5 Best Pizza Restaurants near Central Islip

“Great food and nice people behind the counter. They are kind and do not kick out homeless, so please respect that.“

“This Little Caesars is takeout only. I ordered a veggie pie and Cheesy Puffs. I came about 10 minutes after the order was put into the take out holder. When I got it to the car and opened it, it was still hot and I was impressed. But I was not too impressed with the pizza. Though it was not too saucy, the onions, mushrooms, peppers and olives seem to be a little scanty and slim and they seemed to be crowded in the middle and nothing towards the edges of the pizza. It also appeared that the pizza was not cut at all, so I had to rip slices off, which I was not too happy about. But overall, it was a positive experience. I would definitely go there again.
Sorry about the pics. I was so hungry I had to eat first and take pics later - LOL“

“Amazing pizza and chicken best in town! It tasted all homemade!“

“there customer service is a trip ! been waiting over an hour for a slice when they told me 30 mins. unbelievable this is the last time I will order from here.“

“Had a visitor come to town late and this was one of the only places open late. While we waited on our pizza, an unruly customer came in and the manager handled it perfectly with professionalism and grace. Shout out Yeunis (hope i spelled her name right). She behaved by the book how someone should act in those situations. Hope Domino's corporate sees this and shows her some love ❤️“