Toast Coffeehouse
9 S Pk Ave, Bay Shore
(631) 647-9560
Customers' Favorites
Lemon Blueberry Ricotta Pancakes
Miss Lucy's Tortilla Scramble
Blueberry Jonny Cake Pancake
Tennessee Chicken & Waffle
Biscuits & Gravy Benedict
Cinnamon Bun Short Stack
Cookie Dough Pancakes
Side of Home Fries
Bkyln French Toast
Splendid Benedict
Food Specials
Fall French Toast Trio
fresh brioche, cinnamon swirl and pumpkin bread with pumpkin syrup and cinnamon creme fraiche*contains gluten and dairy
Butternut Maple Bacon Omelet
Roasted butternut squash, caramelized onion, and maple bacon with white cheddar cheese*contains dairy
Pumpkin Cinna Bun Pancakes
Homemade pumpkin pancakes with pumpkin cinnamon syrup and vanilla icing**contains gluten and dairy
Apple Cider Donut French Toast
Cinnamon apple, apple cider reduction, cinnamon sugar*contains dairy and gluten
Chicken Chorizo Skillet
Two organic poached eggs, homemade chorizo seasoned chicken hash with caramelized onion & smashed home fries, corn & pepper relish, poblano hollandaise over cornbread*contains dairy and gluten
The Revival
Whipped ricotta, roasted garlic, crushed red pepper, fresh avocado, drizzled honey on grilled sourdough *contains dairy
The Fall Festival Sandwich
Grilled chicken, apple slaw, crispy bacon, melted jack cheese
Sweet Potato Pie
graham cracker, marshmallow, maple pecan syrup*contains gluten and dairy
Cup Soup
Bowl Soup
Drink Specials
Pumpkin Crumb Cake Cappuccino
Maple Spiced Chai
Apple Cider Mimosa
Pomegranate Ginger Pear Mimosa
Pumpkin Espresso Martini
Specialty Iced Coffee Full
Warm Apple Cider
Coffee Drinks
Coffee
Tea
Cafe Latte
Cappuccino
Iced Cappucino
Iced Latte
Iced Coffee
Peanut Butter Mocha
Chai Tea Latte
Matcha Latte
Caramel Apple Chai
Shaken Espresso Maple Latte
Salted Caramel Latte
Hot Chocolate
Double Espresso
Americano
Single Shot Espresso
Regular Cold Brew
Graham Cracker
Cortado
Cocktails
Virgin Mary
Bloody Mary
Bloody Maria
BLT Mary
Sriracha Shrimp & Bacon Bloody Mary
Brunch Punch
Toast'd Sunrise
Morning Drive
Espresso martini
Strongman Irish Coffee
Maple Old Fashioned
Blueberry Gin Fizz
Midway Margarita
Luna Park Margarita
Brooklyn Flyer
LIT
Arnold Palmer
Dragons Gorge
Strawberry Cyclone
GrahamChata
Morning Glorious
Beer
Blue Point
Great South Bay Blonde
Guinness
DUBCO Peach
Ghost Sour
Montauk IPA
Blue Point Summer
Ghost Kentucky Common
DUBCO Triple IPA
Mimosas
Orange Mimosa
Cranberry Orange Mimosa
Lemon Blueberry Mimosa
Pomegranate Mimosa
Strawberry Lemonade Mimosa
Fresh Orange Mimosa
Peach Bellini
Pineapple Coconut Mimosa
Wine
House Red
House White
Pindar Rose
Red Sangria
White Sangria
Rose Sangria
Juices and Milk
Orange Juice
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice
Apple Juice
Cranberry Juice
Pineapple Juice
Tomato Juice
Milk
Chocolate Milk
Iced Teas
Iced Teas
Lemonades
Smoothies
Strawberry Banana
Pineapple Coconut Sm
Wild Berry
Mango
Soda
Soda
Seltzer
Early Riser
Eggs Any Style
Two organic eggs, your choice of bacon, turkey bacon, sausage, or ham, served with home fries and toast
Organic Oatmeal
With cinnamon apples and dried cranberries, topped with brown sugar and strawberries
Fruit Parfait Bowl
Fresh fruit & berries on top of vanilla yogurt and coverd with organic harvest granola
Egg Sandwich
Classic egg sandwich with two eggs cooked to your liking, your choice of meat, American cheese, and your choice of bread!
