Butera's - Bay Shore

8 Third Ave, Bay Shore
(631) 328-4948

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Penne Vodka with Chicken and Chicken Meatballs
Butera’S Cauliflower Gluten Free Crust Pizza
Rare Seared Sesame Crusted Tuna Salad
Double Cut Pork Chop Scarpariello
Fettuccine Lump Crab Bay Scallop
Pistachio Encrusted Salmon
Rainbow Cookie Cheesecake
Chocolate Brownie Sundae
Linguine Seafood Scoglio
Pistachio Crusted Salmon

Menu

Appetizers
Burrata
Red, yellow grape tomatoes, grilled marinated red peppers, balsamic glaze, basil pesto, sundried tomato pesto, and crostini.
Mozzarella Frita
Breaded fresh mozzarella medallions and marinara sauce.
Pulled Short Rib and Herb Ricotta Crostini
Short rib ragu, herb ricotta, grana padano, and crispy onion.
Calamari Fritti
Fried crisp, lemon, and marinara sauce.
Baked Clams Oreganata
Baked whole top neck clams (6 pieces), bread crumb, and wild Greek oregano.
Tuna Crostini
Seared rare yellowfin tuna, caponata, fennel red pepper slaw, and remoulade.
Funghi Mozzarella
Sauteed whitecap, shiitake, king oyster mushrooms, fresh mozzarella, tomato, bruschetta points, and frisee Insalata.
Baked Eggplant Gratinato
Pomodoro sauce, fresh mozzarella, and toasted bread crumbs.
Shrimp Limoncello
Sauteed jumbo shrimp, lemon, garlic, and limoncello sauce, and toasted almonds.
Grilled Pesto Glazed Calamari
Grilled calamari, broccoli rabe, and cannellini beans.

Salads
Caesar Salad
Romaine, anchovies, crouton, classic dressing, and shaved grana Padano.
Butera Wedge Salad
Romaine, gorgonzola & bleu cheese dressing, bacon, grape tomato, olives, and croutons.
Arugula Salad
Fennel, fresh mint, pistachio, shaved ricotta Salata, lemon, and extra virgin olive oil.
Farro Salad
Roasted pepper, corn, grape tomato, fresh mozzarella, arugula, frisee, and hazelnut vinaigrette.
Mista Salad
Mixed greens, grape tomato, olives, cucumber, radish, and vinaigrette.
Warm Mushroom, Asparagus, and Roasted Pepper Salad
Sauteed mushroom, asparagus, roasted pepper, mixed greens, crouton, and vinaigrette.

Luncheon Focaccia Sandwiches
Grilled Chicken, Spinach, Roasted Pepper, and Mozzarella Sandwich
Served on freshly baked focaccia with mixed salad or French fries.
Classic Roasted Pepper, Mozzarella, Tomato, and Basil Pesto Sandwich
Served on freshly baked focaccia with mixed salad or French fries.
Chicken Cutlet BLT Sandwich
Breaded cutlet, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and basil aioli. Served on freshly baked focaccia with mixed salad or French fries.
Zucchini Parmesan Sandwich
Served on freshly baked focaccia with mixed salad or French fries.

Mains
Chicken Parmesan
Breaded chicken breast, marinara, mozzarella, and linguine.
Romano Crusted Chicken "Piccata" Style
Mushroom, lemon caper wine sauce, arugula, frisee, and roasted tomato Insalata, and crispy smashed potato.
Double Cut Pork Chop "Scarpariello"
Hatfield premium reserve pork, sausage, red and cherry peppers, potato, and rosemary balsamic wine sauce.
Baked Eggplant Gratinato
Baked eggplant, marinara, fresh mozzarella, bread crumb, basil, and linguine.
New York Strip Steak
Grilled certified Angus 14 oz boneless strip steak, grilled asparagus, crispy mashed potato, crispy onion, and chianti wine sauce. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meat, fish, shellfish, or shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions! Before placing your order, please inform your server if any person in your party has a food allergy.
Veal "Parmesan"
breaded veal, marinara, mozzarella, served with linguine
Low Carb Grilled Salmon
Light oil sauteed asparagus, broccolini, and sundried tomato. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meat, fish, shellfish, or shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions. Before placing your order, please inform your server if any person in your party has a food allergy.
Zucchini Parmesan
Crispy panko crusted zucchini, marinara, fresh mozzarella, and linguine.
Pistachio Crusted Salmon
Pistachio breadcrumb crust, mushroom, leeks, limoncello sauce, and tomato herb risotto cake. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meat, fish, shellfish, or shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions. Before placing your order, please inform your server if any person in your party has a food allergy.
Seared Sea Scallops
asparagus, leek, green peas and bacon risotto
Grilled Chicken, Spinach, and Roasted Pepper
Grilled chicken breast, mozzarella, and crispy smashed potato.
Tuna
Seared rare, sliced, sesame-crusted yellowfin tuna, eggplant, tomato, olives, potato, remoulade, and crispy capellini garnish. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meat, fish, shellfish, or shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions. Before placing your order, please inform your server if any person in your party has a food allergy.
Grilled Shrimp Caprese
jumbo shrimp, roasted tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil pesto, bread crumbs, orzo
Bronzino
Seared Bronzino filet, fennel, mushroom, and grape tomato farrotto, baby greens Insalata, and roasted tomato vinaigrette.

