The Cortland

$$$ •

27 W Main St, Bay Shore
(631) 666-2333



Reviews for The Cortland

We stumbled into The Cortland on a Monday night looking to have a nightcap somewhere. It was karaoke night which we did not know and we are so glad it was. Some awesome talent got up to sing and the crowd was just having a good time! The drinks was cold and the bartender Ryan was awesome! We will be back in here for more drinks and hopefully karaoke. Cheers!

Let me help them out because there is karaoke here on Monday nights, although no place is it advertised. Not on Facebook, not in places that list local karaoke shows. So just as you should know, this IS a place where you can do karaoke. The drinks are okay, fair priced. But I ordered a specialty on tap; got one of them (it was delicious) then they were out of it when I ordered a second. The bartender suggested a Brooklyn lager instead and it was disgusting. Sorry I'm full review
The Cortland is the perfect local low-key bar. I love their local selections on tap, their infused vodkas (the ones during the fall season are always incredible), and there's always unique cider options. Last time I had the Cloud City Opal Cider - It was dry with hints of orange and wood, I enjoyed it! They currently serve ramen and their famous grilled cheese. I REALLY hope they bring back the Jiffy Pop, that was always my favorite thing to order! They have art on the full review

More Reviews(81)


Monday 6PM - 3AM
Tuesday 6PM - 3AM
Wednesday 6PM - 3AM
Thursday 6PM - 3AM
Friday 6PM - 3AM
Saturday 6PM - 3AM
Sunday 6PM - 3AM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.