The Penny Pub
$ • Pubs
Hours:
79 W Main St, Bay Shore
(631) 969-4061
About The Penny Pub
Customers' Favorites
Homemade Fried Mac & Cheese with Chipotle Ranch for Dipping
Buffalo or Irish Whiskey BBQ Chicken Quesadilla
Penny Pub Chicken Club
The Penny Burger
Penny Pretzels
Fish & Chips
Dublin Dip
The Penny Pub Reviews
Ratings
Menu
Add a Menu
Hours
| Monday | 12PM - 4AM |
| Tuesday | 12PM - 4AM |
| Wednesday | 12PM - 4AM |
| Thursday | 12PM - 4AM |
| Friday | 12PM - 4AM |
| Saturday | 12PM - 4AM |
| Sunday | 10AM - 4AM |
People in Bay Shore Also Viewed
Henley's Village Tavern
American, Gastropubs, Bar
Brightwaters Inn - Neighborhood Bar & Grill
Pubs, Sports Bar, Vegan
Mustang Sally's
Bar & Grill, Pubs
The Penny Pub offers top-notch quality Irish American food, including Fish And Chips, Corn Beef Sliders, Irish Epinonada, and Sheppards Pie. The staff, Mike and Allison, are professional, kind, and have a great sense of humor, creating a welcoming atmosphere. However, some guests have mentioned issues with the bar service, such as not being offered specials or receiving drinks that were not ordered. Despite this, the food is consistently excellent, and the service is generally good. Some customers have noted that the tap beers can taste flat with a strange aftertaste, possibly indicating an issue with the beer lines. Overall, The Penny Pub provides a great dining experience with delicious food and friendly staff.