50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Amityville

“Great food besides pizza his Philly cheese steak hero is absolutely killer and can easily be split for two people Absolutely The Best 🤩🤩“

“Carmelina’s Pizzeria & Gelateria in Amityville is an absolute gem! From the moment we walked in, we were impressed by how clean and welcoming the restaurant was. The food was outstanding, and the hardest part of our visit was deciding what to order because they have such an incredible selection of delicious options.

The atmosphere is very family-oriented, making it a great place for families, friends, or anyone looking for a great meal in a warm environment. A special shoutout to the owner, Paul, who was one of the nicest people we’ve ever met. His positive energy, genuine kindness, and amazing personality truly brighten your day and make you feel right at home.

Between the excellent food, spotless restaurant, friendly service, and welcoming atmosphere, Carmelina’s is a place we will definitely be returning to. If you’re thinking about giving it a try, don’t hesitate—you won’t regret your decision!“

“Always on time always hot“

“exelente atencion and amazing food“

“We have ordered several different pizza slices and pasta dinner. Absolutely yummy. You must try. We do Grab and Go from many different restaurants in Lindenhurst, Copiague, Babylon and Farmingdale. Put The Pizzeria on your list to try. Yummy“

“We celebrated my dad’s 80th bday in one of the igloos. We had such a nice time. My dad loved the unique experience and the food was absolutely delicious.“

“This is such a beautiful space. The atmosphere is friendly and welcoming. The pizza is amazing and the location is perfect.“

“Today we had my daughter’s high school graduation party at Red Volpe ! it housed 50 people in their aide party room- we chose buffet style- we did cash bar - and it was AH amazing ! Salvatore (the owner) and his staff were on point ! Thirty teens plus the rest of the crowd can’t stop raving about the food - chicken francais- chicken parm - vodka pasta- caesar salad- rolls - mozzarella sticks- meatballs- we got to choose what we wanted and we designed the menu ! Sal scooped italian ices for dessert and I also brought in NoFoDoCo custom mini doughnuts. I sat in the bar area and Sal made amazing drinks- blueberry smash is one of my new faves ! We also created a little space for photo back drop ! This local place is a great addition to Bethpage and cannot wait to frequent it for dinners and lunches. I have also had their pizza which is delicious as well !“

“Was just there Friday night for the first time, visiting from Saratoga Lake. They had a great menu, delicious food, and the staff were incredible. I think the woman talking to my friends who had a newborn baby may have been Flora.. Never asked. :) You're going to have a great time here, and try the Limoncello!“

“DELISH!! Uriel & staff are so nice ! Hands down the BEST PIZZA! WELCOME to EAST MEADOW!!“

“Amazing and very friendly staff“

“creativos algo diferente...es más que pizzas.“

“Ate at this establishment in Farmingdale yesterday evening! Best pizza we have ever had! Fast friendly service will definitely be returning when I come back area“

“Unbelievable gem. Red pie was outstanding, goes toe to toe with any New Haven style (speaking from ample experience). Service was courteous, timely, and down to earth. If you have a soul and love pizza, Nico’s Charred is a MUST have.“

“The Pizza here is some of the best on LongIsland“

“great host,excellent waitstaff fantastic food a great dining experience very attended. nice fresh food love this place going there since opening day.“

“I’m a lover of pizza and finding new great pizzerias to eat at. The selections were plentiful. I ordered an eggplant Parm slice and it was pretty delicious except for 1 piece of eggplant that had to much skin on it and did not breakdown to easily but besides that the flavor was very good. I also ordered a capenilli ball which was also very tasty 3 out of 5 stars. I was greeted when I walked in which was nice, the place looked clean and the atmosphere was a little quiet with a news channel playing in the background. Overall I would probably return to try something different next time.“

“Excellent restaurant! Food was delicious, compliments to the chef. Our server Carlos was great! Joe the owner was attentive and accommodating! Would highly recommend!“

“friendly people excellent food“

“Always such a great experience. The owner Frank always is accommodating. It’s a family owned business and the food is phenomenal!“

“I love the hot pepperoni slice. Also the spicy chicken with honey. But the little extras like empanadas and cinnamon knots are why I visit. The crew has exceptional customer service skills I enjoy a nice lunch or dinner alone. It’s a nice escape from the hot kitchen at home. 🤗“

“I live down the block so I'm happy this is a quality pizza place. Their regular, square vodka and chicken bacon ranch slices are great and you get good value for your dollar. The chicken bacon ranch is the best i have ever had. I would have given this place 5 stars if they made the Buffalo chicken and bbq chicken slices like they do the chicken bacon ranch. Unfortunately, those are usually my go to slices but for some reason they take a very different approach than they do the chicken bacon ranch and it definitely doesn't work. I recommend giving this place a try especially if you live in the neighborhood.“

“Fantastic pizza. One of the best in commack“

“Always A Great Experience here. Food is Great. Staff is Excellent. Best Specialty Pies in the neighborhood. If you have not tried Pappardelle's. You Should !!“

“We used Pizza Cucina to cater our daughter's baptism party in our backyard last month! Food was delicious, delivered without an issue and the owner of Pizza Cucina was very nice to work with. All of our guests enjoyed the spread as well and continue to compliment it!“

