The Penny Pub


79 W Main St, Bay Shore
(631) 969-4061


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for The Penny Pub

Can't believe the kitchen is open till 2am . It's a small place like from the outside it looks small. I just got food to go. It was good but after eating the chicken wings , stomach kinda gutted. The grill cheese was ok, not the best. The mozzarella sticks were good. The tots were good to. Salads look like a salad for a champion. Overall, if ur looking for food late at night, this may be the place to go if your tired of fast food drive thru.

Local pub true to traditional Irish values. Mixed group and very accessible. Parking ample. Brunch on a Sunday was exceptional. Many local beers available. Tvs were plentiful. The Food was a good amount. There was the cutest large poodle ( care dog) oh my ! This place welcomes all ! A must try

ordered 4 burgers yesterday on door dash and couldnt be more dissapointed. the menu looked so promising but we ordered every burger Med and they all came very well done. there was not 1 drip of juice from these burgers. the flavor was also non existent and lacked seasoning.

More Reviews(84)


Monday 12PM - 4AM
Tuesday 12PM - 4AM
Wednesday 12PM - 4AM
Thursday 12PM - 4AM
Friday 12PM - 4AM
Saturday 12PM - 4AM
Sunday 12PM - 4AM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.