Nicky's On the Bay
150 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore
(631) 892-6694
Customers' Favorites
Lobster Roll Sweet Potato Fries and Cole Slaw
West Coast Oysters on the Half Shell
Nicky's Fried Calamari
East Coast Oysters
Sauteed Spinach
Fish and Chips
Seafood Bisque
Clam Chowder
Shrimp Tacos
Seafood
Menu
Photos
+69 photos
+68 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Jade was the most amazing waitress. Attentive from the beginning to the end and always with a smile. My wife and I absolutely loved her and hands down best food and service. We found our new place!
We had a great meal at Nicky's! The bisque, street corn and hot lobster rolls were all amazing! Megan was our server...she is the best!!!! She kept checking in without making us feel rushed, and anticipated all our needs! She was funny and personable...will definitely request her again. Sitting and watching the water can't be beat!
You May Also Like
The Lakehouse - 135 Maple Ave
![]()
New American, American, Vegetarian
Whalers - 124 Maple Ave
![]()
New American, Bar, American
Megan our server was so friendly, welcoming, and warm…we would come back just to see her! Amazing service, the seafood was fresh and delicious. A great place to keep on your local radar, you will not be disappointed! Thank you again Megan <3