Ok now this place blew my taste buds!!!! The owner was sooooo kind and recommended the spinach , mushroom , truffle slice ,,,, woooooow that’s all i got to say and the vodka slice to die for !!! I’m so glad i had to go to mavis and wait and found this delicious place I’m going to say this is my 3rd favorite pizzaPlace now , THATS HUGE !!! ??❤️
Dominique Romain
Great service! Reasonable prices! Great slices! Need I say more.
Erin Daly
Best pizza !!! Delicious ? love this place. The owner is a class act who knows what he's doing, love love love everything they make and the awesome welcoming smiles
Thomas Lang
Wow not only is the food quality top notch, but the deals, and service are the amazing. Definitely stop here
David Schlobohm
Great people and amazing food. If you often they remember you like family
Ramen Rider
Always neighborly and delicious! I asked them if they had peaches in their sangria and they made me an absolutely fire mango one instead. Way to respect somebody's allergies!
Corrina Brady
Great pizza, great people working there. It’s our only pizza place now!
Chip McKeon
Stopped in for a quick bite and was amazed at how good the pizza was.
Jeff Citron
Won a gift card here food was amazing service was fast and polite building was very clean its small and down home just how I like will return
Ghost
4 dollars a topping and 13 bucks for a personal sized pizza?... Outta your minds.Response to owner: Same prices are advertised on YOUR website.
Curiosity finally got to me and Slice of BayShore did not disappoint! After a long walk on the first spring-like day of the year, we were hungry and decided to stop in. I enjoyed the Chicken Scarpiello, my son just got some traditional mozzarella sticks. The service was AMAZING. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with a smile, it was quiet and cozy and we were able to enjoy each others company. Our server, Debbie, was absolutely wonderful. Chances are, if you decide to see it for yourself, you’ll see me and my family in the dining room. We plan to be frequent flyers from here on out!
Ali Jenkins
Wonderful atmosphere and super personal service. The food was crisp and enchanting. Will clearly recommend this restaurant to others. Affordable prices and big meals. Keep up the great work.
Ray N.
Doug W, thank you for your inspiring and spot on review which deservedly received ROTD honors 2 days ago. Chef Michael - you are a genius, you are super talented and creative, you are so generous; you are a magician. Your creations, all made from scratch are beyond words. The garlic knots, the intoxicating clams, the pasta e fagioli, the lasagne, the cannolis were all stellar beauties I absolutely enjoyed. The servings and portions - huge! The menu is very inviting. Love the Monday to Wednesday Pasta, Chicken and Italian specials( see photo). The 7 days a week lunch specials ( photo)look yummy as well. Debbie: you waited on me and made me feel at home and like a million bucks. You were kind, attentive, friendly, professional, so hospitable and sweet. You had that beautiful and natural rapport with all the guests. You made that fresh pot of coffee for me and immaculately packed the ample leftovers. Brianna - grateful for your lovely welcome and warmth as you seated me. The vibe and the atmosphere ooze a slice of food heaven. Immaculate restaurant. Spotless bathroom! Everybody, I can talk and write till the whole herd not just the cows come home. As Doug wrote, get your a** over to Slice of Bay Shore! Pronto! I drove 41 miles from Lower Manhattan to 298 W Main St in Bay Shore. I would do this in a heartbeat any chance I get and every week.
Crystal Alvarado
I was there earlier this week. I overheard her talking. The manager was extremely rude and disrespectful. I overheard her cursing to her staff. Extremely unprofessional. Get a better manager, I’m never ordering from here again.
Meri L.
Wanted something different, unique and not expensive for Valentine's Day. Heard about this place via Facebook. The pizza was absolutely delicious. Nice and well done, generous portion of pepperoni and an awesome heart shape. It still had 8 slices, which I was pleasantly surprised at. They don't only make the heart pie during Valentine's Day. It's available year round! Yummy yummy!
Ok now this place blew my taste buds!!!! The owner was sooooo kind and recommended the spinach , mushroom , truffle slice ,,,, woooooow that’s all i got to say and the vodka slice to die for !!! I’m so glad i had to go to mavis and wait and found this delicious place I’m going to say this is my 3rd favorite pizzaPlace now , THATS HUGE !!! ??❤️
Great service! Reasonable prices! Great slices! Need I say more.
Best pizza !!! Delicious ? love this place. The owner is a class act who knows what he's doing, love love love everything they make and the awesome welcoming smiles
Wow not only is the food quality top notch, but the deals, and service are the amazing. Definitely stop here
Great people and amazing food. If you often they remember you like family
Always neighborly and delicious! I asked them if they had peaches in their sangria and they made me an absolutely fire mango one instead. Way to respect somebody's allergies!
Great pizza, great people working there. It’s our only pizza place now!
Stopped in for a quick bite and was amazed at how good the pizza was.
Won a gift card here food was amazing service was fast and polite building was very clean its small and down home just how I like will return
4 dollars a topping and 13 bucks for a personal sized pizza?... Outta your minds.Response to owner: Same prices are advertised on YOUR website.
Restaurantji Recommends
Curiosity finally got to me and Slice of BayShore did not disappoint! After a long walk on the first spring-like day of the year, we were hungry and decided to stop in. I enjoyed the Chicken Scarpiello, my son just got some traditional mozzarella sticks. The service was AMAZING. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with a smile, it was quiet and cozy and we were able to enjoy each others company. Our server, Debbie, was absolutely wonderful. Chances are, if you decide to see it for yourself, you’ll see me and my family in the dining room. We plan to be frequent flyers from here on out!
Wonderful atmosphere and super personal service. The food was crisp and enchanting. Will clearly recommend this restaurant to others. Affordable prices and big meals. Keep up the great work.
Doug W, thank you for your inspiring and spot on review which deservedly received ROTD honors 2 days ago. Chef Michael - you are a genius, you are super talented and creative, you are so generous; you are a magician. Your creations, all made from scratch are beyond words. The garlic knots, the intoxicating clams, the pasta e fagioli, the lasagne, the cannolis were all stellar beauties I absolutely enjoyed. The servings and portions - huge! The menu is very inviting. Love the Monday to Wednesday Pasta, Chicken and Italian specials( see photo). The 7 days a week lunch specials ( photo)look yummy as well. Debbie: you waited on me and made me feel at home and like a million bucks. You were kind, attentive, friendly, professional, so hospitable and sweet. You had that beautiful and natural rapport with all the guests. You made that fresh pot of coffee for me and immaculately packed the ample leftovers. Brianna - grateful for your lovely welcome and warmth as you seated me. The vibe and the atmosphere ooze a slice of food heaven. Immaculate restaurant. Spotless bathroom! Everybody, I can talk and write till the whole herd not just the cows come home. As Doug wrote, get your a** over to Slice of Bay Shore! Pronto! I drove 41 miles from Lower Manhattan to 298 W Main St in Bay Shore. I would do this in a heartbeat any chance I get and every week.
I was there earlier this week. I overheard her talking. The manager was extremely rude and disrespectful. I overheard her cursing to her staff. Extremely unprofessional. Get a better manager, I’m never ordering from here again.
Wanted something different, unique and not expensive for Valentine's Day. Heard about this place via Facebook. The pizza was absolutely delicious. Nice and well done, generous portion of pepperoni and an awesome heart shape. It still had 8 slices, which I was pleasantly surprised at. They don't only make the heart pie during Valentine's Day. It's available year round! Yummy yummy!