50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Islip

“Great selection at all times, just walk in and pick something OR order ahead and be amazed“

“I am a loyal Pizzeria customer but I usually go to their Bay Shore location because I live in Bay Shore. Last Friday I wanted to send a pizza to a sick friend but she lives in East Islip so I decided to use the Islip location. Upon calling, I was told delivery orders had to go thru the website. No problem. I tried and use 2 valid credit cards but the site wouldn't take either of them. I called the Islip location and the suggestion was to refresh the site which I did and still was not able to complete my order so I used a different pizza place. I called back in case there was a problem with their site and then they would know. Again I spoke to Tony and at the end of the conversation he said that he would like to compensate for the time I spent trying to order and that I would have a $25 credit for the next time that I came in. This is what sets The Pizzeria locations apart, not only is their food amazing but they take customer service to a whole higher level than most establishments. Give them a try, you won't be disappointed.“

“Always awesome and delicious!!!“

“I went to dinner with my son last and there was a bit of misunderstanding staff fixed the problem Food is great the atmosphere is great I’d like to think the management to straighten out the problem I’ve been eating there in Islip that pizza place for a while great food“

“This is such a beautiful space. The atmosphere is friendly and welcoming. The pizza is amazing and the location is perfect.“

“All I'll say is.. Mama Mia !!“

“They have been working with so many families in need. They are helping feed Long Island families while the SNAP program is still not being funded. In addition to a friendly eatery that truly cares about people their food is amazing. So many options to choose from! Stop by and say hello, grab some delicious food and help spread the love. Donate today or share their mission to feed Long Island families in need during this difficult time. No child should ever be hungry.“

“We participated in the pizza fundraiser through our church. The pizza was on the smaller size but came out really well.This was an excellent idea for a fundraiser. The sauce was a bit too salty but we appreciated how the product was packaged.“

“Just Made the pizza from the Pizza Kit for The Harding Avenue Elementary School fundraiser, and it was delicious.“

“Both round and square.“

“Great pizza!!! Great people!!!“

“Fantastic pizza. One of the best in commack“

“I snowbird to and from Brentwood to PR and I meet all of my friends who I grew up with at Tony's. There is nothing more exciting than grabbing a slice of both pies, everything is good quality and delicious.“

“After having a falling out with our original catering company just weeks before our wedding, finding La Cucina Paisanos was truly a blessing in disguise. From the very first moment we walked into the restaurant to see if they might be an option for our wedding, we were warmly greeted by Nick, the owner, and immediately felt at ease. Nick took the time to walk us through the entire catering process and even allowed us to sample several menu items since we hadn’t yet had the chance to try the food. That level of care and hospitality set the tone for the entire experience. The customer service from Nick and the entire La Cucina Paisanos team genuinely went above and beyond every step of the way. My now husband and I are both Johnson & Wales Culinary graduates, so food quality was incredibly important to us — not just for ourselves, but because we knew our guests would expect nothing less. La Cucina Paisanos absolutely delivered. The food was outstanding, prepared with care, flavor, and consistency, and our guests raved about it all night long. It truly elevated our wedding day. That says so much that after returning from our honeymoon, we went straight back to La Cucina Paisanos for dinner — and once again, everything from the service to the ambiance to the quality of the food was exceptional. Whether you’re looking for incredible Italian cuisine for a family dinner or need catering for a special event, we cannot recommend La Cucina Paisanos enough. You can truly taste the love and passion that goes into every dish. This restaurant has earned our highest recommendation — 10-fold.“

“Food was great as usual. Live the food here. The last time I was here the server was fantastic. Tonight the serve was not attentive. I had to get up twice to get her attention. I really like this place. But this server should not be working there. I am not sure if I will be coming back.“

“Local pizza joint with 1980 prices! Food is good, people are nice, happy to support our small businesses in the neighborhood!“