CBT
Vegan Any Style
Two vegan scrambled eggs, with your choice of fruit or vegan sausage, served with home fries and toast**Vegan**
Avocado Toast
Classic Avocado Toast
Toasted multigrain bread with sliced avocado, red onion, everything seasoning and microgreens
Vegan Avocado Toast
Toasted multigrain bread with sliced avocado, red onion, and microgreens, served with home fries
Avo BLT Toast
Fresh sliced avocado, mashed avocado, bacon jam, grape tomato & microgreens served with home fries
Burrata Caprese Avocado Toast
Sun dried tomato pesto, fresh sliced avocado, julienned basil & balsamic glaze served with home fries
Quesadillas
Ranchero Quesadilla
Scrambled eggs, black beans, roasted corn & pepper relish, with melted jalapeno jack and chipotle aioli on a grilled honey wheat tortilla
Hawaiian Coast Quesadilla
Scrambled eggs, BBQ pulled pork, red pepper, grilled pineapple, & yellow cheddar
Voodoo Quesadilla
Creole scrambled eggs, shrimp, chorizo, fresh avocado, roasted corn & pepper relish, melted cheddar
The Vegan Brussels Quesadilla
Vegan scrambled eggs, vegan sausage, Brussels sprouts, corn & pepper relish with Chao cheese**Vegan**
Handhelds
Millionaire Egg Sammy
Eggs any style with fresh arugula, millionare bacon, caramelized onions, garlic aioli & smoked gouda pield high on a homemade ciabatta
Supreme Sammy
Vegan scrambled eggs, vegan sausage & Chao cheese with chipotle mayo on a multigrain roll**Vegan**
Bandito Burrito
Scrambled eggs, crisp bacon, potato, roasted red pepper, & smoked gouda, served with home fries & mango salsa*contains dairy and gluten
Original Burrito
Scrambled eggs, sausage, potato, peppers, onion, & jack cheese, served with home fries & mango salsa*contains dairy and gluten
Twin Sister Burrito
Vegan scrambled eggs, vegan sausage, potatoes, peppers, and onions, served with home fries and mango salsa**Vegan**
Omelets
Plain Jane Omelet
American cheese omelet, served with home fries and toast
Avocado BLT Omelet
Avocado, crisp bacon, spinach, plum tomato, & Vermont white cheddar, served with home fries and toast
Mediterranean Omelet
Baby spinach, plum tomato, onion, & feta, served with home fries and toast
Delancey Street Omelet
Crisp bacon, spianch, mushroom, tomato, onion, & swiss, served with home fries and toast
Huevos Migas Omelet
Chorizo sausage, tomato, green pepper, onion, & jalapeno havarti, served with home fries and toast
The "Dig Me" Omelet
Egg whites, spinach, turkey, & jack cheese, served with home fries and toast
Vegan Farmer's Omelet
Vegan eggs, grape tomatoes, arugula, corn & pepper relish, avocado, quinoa and Chao cheese**Vegan**
Toast Favorites
Benedict Arnold
Two organic poached eggs served with grilled ham on a toasted english muffin, topped with hollandaise, roasted red pepper & green onion, served with home fries
Splendid Benedict
Two organic poached eggs served with sliced avocado fritter on a toasted english muffin, topped with hollandaise & maple bacon crumbles, served with home fries
Corned Beef Hash & Eggs
Two organic poached eggs atop homemade corned beef, caramelized brussels sprouts, on thick cut rye with hollandaise & diced bacon
Biscuits & Gravy Benedict
Two organic poached eggs served with sausage gravy and homemade biscuits
Shrimp & Grits
Two organic poached eggs with crumbled chorizo & sauteed cajun shrimp in etouffee style sauce over cheddar grits
Three Ring Circus
Two organic eggs, home fries, classic pancakes & your choice of bacon, turkey bacon, sausage, turkey sausage or ham*no substitutions
Steak & Eggs
eggs any style, espresso rubbed flat iron steak, crispy onions with homemade biscuit, served with home fries
Egg Skillets
Miss Lucy's Tortilla Skillet
Creole scrambled eggs, sausage, potato, green onion, melted cheddar and corn tortillas topped with sour cream, served over home fries
Denver Skillet
