Nicky's On the Bay
150 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore
(631) 206-3311
Customers' Favorites
Lobster Roll Sweet Potato Fries and Cole Slaw
West Coast Oysters on the Half Shell
Nicky's Fried Calamari
East Coast Oysters
Sauteed Spinach
Fish and Chips
Seafood Bisque
Clam Chowder
Shrimp Tacos
Seafood
Menu
Photos
+53 photos
+52 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Beautiful location, great to watch the sunset. The prix fixe menu being offered now is an amazing bargain with lots of great choices. The food is very good, service excellent, take advantage of this before they close for the season!
Party on the rooftop,
Nick was extremely accommodating and flexible. Service top notch , Buffet was well presented, and maintained. Bartenders friendly and made everything and everything.
A big Thank you to Nick and the entire team that help make our party, a party to remember.
Nick was extremely accommodating and flexible. Service top notch , Buffet was well presented, and maintained. Bartenders friendly and made everything and everything.
A big Thank you to Nick and the entire team that help make our party, a party to remember.
We so enjoyed our first visit to Nicky’s on Sunday . The atmosphere was fantastic. A gorgeous view and we loved watching all the ferrys and boats passing by. Our server Kat was the best. She offered up suggestions to us as it was our first time and she was on point. I’m not much of a seafood eater so she suggested the short ribs and they were like butter. Appetizers of mussels and clams and even the shrimp cocktail were so fresh and just the right way to start the meal....
You May Also Like
Lakehouse - 135 Maple Ave
![]()
New American, American, Vegetarian
Whalers - 124 Maple Ave
![]()
New American, Bar, American