It's a great place to have a hand crafted beer and a hot pretzel. Aswome atmosphere and people. If you are near Bayville, it is worth the trip.
Bill Albert
Great brewery with a great selection of micro brew. Great service also.
Jim Holland
Enjoyed this nano brewery and the casual atmosphere. Feels like being with old friends when you are there.
Betsy Kotsogiannis
Great beer,cute place,nice atmosphere,excellent service!We will be back.
Billie Kostas
Great beer,cute place,nice atmosphere,excellent service!We will be back.
Mike L
I'm happy to say that we had a nice time here! Enjoyed a few pints of Irish Amber Ale. It was tasty and cold. Bartender was friendly and offered some samples of their other offerings. The Amber Ale hit the spot, but I look forward to trying their other brews. The setting was pleasant and clean. We look forward to returning soon.
Mike L.
I'm happy to say that we had a nice time here! Enjoyed a few pints of Irish Amber Ale. It was tasty and cold. Bartender was friendly and offered some samples of their other offerings. The Amber Ale hit the spot, but I look forward to trying their other brews. The setting was pleasant and clean. We look forward to returning soon. Thank you!!!
Joe Marchese
My friend and I went here last night and had a terrible experience, I would not recommend this brewery to anyone.We grabbed a flight and started to try some of the beers. Those selections were not to our taste and left reasonable but honest feedback on another platform. The bartender saw the feedback, came over to our table, grabbed several unfinished beers, poured them out and told us we were done.We immediately left the store to have the bartender follow us out into the parking lot, curse us out, say some very rude things, and told us never to come back. Completely unacceptable behavior. Rest assured, I will never return, no one that I know will go and I ask that anyone reading this consider the same.This was an opportunity for the brewery to speak with us and understand where we were coming from. If the feedback was so personal, why not ask us not to review it, or incentivize us with a refund to leave a good impression for the future? I feel a more reasonable person would not have behaved in such a disrespectful, ignorant and mean-spirited way for honest feedback. Certainly a missed opportunity to improve and perhaps adapt to different beer drinkers that may have benefited everyone.
Jimmy EL
Went with a friend the other day to this brewery. We have a goal of trying every LI brewery. Unfortunately, our experience at this brewery was not a good one. We ordered a flight to try and the beers we had were about average. The last ipa we had was not very good and we gave it a rating on untapped(beer rating app) to reflect that. My friend and I were the only people still in the bar and I guess the bartender was checking untapped. The bartender came over, took our last beer away while we we're drinking it and said that we should leave. He then followed us in the parking lot and continued to yell at us. The place was nice overall but having that experience completely changed my view of that brewery. We will not be returning.
Joe M.
I went here last night and had a terrible experience, I would not recommend this brewery to anyone. We grabbed a flight and started to try some of the beers. Those selections were not to our taste and left reasonable but honest feedback on another platform. The bartender saw the feedback, came over to our table, grabbed several unfinished beers, poured them out and told us we were done. We immediately left the store to have the bartender follow us out into the parking lot, curse us out, say some very rude things, and told us never to come back. Completely unacceptable behavior. Rest assured, I will never return, no one that I know will go and I ask that anyone reading this consider the same. This was an opportunity for the brewery to speak with us and understand where we were coming from. If the feedback was so personal, why not ask us not to review it, or incentivize us with a refund to leave a good impression for the future? I feel a more reasonable person would not have behaved in such a disrespectful, ignorant and mean-spirited way for honest feedback. Certainly a missed opportunity to improve and perhaps adapt to different beer drinkers that may have benefited everyone.
I recently worked with Dawn from the Old Tappan Team to coordinate renting out the taproom for my cousins surprise 30th birthday party, Dawn and the whole team were so accommodating! The space is perfect, great tall bar, nice seating areas and plenty of games to enjoy and the beer is very enjoyable! We brought in our own catered food from the Delicious Bayville Meat Center ( highly recommend) and it paired perfectly with the delicious Old Tappan Brews, Jess was our Beertender and she was awesome. 10/10 recommend. Thank you for everything!
Adam S.
Great beer and vibe. We always enjoy stopping by for a drink and chatting with the owner.
Rob D
Awesome place, awesome people, awesome beer!