“THE BEAT SALAD (added shrimp & avocado) ! Holy HEAVENS! OH MY DAYS! I had to sit in the parking lot to chow down. Absolutely worth the wait. Super delicious. Honestly I forgot to use the salad dressing. That’s how yummy this is. Will be back! Thank you all!! #DELISH“

“Had a wonderful lunch with three friends today. Great food and service. Such a wonderful surprise will certainly make it a go to place. Thanks for a great lunch.“

“Ever since the new owners completely revamped the old Spinelli's, this has been my go-to pizza, and more, place. The food is amazing and the pizza selection is unique and incredible. I'm mean, Thai Chili Calamari pizza, getoutahere! And the Black & Blue burger on toasted garlic hero is one go the best burgers I've ever had...and I've had a lot of burgers. The Italian wedge salad with crispy prosciutto is incredible, and I don't eat salad but after seeing it, made my mouth water...I had to have a plate. I have to mention the Pasta Gambero with shrimp, un effin believable! And the staff is truly wonderful. They're so friendly. They really make you feel welcome and appreciated as a customer. So much so that I wound up marrying one of the owners daughters and (yes we did) gave our newborn Samuel, Sardo as a middle name!!! This place is here to stay. Check it out. You will not be disappointed!“

“friendly people excellent food“

“By far the best pizzeria in the Deer Park area and beyond! Be sure to try the meatball parm hero, the salad slice and the stuffed pizza slices. If stuffed slices are not available when you go, just ask as this pizzeria is always accomodating to their customers!“

“Seriously the best pizza I’ve ever had. And in 58 years, I’ve tried quite a few! This place cares about quality ingredients, details and consistency. Truly from the way they make their fresh dough, choose their top of the line cheese, tomato sauce, Dearborn ham, etc, I can tell they shopped around and chose the best. From perfectly crisped meaty bacon bits, tender chicken and how they cut their produce to carmelize the onions on top so it complements the entire BBQ chicken pizza I just tried. This is the first round pizza I had from them and it didn’t disappoint. It had a nicely seasoned Parmesan garlic butter crust and the toppings were perfectly placed with just enough bbq sauce. Can we talk about their salads, too?? Quality produce with romaine lettuce cut like pros-uniform and easy to eat. And generous toppings with a yummy ranch (my favorite here) dressing. Take a day off and do yourself a favor. Try this place! They now have a Michigan Salad! My new fav go- to place.❤️🥰🍕🥗“

“The pizzettes are amazing. Anthony is the best. Everything is always cooked to perfection and customized with no question.“

“Once again, ordered from this pizzeria and blown away by the consistency of their food and accuracy on taste. When asked for a well- done pizza, it’s perfectly cooked! Please do yourself a favor-Ask for the sesame seed crust. It’s just outstanding. I also get the hot anti-pasto and I love the variety of food in it. Stuff clams, eggplant rollatini, roasted mussels, and shrimp, Everything somehow is perfectly cooked with the breadcrumbs, delicious Appetizer. I get it every time!! Actually everything I’ve gotten so far has been delicious. The Chicken Marsala and their Chicken Francese and couple other things but don’t want this to be too long. Definitely try the place. Much love, Lauren.“

“Amazing pizza 🔥 Best late night spot in town. Quick question — do you guys have a website for direct orders?“

“I came in there over the summer with my wife and my grandson, Gerald. We were greeted by a young lady by the name of Brooke. Let me tell ya, she was a wonderful waitress to mi familia y yo! She brightened up out dinner experience and made the whole restaurant glow with positivity. I have never experienced such amazing service in my 73 years of life. I especially want to thank her for being nice to my grandson. he has severe autism and she was just a doll! She even sang him happy birthday (he was turnin 7). I tell ya what, if I hadn't lost so much money to these darn taxes, I would've left a $100 tip for this sweet girl. PLEASE give miss Brooke a nice raise. And give her my best wishes. Hugs & Kisses, -Rupert, Gerald and family <3“

“Have been getting pizza from here for over 15 years - best pizza around! They also give so much back to our local community, especially our schools.“

