50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Islip

“Great selection at all times, just walk in and pick something OR order ahead and be amazed“

“I am a loyal Pizzeria customer but I usually go to their Bay Shore location because I live in Bay Shore. Last Friday I wanted to send a pizza to a sick friend but she lives in East Islip so I decided to use the Islip location. Upon calling, I was told delivery orders had to go thru the website. No problem. I tried and use 2 valid credit cards but the site wouldn't take either of them. I called the Islip location and the suggestion was to refresh the site which I did and still was not able to complete my order so I used a different pizza place. I called back in case there was a problem with their site and then they would know. Again I spoke to Tony and at the end of the conversation he said that he would like to compensate for the time I spent trying to order and that I would have a $25 credit for the next time that I came in. This is what sets The Pizzeria locations apart, not only is their food amazing but they take customer service to a whole higher level than most establishments. Give them a try, you won't be disappointed.“

“Always awesome and delicious!!!“

“This is such a beautiful space. The atmosphere is friendly and welcoming. The pizza is amazing and the location is perfect.“

“They have been working with so many families in need. They are helping feed Long Island families while the SNAP program is still not being funded. In addition to a friendly eatery that truly cares about people their food is amazing. So many options to choose from! Stop by and say hello, grab some delicious food and help spread the love. Donate today or share their mission to feed Long Island families in need during this difficult time. No child should ever be hungry.“

“I went to dinner with my son last and there was a bit of misunderstanding staff fixed the problem Food is great the atmosphere is great I’d like to think the management to straighten out the problem I’ve been eating there in Islip that pizza place for a while great food“

“I grew up in a 100 percent Italian family and I have to say Nona’s lasagna was the best I’ve ever had in my life. At 58 years old I have had plenty of lasagna. This is my new go to spot for Italian fare.“

“All I'll say is.. Mama Mia !!“

“Amazing food and drinks! Highly recommended. Luke the bartender is the best of the best ❤️🍕“

“Food was great as usual. Live the food here. The last time I was here the server was fantastic. Tonight the serve was not attentive. I had to get up twice to get her attention. I really like this place. But this server should not be working there. I am not sure if I will be coming back.“

“I just had another amazing lunch at Zest. The portions are VERY generous and the food is always amazing. The chef is a culinary artist.“

“Everything! Food and service Holbrook definitely has a large assortment of goodies and staff is friendly and smart ❤️“

“After having a falling out with our original catering company just weeks before our wedding, finding La Cucina Paisanos was truly a blessing in disguise. From the very first moment we walked into the restaurant to see if they might be an option for our wedding, we were warmly greeted by Nick, the owner, and immediately felt at ease. Nick took the time to walk us through the entire catering process and even allowed us to sample several menu items since we hadn’t yet had the chance to try the food. That level of care and hospitality set the tone for the entire experience. The customer service from Nick and the entire La Cucina Paisanos team genuinely went above and beyond every step of the way. My now husband and I are both Johnson & Wales Culinary graduates, so food quality was incredibly important to us — not just for ourselves, but because we knew our guests would expect nothing less. La Cucina Paisanos absolutely delivered. The food was outstanding, prepared with care, flavor, and consistency, and our guests raved about it all night long. It truly elevated our wedding day. That says so much that after returning from our honeymoon, we went straight back to La Cucina Paisanos for dinner — and once again, everything from the service to the ambiance to the quality of the food was exceptional. Whether you’re looking for incredible Italian cuisine for a family dinner or need catering for a special event, we cannot recommend La Cucina Paisanos enough. You can truly taste the love and passion that goes into every dish. This restaurant has earned our highest recommendation — 10-fold.“

“Just Made the pizza from the Pizza Kit for The Harding Avenue Elementary School fundraiser, and it was delicious.“

“Had the hunny hot mozzarella slice and a cannoli and let me tell you, I couldn’t be any happier. I tried from staton to joes and I have to say, I am glad I stopped here. Kind people with good music and don’t stare you down every second. I will definitely come back here with my family now.“

“friendly people excellent food“

“Fantastic pizza. One of the best in commack“

“THE BEAT SALAD (added shrimp & avocado) ! Holy HEAVENS! OH MY DAYS! I had to sit in the parking lot to chow down. Absolutely worth the wait. Super delicious. Honestly I forgot to use the salad dressing. That’s how yummy this is. Will be back! Thank you all!! #DELISH“

“Had a wonderful lunch with three friends today. Great food and service. Such a wonderful surprise will certainly make it a go to place. Thanks for a great lunch.“

“I snowbird to and from Brentwood to PR and I meet all of my friends who I grew up with at Tony's. There is nothing more exciting than grabbing a slice of both pies, everything is good quality and delicious.“

“Seriously the best pizza I’ve ever had. And in 58 years, I’ve tried quite a few! This place cares about quality ingredients, details and consistency. Truly from the way they make their fresh dough, choose their top of the line cheese, tomato sauce, Dearborn ham, etc, I can tell they shopped around and chose the best. From perfectly crisped meaty bacon bits, tender chicken and how they cut their produce to carmelize the onions on top so it complements the entire BBQ chicken pizza I just tried. This is the first round pizza I had from them and it didn’t disappoint. It had a nicely seasoned Parmesan garlic butter crust and the toppings were perfectly placed with just enough bbq sauce. Can we talk about their salads, too?? Quality produce with romaine lettuce cut like pros-uniform and easy to eat. And generous toppings with a yummy ranch (my favorite here) dressing. Take a day off and do yourself a favor. Try this place! They now have a Michigan Salad! My new fav go- to place.❤️🥰🍕🥗“

