This cozy spot in Bayville offers a charming community atmosphere, often frequented by friendly older folks who enjoy cracking jokes. It adds to the experience! You can even play the New York Lottery while enjoying some pizza. However, if this place is closed, it might be best to head home or order from nearby options through food delivery apps.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Hungryman
Larry O'Connell
Pizza is fantastic!!!
Joseph Fresolo
Very local and homey
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katia Barros
This is a good place to stop for a sandwich, or a slice of pizza. The parking is very limited with only a few spaces in front of the store.
I was driving around wasting time, and I saw their sign. I thought, "I'm in NY. I need pizza." It was not your average NY slice. Very tasty. Spinach, fried chicken, and fresh chunks of tomato, and just a touch of cheese on a pizza crust.
Steven Spost
Best deli on the planet. The sandwiches, pizza and service are amazing.
Justin D.
Found mold at the bottom of the parmesan shaker. Deli clerk said it's normal.Attitude from the pizza side guy. Asked for fresh cheese, said "there is no cheese here for you."Clerk on deli side rectify the situation. I don't know how you have a pizza place and have no cheese.
Jackie
Firstly, all the guys at the pizza counter are always nice, but the staff at the checkout counter definitely hate their job. I've been here multiple times wanting to like it but I didn't like any of the sandwiches or pizzas. :( The prepared cold salads and soup was good, though. Also the prices seem to fluctuate pretty often, so just keep that in mind.
Dana L.
This place is complete over priced crap. Ordered a turkey sandwich and the meat was not Boars Head it was salty and rancid, furthermore the Dragon Lady by the cashier was a nothing but an overgrown douche bag! Avoid this over priced tomeijn palace at all costs!!!! Btw this place was not too clean either!
Delicious pizza, friendly service and the best calzones you’ll ever have. The chicken parm calzone was superb! Will definitely repeat..Also, a nice variety of many different dishes on their menu. Highly recommended! ??
D D
Great specialty pizza options, affordable price & the spinach & pepperoni wheels are so delicious!! No indoor or outdoor seating
Thomas Troisi
Friendly staff great place
Paolo Barsanti
Excellent pasta salad, macaroni salad, grilled veggies, and Italian sub.
Dr. Ron Natale
We stopped in for marvelous breakfast sandwiches on kaiser or crescent rolls. There were so many options.
Awesome
Food: 5
This cozy spot in Bayville offers a charming community atmosphere, often frequented by friendly older folks who enjoy cracking jokes. It adds to the experience! You can even play the New York Lottery while enjoying some pizza. However, if this place is closed, it might be best to head home or order from nearby options through food delivery apps.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Hungryman
Pizza is fantastic!!!
Very local and homey
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a good place to stop for a sandwich, or a slice of pizza. The parking is very limited with only a few spaces in front of the store.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Barbecue Pulled Pork, Grilled Chicken
I was driving around wasting time, and I saw their sign. I thought, "I'm in NY. I need pizza." It was not your average NY slice. Very tasty. Spinach, fried chicken, and fresh chunks of tomato, and just a touch of cheese on a pizza crust.
Best deli on the planet. The sandwiches, pizza and service are amazing.
Found mold at the bottom of the parmesan shaker. Deli clerk said it's normal.Attitude from the pizza side guy. Asked for fresh cheese, said "there is no cheese here for you."Clerk on deli side rectify the situation. I don't know how you have a pizza place and have no cheese.
Firstly, all the guys at the pizza counter are always nice, but the staff at the checkout counter definitely hate their job. I've been here multiple times wanting to like it but I didn't like any of the sandwiches or pizzas. :( The prepared cold salads and soup was good, though. Also the prices seem to fluctuate pretty often, so just keep that in mind.
This place is complete over priced crap. Ordered a turkey sandwich and the meat was not Boars Head it was salty and rancid, furthermore the Dragon Lady by the cashier was a nothing but an overgrown douche bag! Avoid this over priced tomeijn palace at all costs!!!! Btw this place was not too clean either!
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious pizza, friendly service and the best calzones you’ll ever have. The chicken parm calzone was superb! Will definitely repeat..Also, a nice variety of many different dishes on their menu. Highly recommended! ??
Great specialty pizza options, affordable price & the spinach & pepperoni wheels are so delicious!! No indoor or outdoor seating
Friendly staff great place
Excellent pasta salad, macaroni salad, grilled veggies, and Italian sub.
We stopped in for marvelous breakfast sandwiches on kaiser or crescent rolls. There were so many options.