Fatfish
28 Cottage Ave, Bay Shore
(631) 666-2899
Customers' Favorites
East Coast and West Coast Oysters
Vanilla Bean Créme Brulee
Alaskan King Crab Legs
Whole Maine Lobster
Mushroom Gnocchi
Seafood Salad
Lobster Bisque
Lobster Salad
Fish & Chips
Crab Cakes
Menu
Photos
+47 photos
+46 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We really enjoyed our time at this wonderful reesataurant right on the Great South Bay. We had appetizers, drinks (martini/beer) main dinner (Lobster, Branzino, Lobster Bisque, Shrimp) and dessert . The food was outstanding, the location was outstanding, and our waitress/server - Kathy - was superior! This was our first time here (myself, my wife, and my adult son who was in town) - and we highly recommend Fatfish and will return again!
We've eaten at Fat Fish many times but this was the first time we utilized the new reservation option. So delighted knowing our table was waiting and ready for us when we arrived. Seated outside directly over the water. Ordered the beef carpaccio and mushroom gnocchi to start. Then the tuna (rare) and the open ravioli for entrees. Everything was delicious and cooked to perfection. Key lime pie for dessert was a special summer treat. Will return again using the reservation...
Cool rainy night. My husband was parking the car. I was inside with the other couple of our foursome Restaurant at the time was empty but the receptionist would not seat 3 80 -year - olds till the 4 th person( my spouse) came in . Ridiculous!!!
You May Also Like
Ditch Kitchen & Surf Bar - 25 Bayview Ave
![]()
Seafood, Bar, Tacos, Pet Friendly
Whalers - 124 Maple Ave
![]()
New American, Bar, American