Salad Entrees
Rare Seared Sesame Crusted Tuna Salad
Seared sliced sesame crusted tuna, mixed greens, roasted peppers, crispy capellini garnish, and vinaigrette.
Balsamic-Glazed Salmon Medallions
Lentils, black beans, grape tomatoes, Moroccan spice, arugula, frisee, and vinaigrette.
Warm Chicken Frisee
Spinach, greens, roasted pepper, smoked mozzarella, and warm vinaigrette.
Warm Seared Sea Scallop
Greens, shiitake mushrooms, cannellini beans, grape tomato, warm white wine vinaigrette, and bruschetta points.
Grilled Shrimp
Greens, fresh mozzarella, grape tomato, onion, almonds, and bruschetta points.

Pasta Entrees
Rigatoni Butera
Fresh rigatoni, crumbled chicken sausage, green peas, pink sauce, and shaved grana Padano.
Rigatoni Short Rib Ragu
Fresh rigatoni, herb ricotta, crispy onion, slow-cooked tomato, short rib, and soffrito vegetable ragu.
Baked Gnocchi Rosa
Housemade ricotta gnocchi, spinach, mushroom, pink sauce, diced fresh mozzarella, and pecorino.
Nonna's Pan Baked Lasagna
Sausage, chicken meatballs, meat ragu, ricotta, and mozzarella.
Ravioli Pomodoro
Cheese ravioli, fresh Pomodoro sauce, diced fresh mozzarella, pecorino, and basil.
Penne Shrimp, Broccolini, and Asparagus
Fresh tomato, light side garlic, onion, and wine sauce.
Zucchini "Linguine"
Crumbled chicken sausage, asparagus, spinach, roasted tomato, and wine sauce.
Linguine Seafood "Scoglio"
Shrimp, scallops, clams, calamari, marinara, and basil.
Rigatoni Broccoli Rabe Chicken Meatball
Fresh rigatoni, cannellini bean, fresh tomato, garlic, and oil.
Linguine Vongole
Littleneck clams, garlic, parsley, and extra virgin olive oil.

Luncheon Grilled Pizza
Focaccia Pomodoro
house made focaccia, pomodoro sauce, pecprino, mozzarella, oregano, basil

Grilled Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil.
Chicken Meatball Pizza
Chicken meatball, ricotta, mozzarella, and marinara.
Pepperoni Piccante Pizza
pepperoni, cherry peppers, marinara, and mozzarella.
Butera's Cauliflower Gluten-Free Crust Pizza
Eggplant, caramelized onion, marinara, and mozzarella.
Focaccia Pomodoro
house made focaccia, pomodoro sauce, peccorino, mozzarella, oregano, basil

For the Table
Chicken Meatball Pot
Chicken meatballs, marinara, herb ricotta, and fresh mozzarella.
Housemade Fresh Ricotta
Extra virgin olive oil, fresh thyme, basil, pecorino, and charred ciabatta toast.
Butera's Sunday Salad
Iceberg, tomato, olives, cucumber, red onion, pepperoncini, and focaccia croutons.
Focaccia Pomodoro
Fresh Pomodoro sauce, pecorino, mozzarella, Greek oregano, and basil.

Sides
Chicken Meatball Marinara
Broccoli Garlic and Oil
Broccoli Rabe Garlic and Oil
Spinach Garlic and Oil
Crispy Smashed Rosemary and Pecorino Potatoes

Kids Menu
Penne Meatballs
Kid's Pizza
Chicken Finger and Fries
Grilled Chicken and Broccolini
Penne Broccolini
Penne Marinara
Penne Butter

Dessert
Chocolate Brownie Sundae
Rainbow Cookie Cheesecake

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: tripadvisor
+80 photos
Photo credit: tripadvisor
+79 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Pretty good food , nice size portions , had fried calamari good my chicken was decent a little oily , my husbands pork chop very good large portions. Good service , The restaurant is very noisy . Moderate prices .
October 2025
My husband and I had a very nice experience. The portion size of my salad and entree were enough for 2-3 people. My husband ordered baked claims which were generous in size and he liked them very much.
September 2025
We went on a Monday night and it was empty. Service was great and our server was attentive. Most of the food was good but unremarkable. I had the spicy crumbled veal lasagna. It was not traditional lasagna, but had smaller pieces of pasta. My one complaint was that I specifically asked about the sauce and was assured it was a red sauce, not a cream sauce, but that was not true. The sauce was OK, but not what I expected. My wife had the swordfish puttanesca. The pasta and sauce...
September 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Tula Kitchen - 41 E Main St
Fine Dining, Vegan, American, New American, Juice Bar & Smoothies
Bay Shore Bean - 47 E Main St
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Coffee, Vegan
Kiseki Sushi Hibachi & Lounge - 33 E Main St
Asian Fusion, Japanese, Sushi Bar

Butera's - Bay Shore

8 Third Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 328-4948