Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering
122 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore
(631) 665-6262
Customers' Favorites
Pan Seared Shinnecock Sea Scallops
Linguini with Lobster and Shrimp
Horseradish Crusted Grouper
Jumbo Gulf Shrimp Cocktail
Whole Live Maine Lobster
Broiled Seafood Platter
Grilled Atlantic Salmon
Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes
Crispy Fried Calamari
Halibut Dinner
Menu
Photos
+75 photos
+74 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Have never been disappointed. We went for the Oktoberfest prix fixe. Sauerbraten was generous, tender, nice sides. Double flounder fillet with homemade spaeztel, delicious. Delicious apple strudel to finish. Waitress was sweet. Reasonable prices in a lovely setting.
Wonderful dinner last night. Shared the mussels as an appetizer and they were delicious. The broth/sauce was so wonderful, great dipping with the toasted garlic bread. As a main dish, I really enjoyed the horseradish crusted grouper. It was done perfectly. My friend had the prime rib and it was a huge portion and cooked to her liking. The service was great, and our server brought our courses out in a timely manner. Carrot cake for dessert was very yummy! It was a beautiful night...
Captain Bill's is our family go-to for celebrations large and small. Hosted a wedding, annivesary party, and a rehearsal dinner at Captain Bill's and they never fail to please and go above and beyond to accomodate. Went there with my husband last night for a quiet celebration of an important family milestone. Food was great - my husband dove into the Oktoberfest menu and my scallops were cooked perfectly. Our server was lovely and didn't rush us out the door. All...
You May Also Like
Ditch Kitchen & Surf Bar - 25 Bayview Ave
![]()
Seafood, Bar, Tacos, Pet Friendly
Whalers - 124 Maple Ave
![]()
New American, Bar, American
Lakehouse - 135 Maple Ave
![]()
New American, American, Vegetarian