19 Best Pubs near Bay Shore

The Penny Pub Pubs • $
79 W Main St, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Homemade Fried Mac & Cheese with Chipotle Ranch for Dipping
Buffalo or Irish Whiskey BBQ Chicken Quesadilla
Penny Pub Chicken Club
The Penny Burger
Penny Pretzels
Fish & Chips
Dublin Dip

“great bartender great service“

4.1 Good63 Reviews
Mustang Sally's Bar & Grill • $
186 Howells Rd, Bay Shore

“If you know, you know. This place is the absolute best for locals. Bartenders are excellent and do a great job, even when the bar is packed. The food is amazing. The wings, kitchen sink burger, or tenders so good. Everything is very reasonably priced but be sure to bring cash as they don't take cards. The best part is the patrons are just good people too.“

4.6 Superb27 Reviews
Brightwaters Inn - Neighborhood Bar & Grill Pubs • $$
200 Orinoco Dr, Brightwaters - 1.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Fries
Blue Cheese Burger
Classic Burger
Mac & Cheese
Nachos

“Ordered Uber eats. Very pleased. Everything great. Burger, wrap and wings! Will be back.“

4.5 Superb61 Reviews
Old City Public House Pubs • $$
200 Portion Rd, Lake Ronkonkoma - 10.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

French Dip Sandwich with American Cheese & Fried Onions
Open Faced Pastrami Reuben with Fries
Old City Balsamic Chicken Platter
Mozzarella Sticks with Fries
Chicken Fingers blt Sandwich
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Classic Chicken Wings
French Onion Soup
Burger and Fries
The Big Pretzel

“Great place and atmosphere“

4.4 Superb103 Reviews
Grafton Street Irish Pub Gastropubs • $$
1261 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Hauppauge - 6.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Clams and Chips
Deep Fried Mushrooms
Mozzarella Sticks
Fish \u0026 Chips
Jalapeno Poppers
Shades of Green
Reuben Sandwich
Fish and Chips
Paddy's Burger
Clery's Clock

“We came in with a large group for dinner on a work trip. The service from the ladies behind the bar was fantastic. The food was great and it’s nice they have all day drink specials. Outdoor seating option with corn hole. A nice authentic pub and cool atmosphere. We will be back!“

4.4 Superb125 Reviews
Grey Meers Pub Pubs • $
86 Broadway Greenlawn, Greenlawn - 11.66 miles

“The new bartender Tom was amazing! It was my first time here in forever and I’m glad I stopped by. He was ON TOP OF EVERYTHING. I never had to wait for a drink despite a busy bar. He recommended places in the area for me to try and was so friendly the whole time. When I closed out, I asked him how long he’s been bartending… I was shocked to find out that he’s new to it. I will personally definitely come back here because of him.“

4 Good11 Reviews
Faraday's Of Smithtown Pubs • $$
17 W Main St, Smithtown - 9.36 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cajun Fried Calamari with Cajun Dipping Sauce
Crock of French Onion Soup
Mozzarella En Carozza
Chili with the Works
French Dip Sandwich
Stuffed Flank Steak
Garlic Steak Melt
Stuffed Mushrooms
Chicken Marsala
Buffallo Wings

“Had the absolute pleasure of experiencing Faraday’s and couldn’t wait to return to celebrate my birthday there!!The food is mouth watering!! The appetizers, entrees and deserts are outstanding!! Completely comforting food at its best!!The service is wonderful and Claudia what can I say she’s AMAZING!! Her hospitality is endless from the time she greets you to the end of your dinning experience ! Thank you Claudia and the staff at Faraday’s! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

4.2 Good81 Reviews
Henley's Village Tavern American • $$
184 Orinoco Dr, Brightwaters - 1.16 miles

Customers` Favorites

Whistle Pig Pulled Pork Sandwich
Pan Roasted Atlantic Salmon
Henley’S Warm Brownie
Beer Battered Meatballs
Tomato Basil Bisque
Henley's French Dip
Baked Potato Soup
Nashville Chicken
Chicken Sandwich
Tavern Burger

“Staff, food, service, atmosphere and drinks are all stellar!“

4.7 Superb63 Reviews
Riley Fibbers American • $$
148 Carleton Ave, East Islip - 2.92 miles

Customers` Favorites

Riley’S Grilled Chicken Wrap
Buffalo Chicken Risotto Bites
Skirt Steak Sandwich
The Pastrami Bomber
The Reuben Sandwich
Chicken Quesadilla
Pastrami Sandwich
Mozzarella Sticks
The Riley Burger
The Pub Burger

