Pecado Mexican

49 W Main St, Bay Shore
(631) 992-7717

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Katherine Castano

We had such a great experience at Pecado. Our server, Emely, was friendly, attentive, and made us feel truly welcomed from the moment we sat down. She gave great recommendations and had such a positive energy the whole time. The food was delicious, and the overall vibe of the restaurant was awesome. We definitely will be back and requesting the same server if she is available.

Alyssa Nanfro

We had a fantastic experience at Pecado! The food was fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented—but what really made our visit stand out was our server, Sofia. She was friendly, attentive, and made us feel right at home. Her service truly elevated our night. Highly recommend and we’ll definitely be back!

Jack Bosko

Absolutely love this place. The food and service is great. Emely is the best and always makes the experience amazing.10/10

Kyle Slesh

Authentic flavors and great vibes! The dishes were fresh and full of flavor, and the margaritas hit the spot. Service was friendly and quick. Will definitely be back to try more of the menu. Highly recommend!

Tracy

Food was outstanding. Service was great. Drinks were delicious. The churros are my favorite. The mahi mahi tacos were crispy and flavorful. Very happy with dinner.

Holly Dewey

I cannot say enough wonderful things about our experience, and it was all thanks to our incredible waitress, Jasmin. From the moment we sat down, she made us feel genuinely welcomed and taken care of. Her energy was warm, her recommendations were spot-on, and her timing was flawless — always there when we needed something, but never intrusive.

What really stood out was how effortlessly she balanced being friendly and professional. You could tell she truly cared about creating a great experience, not just for us but for every table she served. She made our meal feel special, and we left with full stomachs and big smiles.

If you’re lucky enough to have Jasmin as your server, you’re in for a treat. She’s a true gem and a huge asset to the team. We’ll definitely be back — and hoping to be seated in her section again!

Lesego

The wagyu steak was wayyyy too salty. Next time I'm ordering without salt. Anyway, great restaurant! Great service and drinks 🍹 and ambience

Kasey Giarro

We had the pleasure of having Jasmin as our server - she was excellent! She made great suggestions, she was attentive and so friendly and kind. The food was delicious and everything tasted fresh. We truly loved our experience here with Jasmin!

Jessy Telles

beyond amazing experience I highly reccomend coming here. I loved the service & the food. Our waiter Jasmin attended us very well and she was super fun.

Kenneth

Food was delicious and service was great- a little pricey but worth it if you like authentic Mexican cuisine

Fredric

Always consistently awesome. Drinks, food, service and ambiance make for a really nice time out.

Francesca

Delicious food. Waiter was knowledgeable and helpful when choosing drinks and food. Great service. Beautiful restaurant

Arleen

Overall a fantastic experience Our server was wonderful Food was superb The menu was diverse My one and only issue was that the music was SO LOUD Difficult to carry on a conversation

Adele

Very salty. food godd amd priced well. Expensive drinks. Very loud so expect to scream if you want dinner conversation

Opentable Diner

Great place, vibe was great and food was excellent. Only complaint I had was the table they sat us at was so small but we had asked to move to a bigger table and they accommodated which was amazing.

Loading...