Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar

1701 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore
(631) 647-7588

Recent Reviews

Mario Guzman

Best Cajun seafood in Long Island best service . Definitely recommend our server Ivan was the best

desiree windley

The first 3 drink choices of wine and Rose' they did not have (it's only 3pm) and the bathrooms were filthy. Our waitress Angelique was amazing and attentive. The Manager wanted no parts of being there. Not a people person. Don't think I will be back.

Angelica Diaz

This place deserves 0 stars I can’t even believe how horrible the food and service was with all these good reviews.. absolutely no flavor in sauce, gingerale tasted like sink water, kids chicken tenders were red and bloody on inside, and red sangria tasted like water down cheap wine.. on top of everything the place wasn’t even busy and server was non existent.. the amount of times I had to walk to the front for help,someone I do believe who was the manager or owner did come over (we did not request for them to we just wanted to pay and get out but sever was MiA) when I told him sauce was watery he said that was bc I ordered a watery sauce, basically looked at me like I was the crazy one .. McDonald’s is a 5 star restaurant compared to this place .. do not recommend

J H

We had to actually drive to get take out, Grub Hub said closed. Then called and asked are you open and explained, the person said use the app. Tried the app, didn't work as well.When we ate the food wasn't even close to Cajun, below good to say the least.The appetizer was put in your mouth and spit out.Only the sauce was above average.

D Lipp (DüG)

We really liked our meal, but for a Friday night and as a restaurant on the Mall in December it was really quite empty.Food was very good, they had a crab legs and shrimp special which was what we were going to order anyone so it was a good value to boot.I hope they can stay open longer.

Emil Iannone

Delicious and we had so much fresh seafood we brought it home and had it for dinner again the next night.

Claudia Aguirre Subauste (PaperPens)

The food was delicious, the servers very kind and friendly. The place is very neat , clean and pleasant to be in .

Hans Muelthaler

My wife took us out to eat at Hook and Reel. Food was great, price was reasonable compared to other Seafood restaurants. Servers worked hard to get our orders right. I recommend The Shrimp mini boil. Price is right and delish

knotless way

Never will I eat here again . I asked for the sauce on the side and they gave it to me directly on the food. The food was way to spicy so I asked for a new order . They basically rinsed off the food over cooking it and gave it back to me with food that was chewed on. The waiter stated that’s how they do it and had the audacity to have a attitude when he made the mistake in the first place. I didn’t want to try again so I just opted out of paying. So disappointed in the level of service at this location.

jeremy B

Great seafood and seasoned to your spice level.

Ken Glanton

Been there 3 times since they opened. Every time I've been I've had a great experience. Good is really good. Well I've only got one selection but switched up the flavors. Oh yeah, can't forget the oysters... absolute must. Staff was very friendly and my food came out expeditiously. Granted it was in the middle of the week, nonetheless, order was prompt. And the prices aren't that bad. I'll continue to go back again and again.

Cecilia Govea

Delicious, food came quick, server need it to be a little bit on top of drinks.

Domenica J.

I have been to so many Cajun seafood boil places and the shrimp is always chewy and lacks flavor. I was hesitant on getting shrimp but it came with one of the preselected boil bags so I had no choice. Best Cajun shrimp I have ever had and when I go back, i'm getting extra.

Bernadette

We have never been disappointed with the food! We order for delivery and the food is always hot and fresh! Better than some seafood places in the area. The Lobster Bisque is the best! You won’t be disappointed

Renee B.

Here's the Scoop: Our family went to this restaurant to celebrate my husband's birthday. We were quickly seated. The ambiance of the restaurant is low lighting and seating is comfortable. Nice size booths also for large groups. Our waiter Kevin was very attentive and helped with ordering. I really like a waiter that's truthful. We ordered appetizers which were fried calamari and crab bites. Delicious!!! Both were seasoned well and fried to perfection. The crab cake had lots of crab and a little filling. I like that! Our entrees consisted of lemon pepper chicken wing basket! Catfish basket and my honey & I had the boils. The boils had king crab clusters, shrimp, potatoes and corn. You can choose your seasoning and choose add ons. I added broccoli and my honey added sausages and extra corn. It was fingerlickin gooooood. At your table there's a supply of napkins, bibs, tools to crack your crab, hand wipes, gloves etc. and a large bucket sits in the middle of your table for crab shells etc. Kevin was very kind and i definitely would ask for him when I return. I and my family enjoyed the food, music selections and conversations. We left happy and full. Kevin even gave my husband a fabulous slice of cheesecake that he stated was on the house for his birthday. Yelp family check this restaurant out if you like Cajun seafood. Yummylicious!!!

Load More

Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar

1701 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 647-7588