Bayshore Bagels & Deli

222 5th Ave, Bay Shore
(631) 647-4626

Recent Reviews

Melanie Weisberg

Honestly this place needs to clean A LOT. It had a weird smell and my food tasted like straight grill. It has potential but it’s not hygienic and needs to be cleaned, I couldn’t even eat my meal because I could see grill pieces all over my egg sandwich, upsetting.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Miguel Ortiz

Always quick, budget friendly prices, and good food!Going to other places, like the one down the road, would charge me $3 more for the same order.

Mack

Food is amazing, owner is friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

D Lo

Let me tell you something about the man that owns this business. I used to be really strung out on drugs living behind the gas station right across the street. Most of the time I never had money for a meal but this guy would still always feed me. Sometimes it was the ONLY thing I had to eat for days. When I did have money, he wouldn't let me pay because he knew how rough of shape I was in. Fast forward a year later, I have a year clean and went in to buy the breakfast he used to make me. When I tried to pay with my card, his machine didn't accept AMEX and without a second thought he STILL just gave it to me. When you talk about community and delis on Long Island, this place is and will always be at the top of the charts. God bless this man and his family. AMAZING FOOD. AMAZING SERVICE. BUT MOST IMPORTANTLY HE CARES, which is more than people can say about most others.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tommy Chic

Great place for Bagels and you won't break the bank!

George Rice

It looks like a dump from the outside but the food is delicious and the bagels is great

Barritoes

These bagels are authentic NY style bagels from Queens but on Long Island. The owner is a funny guy and has a good heart! His prices are always reasonable and his food is always amazing!!

frankie velez

Very nice guy and great bagels I also love the blt from here something about the bacon ? lol don't judge it by the look u won't regret it

Richard Long

Nice blt with fresh tomatoes and lettuce. did not skimp on bacon either..

Jack McCullough

Always get a nice fresh bagel at a decent price.

Andrew

If I was able to I would give them no stars I would. Let's start things off with the rude azz owner.... he is so rude and nasty.. now I know why it's a beautiful Saturday morning and he has no customers.... I don't know how people go back to that bagel store.... I had way better bagels then his.....

Olivia Poudrier

The guy made my eggs literally perfect. Amazing sandwhich

Bonnie

The place needs a deep clean and better food handling hygiene. Also, please change the cutting board. It should not be that color. I ate my bagel against better judgement, and it was pretty good.

LAURA ORTIZ

The best bagel thank good service

Maria Velez

Best bagel & egg sandwich in town!!!

Load More