Nicky's On the Bay
150 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore
(631) 206-3311
Customers' Favorites
Lobster Roll Sweet Potato Fries and Cole Slaw
West Coast Oysters on the Half Shell
Nicky's Fried Calamari
East Coast Oysters
Sauteed Spinach
Fish and Chips
Seafood Bisque
Clam Chowder
Shrimp Tacos
Seafood
Menu
Photos
+61 photos
+60 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
My wife took me to Nicky's on the Bay for Father's Day. Our waitress was excellent. Very friendly, helpful and professional. We had no issues with her at all; However, the burgers we ordered were average and the lobster bisque was so bad I couldn't eat much of it - left most of it in the bowl. When our friendly waitress came back to the table and noticed most of the soup still in the bowl she asked me if I liked the soup and I told her I didn't like it. Told...
This place was incredible! I was here for a baby shower. First, the view is breathtaking and the restaurant is beautiful. The food was exceptional and I have not stopped thinking about it since. The service was fantastic. The staff was friendly and attentive. I will absolutely be back and have recommended it to everyone I've spoken to.
We hosted a bridal shower there and it went amazing! Haley was so helpful and patient. The food was phenomenal. The water views were phenomenal. The staff was excellent. It went better than I could’ve ever imagined. I got a lot of positive feedback from people on how wonderful the restaurant was and how delicious the food was. Definitely recommend!
You May Also Like
Lakehouse - 135 Maple Ave
![]()
New American, American, Vegetarian
Whalers - 124 Maple Ave
![]()
New American, Bar, American