local initiatives to their recent fundraiser for the victims of the tragic nail salon accident, it's clear they genuinely care about their neighbors. Supporting local businesses like this is so important! If you're looking for amazing pizza, a great vibe, and a business that cares about its community, look no further.“

“They have the best Italian food. Always great service very friendly.“

“My cousin Mike took me to this Pizzeria for food. The Pizza was great, I am from New York and Pizza anywhere out of New York City is never the same. Boy, I was wrong. It was delicious, and the service was amazing. I am glad he showed me the place. I will be coming again, One of the Brothers was behind the counter such nice gentleman ?“

“One of the best, if not the best restaurant in Bay Shore, period! The food is fabulous and the portions are tremendous. Try it for yourself and I bet you'll agree. Order the pork chop and see if you can finish it!“

“Massive slices. Easily double the size of what you get anywhere else. I came hungry and still struggled to eat both slices.

Penne slice very good and overflowing with pasta. Could have used a bit more cheese, but pretty much perfect as-is.

White slice I was less of a fan. Great flavor, but way too oily.

Definitely will be back here when in the area!“

“The staff was very friendly and we really enjoyed the food. We plan to return.“

“We had been getting our pies from Pizza King for years now, but decided to try some other things on their menu. Wow, the stuffed shells were fabulous along with the eggplant rollatini being as tasty as my own. Their prices are very fair and I would not hesitate to host a party using their catering.“

“absolutely delicious and made with love! there's just something about francesco's :)“