Love the Penny Pub for just chilling with cold beer!
Odalis Galeano
Thanks for being open til 4am
Damien Cruz
Great service
Jacinto Herrera Panchana
I love this place! Everyone is super attentive & the food is amazing. If you’re looking for homey vibes and a good time, this is your place!!
Sam A.
Good atmosphere but in 1/30 around 11pm I went to this bar with a group , that lady at the bar with glasses was very rude and unprofessional we order a round of drinks and 2nd round we told her there is some ppl left so u need to take off they drinks on this 2nd round , she still charged us with extra drinks and when I spoke to her to explain she was aggressive and she assist to pay and it was my fault , but I didn’t pay the extra and I left , worst experience ever and I own 2 restaurants, an employee like that need to get terminated she is a bad vibe to the place
Elizabeth Claudio
The best low key down to earth bar in Bay Shore.
Ninz
I had the most horrifying experience at Penny Pub, and I will NEVER go back. The manager, Mike, walked into the women’s bathroom, of all places, and screamed at us to leave the bar because of a drink that was sitting on the counter—which wasn’t even ours! His tone was incredibly disrespectful, startling, and downright threatening.
As if that wasn’t enough, he followed us out of the bar, slandering our names and being unbelievably mean. I was so shaken by the whole ordeal that I couldn’t stop crying. It was truly horrifying to be treated like that, especially by someone who is supposed to be in charge.
This place has absolutely no class, and the staff is beyond unprofessional. I wouldn’t recommend Penny Pub to my worst enemy. Save yourself the trauma and avoid this place at all costs.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Heather Kramer
Great local spot to get a cold drink, hot food, and good conversation.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy Y
They charge for parking out back on a Sundays be careful!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Page Sorter
Don’t bother with this establishment. Over priced drinks and the bouncer acts like he owns the place. Was extremely rude to me and my guests. Asked for the manager because he was out of line to me and my party. Couldn’t give an appropriate reason as to why we had to leave randomly while me and my guests were minding our own business. Asked for the manager and his name. Completely ignored our requests. Completely inappropriate. He should be fired. We won’t come here again. Very unprofessional. Don’t waste your time.
Great little place in the back to play pool. Drinks and people are great
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
James Cunningham
Local
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
eric wong
Amazing food, excellent service, and the vibes here are great! Reyna went above and beyond to serve my friends and I.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alexander Jones
The Irish whiskey BBQ quesadilla was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
anthony janos
I'm new to Long Island and this was the first bar I ever went to out here. The atmosphere is fun and they don't blast music to where you can't carry a conversation. The food is incredibly good and priced good. All of the bartenders I've had are nice and quick at getting your food orders in and keeping your drinks full. Highly recommend going here ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Homemade Fried Mac & Cheese with Chipotle Ranch for Dipping, The Penny Burger, Penny Pretzels, Dublin Dip
Love the Penny Pub for just chilling with cold beer!
Thanks for being open til 4am
Great service
I love this place! Everyone is super attentive & the food is amazing. If you’re looking for homey vibes and a good time, this is your place!!
Good atmosphere but in 1/30 around 11pm I went to this bar with a group , that lady at the bar with glasses was very rude and unprofessional we order a round of drinks and 2nd round we told her there is some ppl left so u need to take off they drinks on this 2nd round , she still charged us with extra drinks and when I spoke to her to explain she was aggressive and she assist to pay and it was my fault , but I didn’t pay the extra and I left , worst experience ever and I own 2 restaurants, an employee like that need to get terminated she is a bad vibe to the place
The best low key down to earth bar in Bay Shore.
I had the most horrifying experience at Penny Pub, and I will NEVER go back. The manager, Mike, walked into the women’s bathroom, of all places, and screamed at us to leave the bar because of a drink that was sitting on the counter—which wasn’t even ours! His tone was incredibly disrespectful, startling, and downright threatening.
As if that wasn’t enough, he followed us out of the bar, slandering our names and being unbelievably mean. I was so shaken by the whole ordeal that I couldn’t stop crying. It was truly horrifying to be treated like that, especially by someone who is supposed to be in charge.
This place has absolutely no class, and the staff is beyond unprofessional. I wouldn’t recommend Penny Pub to my worst enemy. Save yourself the trauma and avoid this place at all costs.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great local spot to get a cold drink, hot food, and good conversation.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They charge for parking out back on a Sundays be careful!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Don’t bother with this establishment. Over priced drinks and the bouncer acts like he owns the place. Was extremely rude to me and my guests. Asked for the manager because he was out of line to me and my party. Couldn’t give an appropriate reason as to why we had to leave randomly while me and my guests were minding our own business. Asked for the manager and his name. Completely ignored our requests. Completely inappropriate. He should be fired. We won’t come here again. Very unprofessional. Don’t waste your time.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great little place in the back to play pool. Drinks and people are great
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Local
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing food, excellent service, and the vibes here are great! Reyna went above and beyond to serve my friends and I.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Irish whiskey BBQ quesadilla was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'm new to Long Island and this was the first bar I ever went to out here. The atmosphere is fun and they don't blast music to where you can't carry a conversation. The food is incredibly good and priced good. All of the bartenders I've had are nice and quick at getting your food orders in and keeping your drinks full. Highly recommend going here ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Homemade Fried Mac & Cheese with Chipotle Ranch for Dipping, The Penny Burger, Penny Pretzels, Dublin Dip
Loading...