My favorite place to get cocktails on Fire Island and the food is always good.
S Western
The stench coming from behind the bar was unbearable!!! Bartender was attentive got a bottled beer cause I didn’t know how sanitary it was. I don’t drink beer .. it wasn’t low tied and I know fire island has drainage problems but this was not that. They need to use bleach and give it a good disinfectant cleaning.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 4
C B
This is for the restaurant/food only. We sat upstairs with a great view of the pier and perfect time to see the sunset. But the food definitely didn't add to the experience. We ordered a piña colada to start and it didn't have any alcohol. The server graciously offered to have it remade, the second one was a little better. I also ordered a ginger ale it was flat and tasted watered down. The food took a while to come out but the atmosphere made up for it. Keep in mind there is a loud bar very close by but we enjoyed the music. I had the fish and chips which were of course from frozen, there were two tiny pieces on top of a basket of fries. It was barely edible. The pasta was a decent portion and cooked well . The servers were nice but the overall service was slow. The prices are high and I would only go back to eat if I had no other options. There are 3 other restaurants around and they all have mixed reviews . I rather get a slice of pizza or go to Sand Castle and pay extra for slightly better food.
D Craig Marcum
Horrible food, the shrimp cocktail was a joke, looked like it was thrown on the plate, see where it lands, $19 for 6 small shrimp! Chicken tenders overcooked & hard & full of grease. Burgers...save ur $$ go to McDonald's Thank goodness for that view, not much else worth it. Stupid expensive for the quality!!
Jack Sullivan
It’s so sad what happened under new ownership. On a Monday, it took 20 min to get a waiter then he forgot to put in our appetizers. After eating our main course, we asked where they were (he said he had put them in) and he responds “there are ten tickets ahead of yours.” This place used to be great. And it has incredible entertainers - the best on the island. So it’s really sad what has happened.
Bryan Lopez
The food for brunch was terrible. Dry potatoes the chicken and waffles was a super small and dry. Very limited menu. Drinks were light and small. Has been better in previous years. Say yourself your money. We closed out and stop by cherry grove pizza.
Kelly Pereyra
Great fun!
Angie Ingham
What it is.
Tony Correnti
Went with my wife on Labor day. Thankful to those who worked on Labor day. What can you say that hasn't already been said? Such a fun atmosphere.
not a safe place for sober people! such a cute fun place with great drag but sadly our waiter was awful and should be fired! he gave our sober friend a pina colada with alcohol in it after we clarified not once but THREE times that it was non alcoholic. this is unacceptable. he then spilled a drink all over her and her bag and instead of apologizing, told her to be careful. our food (fried pickles + chicken tenders) took 50 minutes to come out. many other tables get theirs before we asked where ours was, it must’ve been forgotten. when i wanted to order a mocktail, (after ordering a regular drink before), he literally laughed and scoffed at me, like it was illegal and shameful to not be drinking. we’re really doing that, in 2024? absolutely unacceptable behavior. he also added an extra drink on our tab that wasn’t ours. our bill was $400 and the service was so unbelievably awful. wish i got his name, he was tall ish, tan, semi muscular, brown hair brown eyes, and was wearing an nyc baseball hat saturday the 17th. do better cherry’s!! /:
Food: 2
Service: 1
Peter L Brundige
Went to see a drag show . Always a fun time
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
yolanda jones
The one spot I always stop at for a drink and a quick bite after the beach
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Teresa T
Great vibes and a great time. Just don’t recommend the cherry sampler. 3 Mac n cheese bites. Such a small quantity for a $30 app. The burger and peanut butter cup was delicious.
My favorite place to get cocktails on Fire Island and the food is always good.
The stench coming from behind the bar was unbearable!!! Bartender was attentive got a bottled beer cause I didn’t know how sanitary it was. I don’t drink beer .. it wasn’t low tied and I know fire island has drainage problems but this was not that. They need to use bleach and give it a good disinfectant cleaning.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 4
This is for the restaurant/food only. We sat upstairs with a great view of the pier and perfect time to see the sunset. But the food definitely didn't add to the experience. We ordered a piña colada to start and it didn't have any alcohol. The server graciously offered to have it remade, the second one was a little better. I also ordered a ginger ale it was flat and tasted watered down. The food took a while to come out but the atmosphere made up for it. Keep in mind there is a loud bar very close by but we enjoyed the music. I had the fish and chips which were of course from frozen, there were two tiny pieces on top of a basket of fries. It was barely edible. The pasta was a decent portion and cooked well . The servers were nice but the overall service was slow. The prices are high and I would only go back to eat if I had no other options. There are 3 other restaurants around and they all have mixed reviews . I rather get a slice of pizza or go to Sand Castle and pay extra for slightly better food.
Horrible food, the shrimp cocktail was a joke, looked like it was thrown on the plate, see where it lands, $19 for 6 small shrimp!
Chicken tenders overcooked & hard & full of grease.
Burgers...save ur $$ go to McDonald's
Thank goodness for that view, not much else worth it.
Stupid expensive for the quality!!
It’s so sad what happened under new ownership. On a Monday, it took 20 min to get a waiter then he forgot to put in our appetizers. After eating our main course, we asked where they were (he said he had put them in) and he responds “there are ten tickets ahead of yours.” This place used to be great. And it has incredible entertainers - the best on the island. So it’s really sad what has happened.
The food for brunch was terrible. Dry potatoes the chicken and waffles was a super small and dry. Very limited menu. Drinks were light and small. Has been better in previous years. Say yourself your money. We closed out and stop by cherry grove pizza.
Great fun!
What it is.
Went with my wife on Labor day. Thankful to those who worked on Labor day. What can you say that hasn't already been said? Such a fun atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
I enjoyed the nachos
Restaurantji Recommends
Hedda and Portia are sublime.
Vegetarian options: The shows are spectacular.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burger
not a safe place for sober people! such a cute fun place with great drag but sadly our waiter was awful and should be fired! he gave our sober friend a pina colada with alcohol in it after we clarified not once but THREE times that it was non alcoholic. this is unacceptable. he then spilled a drink all over her and her bag and instead of apologizing, told her to be careful. our food (fried pickles + chicken tenders) took 50 minutes to come out. many other tables get theirs before we asked where ours was, it must’ve been forgotten. when i wanted to order a mocktail, (after ordering a regular drink before), he literally laughed and scoffed at me, like it was illegal and shameful to not be drinking. we’re really doing that, in 2024? absolutely unacceptable behavior. he also added an extra drink on our tab that wasn’t ours. our bill was $400 and the service was so unbelievably awful. wish i got his name, he was tall ish, tan, semi muscular, brown hair brown eyes, and was wearing an nyc baseball hat saturday the 17th. do better cherry’s!! /:
Food: 2
Service: 1
Went to see a drag show . Always a fun time
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
The one spot I always stop at for a drink and a quick bite after the beach
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great vibes and a great time. Just don’t recommend the cherry sampler. 3 Mac n cheese bites. Such a small quantity for a $30 app. The burger and peanut butter cup was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burger, Crispy Chicken Sliders, Tuna Melt
Loading...