“We were in town for a dance convention and after the long drive from CT we were all starving. We ended up at Francescos and we did not regret it! My friend and I couldn't decide so ordered the chicken piccatta and the chicken crispino to share, and our kids ordered a chicken parm and a chicken Ceasar salad. Everything was soo fresh and delicious! If we are ever in the area again we will definitely come back.“

“We ordered from door dash and after striking out with many Italian places, this was some good stuff. will definitely be ordering again!“

“Amazing Pizza! Nice and crispy and delicious. This will be our new go to spot! 🍕“

“My favorite local pizza place! Pizza is always cooked perfectly and never had an issue here. Their sauce is delicious and it goes great with a calzone or garlic knot. The staff treats you like family and cares about the quality of their food. Will be coming back for years!“

“they are the best. Tried about a dozen items and all were terrific. Very accomodating.“

“There’s no better pizza place around! The food is delicious, the staff is friendly & the place is always clean! I am a pizza lover who enjoys trying new places & supporting different local businesses,but if you’re looking for a guarantee with great food & customer service this is the place. This is definitely my family’s “go to” spot.“

“One of our favorite pizzerias. Love all the options. Pizzas and salads are the best around!“

“We love their vodka margarita pizza (if you haven’t it’s a must have). So we decided to have them cater our daughter’s birthday dinner. The catering packages were affordable, good selection, plenty of food and delicious. Everyone enjoyed their food and the pizza. They also delivered which was a huge plus. Thanks so much!! Definitely will be ordering again. Shout out to Autumn who was so helpful, easy to place an order with and pleasant.“

“Very good!! My favorite Pizzeria I will not order from anywhere else“

“Absolutely love this place. Definitely the best pizza in town!“

“Fabulous lunch today!!! Excellent food and service!!!“

“the worker/owner was very chill made my day with a conversation 🤩🤩🤩🤩“

“Great family specials! Just used Memas for a small catering order for my daughters birthday this past Saturday and everyone LOVED the food , especially the rigatoni alla vodka!! Definitely going to be my new go to spot“

“So I don't know why most people in ronkonkoma would get into the family's business of what happened between the brothers or whatever happened I think most people around konkoma should keep their mouth shut especially those who live in Holbrook and those that are just a bunch of drama queens this guy's a great guy he has absolutely amazing food it's actually real pizza it's one of those old school type of feelings when you walk in the pizzeria that he did not have to renovate the place to make you feel welcome so for everybody that lives in Holbrook lake ronkonkoma ronkonkoma center reach Selden all out in this area I suggest those come to gitanos give him the business give him a chance because it's like old Brooklyn style pizza it's legitly that good not only is he an awesome dude very loving very caring when you first walk in he actually treats you like family and actually knows your name so if you're looking for a good hole in the wall pizzeria that's got really great food this is the place to give a try his name's got Tano and he's awesome your gaetano welcome to ronkonkoma we love you and we hope to see you cherish over the next 35 years“

“Everything AMAZING in one word!“

“es un lugar muy agradable familiar los niños selapasan de lo mejor felises“

“I just had another amazing lunch at Zest. The portions are VERY generous and the food is always amazing. The chef is a culinary artist.“

“You guys make the best calzones anywhere. They are stuffed to the gills and baked to perfection.“

“The best food and most wonderful family!“

“They do have good food but used to be better. They have a new staff that looks just miserable and hates being at that place which makes it a bit uncomfortable to be there. Also dont ask for a receipt they dont do receipts so you have to just trust them, not kidding“

“Best pizza and service ever. And best on Long Island.“

“The Quality of food has changed. They put stingy amount of toppings on your pizza the pizza is not cooked properly it was all soft and mushy barely any flavor this place has changed drastically they take a piece of cheese and break it down to little tiny pieces I have never seen anything like this before they do not know how to make PIZZA“

“AMAZING thin crust pizza! it's time here. git the Supreme 🔥🔥🔥🔥🍕🍕🤤🤤“