“I became a regular diner to Riley’s a couple of years ago. Gotta tell ya, the food is as good as any high restaurant I eat at and I dine out a lot. Fun, delicious, quality menu that has never once disappointed on any item, ever. Yes it is mostly basic pub food but so are 50% of the restaurants on Long Island now and Fibbers is perfect and priced more than fair. Can’t remember the servers but the two ladies are always right there, refills on drinks, food on time and always with a smile regardless how busy they are. Come back soon guys! You are the best of EI“

4.7 Superb86 Reviews
Irish Coffee Pub Fine Dining • $$$
131 Carleton Ave, East Islip - 2.94 miles

Customers` Favorites

Select Your Favorite Irish Coffee Pub Dessert
New York Strip Steak Mashed Potatoes
Center Cut Filet Mignon Au Poivre
Corned Beef and Cabbage Potatoes
Blueberry and Peach Cobbler
Dark Chocolate Pecan Pie
Sligo Au Gratin Style
Cream of Potato Soup
Clams Casino Royale
Chicken Harrington

“I want to thank the management and servers for such a Fabulous Thanksgiving meal. My elderly parent's need for accommodation was addressed. The service was extremely professional and courteous. All of the meals were deliciously prepared. I highly recommend this absolute Gem!“

4.6 Superb115 Reviews
Farrell's Tavern Bar • $
284 Ronkonkoma Ave, Lake Ronkonkoma - 9.31 miles

“Love Ira and the bowling game everyone is friendly“

4.8 Superb12 Reviews
Tobins II Pub Bar • $$
327 Smithtown Blvd, Lake Ronkonkoma - 9.44 miles
4.9 Superb8 Reviews
Shennanigans Cafe Bar • $$
228 Hawkins Ave, Lake Ronkonkoma - 9.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Black & Tan Onion Rings
Shrimp Wrap with Fries
Angus Steak Sandwich
Ahi Tuna Nachos
Basket of Fries
Shepherd's Pie
Cheddar Burger
Chicken Wings
Shepard Pie
Crab Cake

“Lived near this place and drove past it a million times for 10 yrs now... never went in. My hubby has with friends a few times. Wanted to get a bite so I suggested going there... glad we did! The food was fantastic! Lots of friendly faces behind and at the bar. This just turned into our new go to!“

4.5 Superb64 Reviews
Shakers Pub Bar • $$
4608 Sunrise Hwy South Service Rd, Oakdale - 7.12 miles

“I go there when Priscilla is there because the 1st time I went there she was amazing and made me feel like one of their own right away. I gave 5 stars for food because they let you order in and theres free food most of the time on fridays when I go. When i stay late theres always a good band or DJ. Definitely worth checking out!!“

4.5 Superb62 Reviews
Parsnip Lake House Bar • $$
432 Smithtown Blvd, Lake Ronkonkoma - 9.82 miles

“Remember Cheers where "everybody knows your name"? Snips is Cheers on steroids!! The bartenders are the BEST! The vibe is ELECTRIC and the back deck overlooking the picturesque lake is awe inspiring! The owners, Chris and Cari, know how to keep a crowd coming back!! They have become part of my extended family! Stop by..."kick the tires" and you'll thank me later! Snips is an oasis strategically place in the, proverbial, desert! You're welcome!!😎🥂🎵💥💥💥“

4.4 Superb67 Reviews
Dublin Jack Bar • $
426 Larkfield Rd, East Northport - 10.49 miles

“Amazing Little Spot, Pricesdrinks & Food are great , Service 💯! Highly recommend! ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️.“

4.1 Good22 Reviews
Lily's Babylon American • $$
345 Deer Park Ave, Babylon - 4.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

House Potato Soup of the French Onion
Burren BBQ Short Ribs
French Onion Soup
Kerry Corned Beef
Grilled Salmon
Buffalo Wing
Seafood Pasta
French Fries
Skirt Steak
Beef Tacos

“We had a retirement party upstairs in the Shannon room. Holly was amazing helping me through it all. The bartender and waitresses were all amazing even my guests said how nice they were. The food was Great! This is the 2nd party I had there first one was 10 years ago since then the room was renovated and looks beautiful.“

4.3 Superb185 Reviews
The Villager Bar • $$
262 Deer Park Ave, Babylon - 4.39 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Villager Burger and Sweet Potato Tots
Up in Smoke Burger with Tots
Fire Island Slaw Burger
Park Ave Steak Sandwich
Bang Bang Shrimp
Burger and Fries
Bavarian Pretzel
Breakfast Burger
Chicken Wings
Gouda Fries

“Great place to go very safe and friendly“

4.2 Good107 Reviews
Village Idiot Irish Pub American • $$
1487 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale - 5.78 miles

Customers` Favorites

Marinated Steak Tidbits
Buffalo Chicken Wings
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Fingers
Celtic Egg Rolls
Reubens Sandwich
Famous Wings
Disco Fries

“Great food great staff indoor outdoor dining“

3.9 Good91 Reviews

You May Also Like