The Pie at Salvatore's

$$ • Pizza

120 E Main St, Bay Shore
(631) 206-1060


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for The Pie at Salvatore's

My son and I were visiting Bayshore last weekend. We stepped into Salvatore's and ordered two individual pizzas. The gentleman who took our order was kind and friendly. Due to the pandemic, we were not able to eat in the restaurant. When we asked for suggestion of where we could go and eat, the gentleman went out of his way and offered to let us eat in his back patio. My son and I enjoyed our experience at Salvatore's. It was a beautiful sunny day and the pizza was was amazing! full review
Let me start by saying I've been here several times and it's always been great, until now. We ordered a chicken roll for the table and at first but it tasted like either the chicken or cheese was bad. Every one spit it out into a napkin, except stupid me who swallowed a mouthful and we sent it back. The waitress was kind enough to take it off the bill. By the time our pizza came I was feeling ill. I wound up having to run to the restroom twice and vomited both times. I full review

The food here is Delicious! The atmosphere feels warm and comfortable, like an Italian grandmothers kitchen ✨. They don’t sell single pizza slices which is a bummer, they only sell the entire pie which is not bad either, Must go if you’re a pizza lover.

More Reviews(86)


Monday 11:30AM - 9PM
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 11:30AM - 9PM
Thursday 11:30AM - 9PM
Friday 11:30AM - 10PM
Saturday 11:30AM - 10PM
Sunday 11:30AM - 9PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.