Goody Two Shoes

42 E Main St, Bay Shore
(631) 647-4856

Recent Reviews

Sort by
marie polinice

Me and my husband started going to this place for drinks and desserts, every time we go the staff is always very friendly and polite. We kept going back, their food is very agreeable and flavorful. Service is A plus in particular Jadon, and other waiters as well. Goody two shoes is a cool spot for us to hang out eat, drink and relax or watch a game in a very warmth environment and we are always acknowledged by their friendly and professional staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tara Nicosia

The restaurant is designed wonderfully.
It has ALOT of potential. However I think the menu needs a revamp. And I’m saying because I’m a chef owner operator w 25 years in the biz.
Staff was pleasant …

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

Kevin H

Ordered some smash burgers from Good Two Shoes. Had 2 family members sick and throwing up after eating from this place. Tried to give them the courtesy of a phone call since we have been there numerous times in the past. Girl who took the call was dismissive and was rude. Never again will we go here and do not recommened it to anyone interested in trying it.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Katherine K

Great food, great drinks and great atmosphere! Love the dirty pickle martini and the smashburgers are great for a late night. Bartenders are always friendly!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dylan Schulz

Came here for lunch, this place has a nice atmosphere and the menu is diverse. Everything we had (short rib mac&cheese, grilled chicken sandwich, yucca fries) was very good. The service was good and staff is attentive and pleasant, I would recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stacy G

The ambiance was perfect. the Service was exceptional 👏

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

martir s

this resturant was great, at first we werent gonna go because the name sounded funny lol but we gave it a try we saw that they had pupusas btw theyre were great we had a nice blonde lady wish i knew her name but she was working so hard bartending/serving all at once shows how much of a great worker she is. we had the grilled chicken royale with yuca fries which were also very great over all this place was very good and service was amazing and fast, we went on june 23 around 3pm for lunch and it was great i highly recommend this place😁

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kaylo-Ren

Went here with a group of friends last night to get a drink after dinner and bouncers at the front let us in at first but proceeded to tell my husband after he was let in that he was wearing shorts and we couldn’t stay because they had a strict dress code? I mentioned that they didn’t have a dress code on the website. Very disappointing and weird!!! I guess don’t come into this establishment if you’re wearing shorts because you’ll get kicked out even after they check your id and then let you in only to come over to you 5 seconds later and tell you to leave because of what you’re wearing!!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Del Voltaire

I had my birthday in the back. 100/10 experience the staff made everything so easy. I recommend booking your next event here asap!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Thomas

After heading back from watching some of the air show my wife and I decided to grab some drinks and apps before heading home. Melanie was the bartender and had a great personality and attentive. The feta balls and chopped cheese tacos are out of this world.
While I live quite a bit away and don’t make it to Bayshore as often as I’d like. This place will always be a must stop!! Keep up the good work.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer Huey

We love this place. Hidden gems

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Justin Himes

Tons of nicer bars in bayshore & babylon area. Its a bar with a seating in the back room but a weird dead vibe back there thats disconnected. I just wish they had a 2nd bar back there because it took me 17 minutes of standing, leaning over the bar and waving my hands as bartenders ignored me for people that just walked up. Im pretty chill and relaxed and began my flag down in a patient and discreet manner but If you see a grown man with money or a card in their hand, alone and leaning over the bar, it might be a sign they need drinks. Had a table of girls I came with waiting for a round. I finally had to get obnoxious and yell at a guy behind the bar and nearly grab him to finally get some drinks. (Sounds fun right?)
If they improve their attention to the line up of customers, add more help or open a 2nd bar, they might be decent.

To the owner: When it comes down to it, this bar just ain't got it like that to front tough over criticism of their poorly handled bar. No one likes having to get obnoxious in order to get a drink. Managing your attentiveness when there is a crowd is 101 to being a good night spot. It will keep people from moving on by 11pm to other spots.
You are probably right though, this bar ain't for me or anyone looking to spend money on service and a fun vibe. Not when powerhouses in Huntington & babylon will operate at peak busy and never feel like I'm fighting to get a round. Good luck 👍

Michael Anderson

Great pub, great atmosphere & excellent food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Quinn

My birria egg rolls was real bad thinner then finger size and they was not crispy and the meat was super dry and had no flavor at all and the sauce was just spicy with no flavor!!! My friend burger was like a kids size with less fires then a kids meal!!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birria Egg Rolls

Makayla McDonald

Gabby was amazing ! Great drinks, great food good vibes ! 10/10 would come back again

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...