“Very good!! My favorite Pizzeria I will not order from anywhere else“

“Amazing Pizza! Nice and crispy and delicious. This will be our new go to spot! 🍕“

“Ever since the new owners completely revamped the old Spinelli's, this has been my go-to pizza, and more, place. The food is amazing and the pizza selection is unique and incredible. I'm mean, Thai Chili Calamari pizza, getoutahere! And the Black & Blue burger on toasted garlic hero is one go the best burgers I've ever had...and I've had a lot of burgers. The Italian wedge salad with crispy prosciutto is incredible, and I don't eat salad but after seeing it, made my mouth water...I had to have a plate. I have to mention the Pasta Gambero with shrimp, un effin believable! And the staff is truly wonderful. They're so friendly. They really make you feel welcome and appreciated as a customer. So much so that I wound up marrying one of the owners daughters and (yes we did) gave our newborn Samuel, Sardo as a middle name!!! This place is here to stay. Check it out. You will not be disappointed!“

“Both round and square.“

“Fabulous lunch today!!! Excellent food and service!!!“

“Local pizza joint with 1980 prices! Food is good, people are nice, happy to support our small businesses in the neighborhood!“

“Great pizza!!! Great people!!!“

“Excellent service and slice! Fresh, hot and ready immediately. Clean and plenty of seating.“

“Everything was great from the time I placed my order till the day it arrive the owner was a pleasure and the food was excellent.so happy I chose them for the baby shower would definitely recommend them to others and if I ever have another party I’ll call him“

“The pizzettes are amazing. Anthony is the best. Everything is always cooked to perfection and customized with no question.“

“Amazing pizza 🔥 Best late night spot in town. Quick question — do you guys have a website for direct orders?“

“the worker/owner was very chill made my day with a conversation 🤩🤩🤩🤩“

“Finally made it to Mozzafiato about two months ago. We have been back many times since. I get a different slice every time. Delicious. By far our favorite pizza place for specialty slices!“

“es un lugar muy agradable familiar los niños selapasan de lo mejor felises“

“ive been looking for a good wood fired pizza place for a while and now ive found it , i went there on friday and got a margarita pizza and a calzone , both were super yum and made with fresh ingredients but the calzone was out of this world and i will be coming back with my wife for lunch“

“We love their vodka margarita pizza (if you haven’t it’s a must have). So we decided to have them cater our daughter’s birthday dinner. The catering packages were affordable, good selection, plenty of food and delicious. Everyone enjoyed their food and the pizza. They also delivered which was a huge plus. Thanks so much!! Definitely will be ordering again. Shout out to Autumn who was so helpful, easy to place an order with and pleasant.“

“Stopped in here for lunch while at work, I ordered the chicken bacon ranch and two vodka slices. The chicken bacon ranch slice was the best one that I’ve ever had in my entire life and I have to say so was the vodka slice, I would have taken a photo of the chicken bacon ranch slice but I was too busy stuffing my face with it lol. The employees are very nice and 10/10 pizza“

“Tonight we had Gino’s Pizza Truck at our school carnival event and they were absolutely a HUGE hit ! Pizza was delicious and families were so happy! The staff were so kind and everyone raved ! Thank you for adding to our carnival event. We will definitely be booking them for future events !“

“We ordered delivery on the app of one of the family meals. The ordering was easy, the food arrived hot and presentation of pizza was great. They tasted great and had a good quantity of toppings. The cheese pesto bread was really good. I will definitely order from them again.“

“Great family specials! Just used Memas for a small catering order for my daughters birthday this past Saturday and everyone LOVED the food , especially the rigatoni alla vodka!! Definitely going to be my new go to spot“

“Bella Cucina has great grandma and drunken grandma pies. Their other pizzas are also good, as well as penne ala vodka and chicken parm. Nice friendly staff too!“

“Great Experience!

I had a really great experience at Papa Johns! 🍕 Everything was fresh, delicious, and made really well. The food tasted amazing, the service was friendly, and everything was prepared quickly. Definitely enjoyed my visit and would recommend it to anyone looking for a good pizza! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“Every time I come, I’m always welcomed. The food is excellent. The service is excellent. The atmosphere is extremely nice for a pizza place with a restaurant. Consistent which is also something that’s not normal these days.“

“My father and I quickly fell in love with this place! The owner is really nice and the woman behind the counter is a shining light :) Their pizza is delicious, but in particular... The Alfredo spice omgggg it's heavenly!!!! Nice environment, friendly people, amazing food, great prices! You can't go wrong.“

“Amazing food Nicest people Very clean Obsessed with their rigatoni rustica Grilled chicken panini Grilled chicken salad French fries and bbq sauce 😋 Yummmmmmm“

“Whether you want to order a pizza to take home , or eat in the dining room. Vinnie’s Mulberry is the spot.

Any meal I had there was excellent. The service is impeccable. The atmosphere is family oriented. So it is like having a hug with dinner. I like that appetizers, soup, salad, main meal are brought out in steps. That way you can enjoy the courses. This has been my favorite spot to eat since last summer. Had taken my family members there. Me and one of my good friends go there all the time. My first time there, they made me mocktails that I requested. They were great.

Go there with your family. There is something for everyone. You will have a nice time.“

“There’s no better pizza place around! The food is delicious, the staff is friendly & the place is always clean! I am a pizza lover who enjoys trying new places & supporting different local businesses,but if you’re looking for a guarantee with great food & customer service this is the place. This is definitely my family’s “go to” spot.“

“Great food! vegan options!!! I always eat vegan when I go out due to an allergy. everything was delicious and I ate safely. thanks! I'll be visiting again!“

“We ordered from door dash and after striking out with many Italian places, this was some good stuff. will definitely be ordering again!“