Pecado Mexican

49 W Main St, Bay Shore
(631) 992-7717

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dr . Leonard

Amazing night with fantastic service. Made my family feel comfortable the entire night, while also attending to our needs at every moment. Sofia our waitress made my wife's night and was tremendous!

Ivan

Really good food, everything was fresh and tasty. Service was fantastic. We sat in the back which is open but covered and heated in early October at 7pm and it was totally comfortable. In leaving through the restaurant inside in the front, that seemed loud and would have been less enjoyable for a sit down dinner with friends. So highly recommend and sit in the back.

Dawn

2nd visit just as disappointing as the first. Entrees came out before the appetizers so they took them back. Shrimp in the cerviche were mushy and still partially raw. Pretty sure they still served us the original Entrees. The tortilla soup and chips and salsa were the highlight of the meal.

Gerri

We've been to this restaurant several times and we've never had a bad experience. Our waiter was not attentive at all. He barely even came over to us. The manager was more attentive to us and I've never had that happen and they weren't even that busy.

Kristine

They had a dj that was so loud that we could not hear each other. When we went to switch out table to the outside patio, the music was turned up there as well. Our waitress said that the dj plays it loud to drown out the sound of the people talking. My friend went to the manager, who had the dj lower the music, but it was still quite loud. The manager did come to our table and was attentive on how everything was, but it did not make for a nice dining experience. As there is no dance floor and it is not a place with a bar crowded with young 20 somethings, it baffles me as to why a dj is even necessary.

Dane

Had a great time. Clean great staff and food was amazing!! Compliments to the chief as well

Michelle Alexandra

Me and my partner have been coming here for many years, and decided that it was the perfect place to celebrate our engagement with my family. We made a reservation on OpenTable as usual, because it could be a little crowded. Last night was supposed to be a very special celebration for us, and instead turned into a very disheartening experience. Me and my fiancé walked in first and grabbed our table while we waited for my family, ordered 2 drinks and got started with choosing our entree. I see my mother at the door and it looked like she was having trouble getting in. My stepfather, who does not speak a lot English, looked confused and started apologizing to me. I was confused, and the security guard told me he can’t come in because he is wearing an Under Armour tank top. My mother then pointed out men at the bar for me and said they are wearing something similar. I understand that you’re doing your job as a security, but don’t humiliate us without checking your surroundings. If tanks weren’t allowed, then the men at the bar should have been told to leave. Were they regulars? His friends? It would have been one thing if he was nice about it but he was so aggressive to my family. I became so aggravated but instead of arguing with the guy, we took our belongings and left because I lost my taste to this place completely. While walking away, the security guard yelled “take a hike” with his friend. That hike costed you a lot of years with us. We’ve been coming here about once every month or two for the last 3 years. That hike costed you a lot of money we were going to put into this establishment for an engagement party or bridal shower or baby shower. I was so excited to let my family know after our dinner that this was going to be a spot for a celebration, and now we have to look elsewhere all because a security guard thought he was macho enough dehumanize my stepfather in front of a crowd.

Karen

Take note if going on a Friday night after 7pm there is a DJ in the main dining room which means you can't have any kind of conversations without yelling. It was very frustrating.

Katherine Castano

We had such a great experience at Pecado. Our server, Emely, was friendly, attentive, and made us feel truly welcomed from the moment we sat down. She gave great recommendations and had such a positive energy the whole time. The food was delicious, and the overall vibe of the restaurant was awesome. We definitely will be back and requesting the same server if she is available.

Alyssa Nanfro

We had a fantastic experience at Pecado! The food was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented—but what really made our visit stand out was our server, Sofia. She was friendly, attentive, and made us feel right at home. Her service truly elevated our night. Highly recommend and we’ll definitely be back!

Jack Bosko

Absolutely love this place. The food and service is great. Emely is the best and always makes the experience amazing.10/10

Kyle Slesh

Authentic flavors and great vibes! The dishes were fresh and full of flavor, and the margaritas hit the spot. Service was friendly and quick. Will definitely be back to try more of the menu. Highly recommend!

Tracy

Food was outstanding. Service was great. Drinks were delicious. The churros are my favorite. The mahi mahi tacos were crispy and flavorful. Very happy with dinner.

Holly Dewey

I cannot say enough wonderful things about our experience, and it was all thanks to our incredible waitress, Jasmin. From the moment we sat down, she made us feel genuinely welcomed and taken care of. Her energy was warm, her recommendations were spot-on, and her timing was flawless — always there when we needed something, but never intrusive.

What really stood out was how effortlessly she balanced being friendly and professional. You could tell she truly cared about creating a great experience, not just for us but for every table she served. She made our meal feel special, and we left with full stomachs and big smiles.

If you’re lucky enough to have Jasmin as your server, you’re in for a treat. She’s a true gem and a huge asset to the team. We’ll definitely be back — and hoping to be seated in her section again!

Lesego

The wagyu steak was wayyyy too salty. Next time I'm ordering without salt. Anyway, great restaurant! Great service and drinks 🍹 and ambience

Loading...