Softly scrambled eggs, grilled ham, green pepper, mushroom, and onion, topped with cheddar cheese, served over home fries
Avocado Skillet
Softly scrambled eggs, grilled turkey, roasted red pepper, green onion, fresh avocado with white cheddar, served over home fries
Garden Gourmet Skillet
Softly scrambled eggs, roasted zucchini, spinach, mushroom, sundried tomato, and sautéed onion, served over home fries
Domingo Skillet
creole scrambled eggs, pulled pork, fresh guacamole, jack cheese, crispy tortilla strips
Tofu Skillet
Grilled tofu with spinach, zucchini, mushroom, asparagus, & red pepper, served over home fries
Vegan Garden Gourmet Skillet
Vegan scrambled eggs, roasted zucchini, spinach, mushroom, sundried tomato, sauteed onion, & eggs, served over home fries**Vegan**
Pancakes
Classic Pancakes
Comes with powdered sugar
Chocolate Chip
Comes with powdered sugar
Cookie Dough
Comes with powdered sugar
Cinnamon Bun
Comes with powdered sugar
Apple Crumb
Comes with powdered sugar
Banana Walnut
Comes with powdered sugar
Blueberry Pecan
Comes with powdered sugar
Sweet Potato with Honey Butter
Comes with powdered sugar and honey butter*contains gluten
Short Stack
Comes with powdered sugar
Very Berry Pancakes
with warm berry compote & fresh berries**CANNOT BE MADE GLUTEN FREE**
French Toast & Crepes
Brioche French Toast
Fresh strawberries & creme fraiche
BKYLN French Toast
Stuffed with NY style cheesecake and topped with a warm berry compote*Contains Gluten
Apple Strudel
Cinnamon apples & creme fraiche*Contains Gluten
The Krispy Nutella
Fresh strawberry with nutella drizzle
Cinnamon Swirl French Toast
Creme fraiche & powdered sugar
Coconut Multigrain French Toast
Dipped in Coconut milk & vanilla, with mangos & bananas, served with your choice of side**Vegan**
Nutella & Banana Crepe
Berry & Brie Crepe
Waffles
Belgian with Fresh Berries
Comes with powdered sugar & whipped cream
Tennessee Chicken & Waffle
Cinnamon sugar sweet potato waffle with spicy honey fried chicken thigh, roasted red pepper & green onion*Contains Gluten & Dairy
Chicken & Waffle
Belgian waffle with cornmeal crusted fried chicken thigh topped with fresh pineapple & strawberry, served with maple pecan syrup*Contains Gluten & Dairy
Toast Specialties
Turkey Reuben
Turkey, sauerkraut and swiss with 1000 island dressing on toasted rye
Bayou Flat
Cajun grilled turkey, red onion and tomato and jack cheese with chipotle mayo on toasted flat bread
The Bad Larry
Grilled turkey, crisp bacon, avocado, red onion, tomato and white cheddar with avocado ranch on a toasted flat bread
The Boardwalk Melt
Roast beef with crispy onions, spicy horseradish mayo & melted mozzarella on toasted rosemary focaccia
Cuban Reuben
Pulled pork, ham, sliced pickle, coleslaw, & melted swiss with spicy mustard on homebaked rye
Nashville Fried Chicken
Spicy fried chicken, mixed greens & pickles with chipotle aioli on a brioche roll
Vienna Chicken
Grilled chicken, spinach, fresh mozzarella with sun dried tomato pesto on a toasted multigrain roll
Brooklyn Chicken
Grilled chicken, mushroom, spinach & fresh mozzarella on a garlic toasted multigrain roll
The Breadwinner
Chicken salad, cucumber, tomato, gorgonzola cheese on toasted rosemary focaccia
Vegan Brooklyn Chicken
Breaded chicken, mushroom, spinach, & mozzarella on a garlic toasted multigrain roll**Vegan**
Vegan Vienna Chicken
Breaded chicken, spinach, sundried tomato pesto and mozzarella on a toasted multigrain roll**Vegan**
Wraps
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, parmesan, crushed croutons, creamy Caesar dressing
Chicken Salad Wrap
Our homemade chicken salad with apple, mixed greens & tomato
Southwest Turkey Wrap
Turkey, crisp bacon, mixed greens, tomato, red onion & jack cheese with chipotle mayo
Sriracha Shrimp Wrap
Shrimp, black bean, roasted corn & pepper relish, & mixed greens with sriracha mayo
