Goody Two Shoes

42 E Main St, Bay Shore
(631) 647-4856

Recent Reviews

Donathan D.

The service and the ambiance were nice. The music was amazing we were dancing having a great time. We had a few shots and drinks and it wasn't that expensive. It was $135 for the 4 of us. The wings were okay I would I have to try them when it's not late night as it was only bar food but the fries were pretty good.

Janette Carosone

We came here for appetizers and drinks. Food was good, drinks were awesome. They had a non alcoholic drink menu as well as drinks with alcohol. Service was excellent ? a must try!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Deviled Eggs, Small Wings, Shortrib Mac

Mike Buonocore

Hidden little gem along Montauk Hwy. Do try the yucca fries! Bartenders are skilled cocktail makers.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alex Stubbings

It’s nice but not Finley’sEverything else is great!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicholas Provenzano

Gabby was our bright young ambitious server was full of knowledge, personality and witty. She definitely made our experience. Top notch!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Small Wings

Kaivona P.

This place is incredible from the food to the service...I cannot wait to go back! I came here with my daughter and my sis. We parked in the back lot and sat in the middle booth seating area. There was a pretty obnoxious party or large group in the front of house which was a bit annoying but whatevs My sis ordered the wings. She got the ones with general tsos sauce . I'm a spicy sauce girl so I wouldnt have ordered it but they were cooked perfectly and THAT GREEN WASABI DIPPING SAUCE omgggggg FIRREEEEEE!! She also got the mac. It was perfectly aldente . I just recommend giving it a good stir before your first bite because the best part of the sauce settles at the bottom of the cast iron. I got the fried chicken sandwich! AMAZING! Crazy part is I usually like a lot of toppings. This one is simple these pickles and sauce on potato bread and wow I demolished it! Fried perfectly! That batter whew Soo good. Yucca fried yummmm My daughter ordered a side of bacon and fries and they made it so fun for her and that bacon is fantastic! Hunter was our server and he was so attentive. I hate when ppl don't talk to my daughter as if she is her own person and he addressed her politely, asked her what she wanted and checked on her to make sure she enjoyed everything. Honestly we might have interacted with 3 or 4 staff members and the whole crew kind funny and cool. Literally the ONLY unpleasant part about this was that the section of the booth that my sister was sitting in was completely sunken in. As in she sank so deep into the cushion she had to sit at the edge. They either need to replace that part or add a cushion on top. Otherwise, I'm definitely coming back! Absolutely!

Steve Alliano

Bartenders need to step up....

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 2

Lisa DB

Shared a few drinks and apps with my friend for a girls night, had the wings and queso fries, food was good, staff was friendly. Very cute inside and clean. A bit pricey, but what isn't now a days? Will be going back to try more of the menu and definitely get more wings.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Redwhitepapi93

Came here for the Arsenal game in the morning. Proper mayhem here in a good way. Good breakfast burgers and beer selections. Great atmosphere!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brunch Burger

amanda kayleigh

I’ve never been here before and was hesitant but our waitress gabby made the experience fantastic!!!! She was so so sweet and fun I will definitely be returning just for her !!! Give that girl a RAISE!

Service: 5

Anastasia C.

Went for dinner and trivia with a friend. Was quickly seated quickly on a Tuesday night. Both of us had burgers which were good. Nice selection of drinks and mocktails which was nice so those who can't drink don't feel left out. Was a little loud for me but that's partially due to the trivia which was a fun extra.

Katherine M.

Small space but fills up- drinks are good, decent price. Only met up with friends for a drink here so can't comment on food. Service was great!

Jeffrey Norwood

Stumbled upon this place as our first two choices were closed. I'm so happy that they were. Outstanding service and good food. Drinks made to perfection. When I return here for business, I will return here for dinner.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Truffle Honey, Brunch Burger, Fried Chicken Sandwich

John Halter

Fried chicken sandwich was good. Cobb salad good also. Beer selection kinda mediocre but they did have Utica Club on tap which is kinda rare. Server was excellent.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fried Chicken Sandwich

Michael

Bartender with beard told gay friend that being gay is not welcome in their establishment. Will never return here.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Load More