The Pizzeria of Islip
$ • Pizza
Hours:
591 E Main St, Islip
(631) 581-9500
About The Pizzeria of Islip
Customers' Favorites
The Pizzeria of Islip Reviews
Share your opinion about The Pizzeria of Islip
I am a loyal Pizzeria customer but I usually go to their Bay Shore location because I live in Bay Shore. Last Friday I wanted to send a pizza to a sick friend but she lives in East Islip so I decided to use the Islip location. Upon calling, I was told delivery orders had to go thru the website. No problem. I tried and use 2 valid credit cards but the site wouldn't take either of them. I called the Islip location and the suggestion was to refresh the site which I did and still...read full review
Ordered for the first time from here. The grandma pie was awesome exactly how I like my pizza & I am super picky about my pizza! The mini rice balls were really good! & I come from a long line of Sicilian rice ball grandmas! Also we ordered the pizzeria chicken entree it was good the chicken was fresh & tender! Can’t wait to try more of their entrees. I picked it up & it was ready as soon as I got there & the guys at counter were so nice! Next I have to try their regular neopolitan...read full review
Ordered the grandma Sicilian pizza and the Pizza deal and food was amazing. Thank you 😊
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 9PM |
People in Islip Also Viewed
The Pizzeria of Islip offers a diverse menu with delicious and fresh food options. The pizza is praised for its good quality, especially the gluten-free pizza, which is regarded as the best around. Customers have noted the excellent gluten-free pie options and the extensive variety of regular slices, including a very good pesto slice. The restaurant has a pleasant atmosphere with open space, joyful music, and helpful staff. The environment is perfect for families, making it a suitable spot for hanging out with friends or having a casual sit-down. The pricing is reasonable, with slices and drinks costing around $3-$4.
The Pizzeria also caters to vegetarians with all-veggie pizza options and is generally kid-friendly. Recent reviews mention that the pizza by the slice can be expensive but is always delicious, with favorites like the Ricotta slice, hot honey with pepperoni or sausage, and a Sicilian regular. Customers appreciate the clean environment, friendly staff who bring food to the table, and the two seating areas, including a second room with restrooms. The pizzeria has a great location on Main Street, and the service is friendly and quick. They also prefer credit cards and don't charge extra for using them.
The reviews suggest that The Pizzeria of Islip is a highly recommended dining destination for its amazing food, cleanliness, and welcoming service. The manager's professionalism and responsiveness to customer feedback further enhance the positive experience.