Hampton's Ham & Brie
Honey ham, red onion, mixed greens, cucumber, apple, candied walnuts, brie with sweet mustard vinaigrette
Roast Beef & Avocado
Grilled red onion, mixed greens, tomato & white cheddar with avocado ranch
Burgers
Toast Smash Burger
Sirloin and brisket blend beef burger, sauteed onions, comeback sauce, white American cheese, brioche bun
Cheddar Bacon Smash Burger
sirloin and brisket blend beef burger, comeback sauce, brioche bun
Homemade Chicken Burger
Handmade ground chicken burger served with lettuce, tomato & red onion on a multigrain roll
Homemade Black Bean Burger
lettuce, tomato, onion, vegan chipotle mayo, multigrain rollcontains gluten**Vegan**
Lettuce Continue
Classic Chicken Caesar Salad
Grilled chicken, romaine hearts, rosemary croutons, parmesan
Toast House Salad
Grilled chicken, sliced green apple. red onion, candied walnuts & crumbled gorgonzola
Lemon Chicken Salad
Grilled chicken, dried cranberries, toasted almonds & crumbled goat cheese with homemade lemon dressing
Chicken in the Garden
Homemade chicken salad on a bed of mixed greens, with grape tomatoes, cucumber & red onion
The Supreme Greek
grilled chicken, spring mix, kalamata olives, feta cheese, grape tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, pepperoncini
Spicy Power Bowl
quinoa, arugula, sliced avocado, sweet potato, black beans, sliced grape tomato, vegan chipotle and microgreens**Vegan**
Small Salad
Bistro Bites
Grilled Cheese Trio
Melted American, cheddar, and swiss with tomato on multigrain
Bacon & Brie Grilled Cheese
with caramelized onion on multigrain
Toast BLT
Crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato and avocado with basil mayo on toast multigrain
Kids
Kids Scrambled Eggs & Bacon
choice of bacon or sausage, served with home fries and toast
Kids French Toast
with strawberries, served with bacon or sausage
Kids Silver Dollar Pancakes
served with bacon or sausage
Kids Grilled Cheese
on whole wheat
Kids Chicken Fingers
Kids Cheese Quesadilla
Sides
100%25 Real Maple Syrup
Bagel
Bowl Soup
Cup Soup
Muffin
Side Bacon Jam
Side Coleslaw
Side Chicken
Side Grilled Shrimp
Side of Avocado
Side of Bacon
Side of Berries
Side of Biscuits and Gravy
Side of Cheddar Grits
Side of Corned Beef Hash
Side of Dipping Sauce
Side of Dressing
Side of eggs
Side of French Fries
Side of fruit
Side of Ham
Side of Hollandaise
Side of Home Fries
Side of Jalapenos
Side of Mixed Vegetables
Side of Pickles
Side of Sausage
Side of Sausage Gravy
Side of Spinach
Side of Sweet Potato Fries
Side of Toast
Side of Turkey Bacon
Side of Vegan Sausage
Side Salsa
Side Tomato
Side Turkey Sausage
Small Salad
Side Crumbled Chorizo
Side of Steak (6 oz)
Photos
+38 photos
+37 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Lazy staff standing around on their phones. I as well as two other tables had to ask the staff for utensils to eat the food they already brought to the tables. The food itself was ok. Nothing special.
March 2025
This place is alright. Its staff seems kind but they aren’t well trained? Most, if not all, restaurants I go to give you a heads up before the kitchen closes. I tried to order a meal to take home for family. But I guess it’s my fault too cause I didn’t know they closed so early. But we also had no napkins or silverware at our table until we asked for them.
The other issue I take is I had my baby shower there years ago. The communication was poor. And...
The other issue I take is I had my baby shower there years ago. The communication was poor. And...
February 2025
You May Also Like
Pecado Mexican - 49 W Main St
![]()
Mexican, Cocktail Bar
Corks and Taps - 53 W Main St
![]()
American, Wine Bar, Cocktail Bar, New American, Vegetarian
Frank & Maria's Italian Market - 10 W Main St
![]()
Italian, Butcher, Specialty Food
Kid-friendliness: Great for kids!