“The best thin crust margarita!“

“Love this place ! Always a great meal ! Thanks Daniella !“

“Just went there today with the family. I enjoyed my food very much. Got the Manicotti , Chicken fingers w/fries, 2 slices of Cheese pizza, and the Anthony panini. Went home with 2 slices of cheesecake. Food was great waitress was so nice. The staff is super friendly.“

“My sister ordered 20 Pizzas for the nurses in ICU at LIJ that are taking care of the Covid patients. Roma generously gave them at half price! Please please give them your business! They gave back to our community!“

“Very good!! My favorite Pizzeria I will not order from anywhere else“

“If you’re looking for a caterer, Felico’s is the One! Excellent customer service, delicious food and amazing servers that go above and beyond so your party can be a success.“

“Even though I have to travel from 5 towns over, I will do it time and again because I LOVE everything about Mama's. Their Chicken a la Mama, as well as their Granma Vodka pizza brings me to my knees without fail. I'm a bit picky (like extra lemon butter sauce and garlic knots please) but the staff always gets it right. You KNOW a restaurant is top notch when the staff smiles from the moment you walk through the door until you leave. Thank you for everything Mama's. I'll see you again VERY soon. Dont change a thing....“

“Best pizza in town. Love their buffalo blue salad too!“

“Pizza crust and sauce is excellent 👍👍 Definitely going back! 🇮🇹“

“Shoutout our server Leslie! She was so nice!

Great food and cocktails! Loved the pizza. Sitting at the hightops with the street views was nice!

The interior of the restaurant is so beautiful too! Very unique!“

“I enjoyed a Friday night dinner there. The staff was very friendly and helpful. The bartenders were very attentive.
The dining room is small,outdoor seating and seating at the bar is available.

They are able to open the large windows in the front of the restaurant and gives an all around al fresco dining experience. It was a very warm day, and I would have preferred air conditioning but it was still nice.

I didn't have a reservation, but was able to sit at the bar. Which was very nice.

They have a good drink menu with nice cocktails and a good selection of wines and beers. I went with a Peroni.

The menu is small but the is a great selection. The roasted chicken wings were delicious, the Uncle Frank's Pizza and the Meatball Pizza were excellent!

I will go back to Uncle Franks but will remember to make a reservation.“

“Great pizza“

“Awesome pizza, fair prices. The garlic knots and zeppoles are awesome. Will be back for sure!“

“I’ve been going here since I was little and boy have they always delivered, like if I had to choose best pizza place this would be it 100% only gripes I got are that sometimes the pizza is different like more cheese less sauce little issues every blue moon. My favorite dish here is the spaghetti and meatballs and if I had to choose taste this would be my equivalent of heaven on earth. Overall would eat here as long as I live within a 1 hour distance.“

“Great pizza, Great home made soups, friendly service“

“A crispy delight! Delicious sauce. Quality cheese. Amazing crisp. The Sicilian was primo too! Not overly thick. The staff friendly! A great hot slice!“

“Hands down one of the best pizzerias I’ve tried in New York. Family-owned since 1975, and you can really taste the history and authenticity in every bite. The flavors are rich, classic, and perfectly made.
Everything I tried was a hit, especially the rainbow cookie gelato. Definitely worth a visit for any foodie.“

“Delicious!! Beautiful family !! Wonderful staff.. I highly recommend 😊“

“Brilliant marketing, amazing torpedo hoagie. Thanks for the coupon!“

“Best Italian food around. I have been a customer since they first opened and turned my parents onto them as well. We order several times a week and LOVE everything. Would highly recommend!!“

“Villa Montes Review

You need to visit Villa Montes in Old Bethpage if you want delicious Italian food! Montes has awesome food, spectacular service, and a beautiful atmosphere!
The food at Montes is marvelous. The garlic squares were dripping butter and oil. They were very flavorful and crispy. They come served super hot and fresh. The cheese pizza was cheesy and the crust was toasty and crunchy. The chicken fingers were perfectly cooked. The bread crumbs were crispy and they came served with ketchup. The sugar knots were sweet, sugary, and cinnamony!
The service at Montes was fast and friendly. The food came out quickly and they always had more food waiting for anyone who wanted more. The staff greeted us with smiles.
The atmosphere was lovely. The restaurant was clean and spacious. One side was counter service and the other side was sit down service. They had pretty artwork on the walls and dim lighting. There was a TV playing a cooking show on the wall. There was a mix of booths and tables. The bathrooms were clean and well stocked. There was Italian music playing softly.
We think you should definitely visit Montes in Old Bethpage for a great dining experience!“

“The food atmosphere and wait staff excellent!!“

“Just had our 5th grade graduation dance and it was absolutely amazing. The staff, the food and the attention to detail was spot on. Can't wait to have another reason to throw a party at Bar Grazi!!“

“Amazing food and service. Would definitely recommend. Was my first time here and it was phenomenal. Drinks amazing as well.“

“Mike put on a great show for our scouts and then we enjoyed amazing pizza. I highly recommend them!“