Fatfish

28 Cottage Ave, Bay Shore
(631) 666-2899

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Maura

Service and ambience were wonderful. The lobster but was extremely expensive and not very good. The lobster was chopped into small pieces and was actually tasteless. Also there was very little bacon.

Niasmom Mays

Amazing meal, Thanks Chef Brian

Gleb Beleavski

Excellent food and drinks. Amazing views

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

S Z

Definitely

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Laura

We celebrated our anniversary having an early dinner on the patio. The scenery is so beautiful, romantic and serene there. We both had the salmon which was delicious, and our server was very attentive. We both love Fat Fish, and I even had one of my husband's birthday celebrations there.

Howard Levine

The food and service was great at fatfish.

Natalia

 the food and ambience was amazing. The views were incredible slightly after appetizers. We felt quite rushed by the waitress, which I did not appreciate since it was a birthday dinner with me and my girlfriends but everything else was excellent.

William

Great views of the great south bay! Great food, service and price! Nice way to relax and enjoy with friend's.

Gail

Beautiful evening with a beautiful view. Friendly & attentive service. Food was mostly good but I had the SEARED SCALLOP MEUNIÉRE. The scallops were good but it had sauteed spinach atop parsley orzo. I don't know why there was a vinegarette tasting dressing on the spinach. It detracted from a pricey dish & seemed unnecessary. I would have preferred just a simple sauteed spinach. Otherwise it was a great experience.

russell

We have been here several times. Always very good. When people want water view this place is literally on the water. Nice Tapas menu as well.

Susanne

Food and service were great! It was a little noisy. We sat out in the outdoor space (plastic walls) which was pleasant even though it was raining a little. I would recommend!!

Mike

Fat fish has always been a favorite there view is gorgeous to the great South Bay! There drinks are amazing! The food and specials are outstanding!!

Kerry

Portions were ridiculously small. Service was slow. The main reason to dine here is for the water view and the plastic sheeting over the windows were closed, understandably due to rain but nobody offered to reopen them when the rain stopped. It was hot and uncomfortable.

JoAnn

Great outdoor venue! We lunched out on the back deck overlooking the water. Just beautiful. The food was delish! The French Dip sandwich was very tasty, as well as the garden salad. Key lime pie, a delight! Will definitely be back.

George

We really enjoyed our time at this wonderful reesataurant right on the Great South Bay. We had appetizers, drinks (martini/beer) main dinner (Lobster, Branzino, Lobster Bisque, Shrimp) and dessert . The food was outstanding, the location was outstanding, and our waitress/server - Kathy - was superior! This was our first time here (myself, my wife, and my adult son who was in town) - and we highly recommend Fatfish and will return again!

Loading...