Corrine Barreiro
Awesome small brewery and dog friendly for our little guy. Tasty beers, good vibes and fun games available to play with your party. The bartender was extremely friendly and even gave treats to our mini bernedoodle. They also gave us one chip per drink we bought and 10 chips gave you a free drink. We will definitely be back!
Mark Dimont
Great little brewery with a diverse selection of styles. I had the red ale and the Oktoberfest which were both excellent. Crowd was friendly and there was an outdoor band on Saturday. Dog friendly as well.
It's a great place to have a hand crafted beer and a hot pretzel. Aswome atmosphere and people. If you are near Bayville, it is worth the trip.
Great brewery with a great selection of micro brew. Great service also.
Enjoyed this nano brewery and the casual atmosphere. Feels like being with old friends when you are there.
Great beer,cute place,nice atmosphere,excellent service!We will be back.
Great beer,cute place,nice atmosphere,excellent service!We will be back.
I'm happy to say that we had a nice time here! Enjoyed a few pints of Irish Amber Ale. It was tasty and cold. Bartender was friendly and offered some samples of their other offerings. The Amber Ale hit the spot, but I look forward to trying their other brews. The setting was pleasant and clean. We look forward to returning soon.
I'm happy to say that we had a nice time here! Enjoyed a few pints of Irish Amber Ale. It was tasty and cold. Bartender was friendly and offered some samples of their other offerings. The Amber Ale hit the spot, but I look forward to trying their other brews. The setting was pleasant and clean. We look forward to returning soon. Thank you!!!
My friend and I went here last night and had a terrible experience, I would not recommend this brewery to anyone.We grabbed a flight and started to try some of the beers. Those selections were not to our taste and left reasonable but honest feedback on another platform. The bartender saw the feedback, came over to our table, grabbed several unfinished beers, poured them out and told us we were done.We immediately left the store to have the bartender follow us out into the parking lot, curse us out, say some very rude things, and told us never to come back. Completely unacceptable behavior. Rest assured, I will never return, no one that I know will go and I ask that anyone reading this consider the same.This was an opportunity for the brewery to speak with us and understand where we were coming from. If the feedback was so personal, why not ask us not to review it, or incentivize us with a refund to leave a good impression for the future? I feel a more reasonable person would not have behaved in such a disrespectful, ignorant and mean-spirited way for honest feedback. Certainly a missed opportunity to improve and perhaps adapt to different beer drinkers that may have benefited everyone.
Went with a friend the other day to this brewery. We have a goal of trying every LI brewery. Unfortunately, our experience at this brewery was not a good one. We ordered a flight to try and the beers we had were about average. The last ipa we had was not very good and we gave it a rating on untapped(beer rating app) to reflect that. My friend and I were the only people still in the bar and I guess the bartender was checking untapped. The bartender came over, took our last beer away while we we're drinking it and said that we should leave. He then followed us in the parking lot and continued to yell at us. The place was nice overall but having that experience completely changed my view of that brewery. We will not be returning.
I went here last night and had a terrible experience, I would not recommend this brewery to anyone. We grabbed a flight and started to try some of the beers. Those selections were not to our taste and left reasonable but honest feedback on another platform. The bartender saw the feedback, came over to our table, grabbed several unfinished beers, poured them out and told us we were done. We immediately left the store to have the bartender follow us out into the parking lot, curse us out, say some very rude things, and told us never to come back. Completely unacceptable behavior. Rest assured, I will never return, no one that I know will go and I ask that anyone reading this consider the same. This was an opportunity for the brewery to speak with us and understand where we were coming from. If the feedback was so personal, why not ask us not to review it, or incentivize us with a refund to leave a good impression for the future? I feel a more reasonable person would not have behaved in such a disrespectful, ignorant and mean-spirited way for honest feedback. Certainly a missed opportunity to improve and perhaps adapt to different beer drinkers that may have benefited everyone.
Restaurantji Recommends
I recently worked with Dawn from the Old Tappan Team to coordinate renting out the taproom for my cousins surprise 30th birthday party, Dawn and the whole team were so accommodating! The space is perfect, great tall bar, nice seating areas and plenty of games to enjoy and the beer is very enjoyable! We brought in our own catered food from the Delicious Bayville Meat Center ( highly recommend) and it paired perfectly with the delicious Old Tappan Brews, Jess was our Beertender and she was awesome. 10/10 recommend. Thank you for everything!
Great beer and vibe. We always enjoy stopping by for a drink and chatting with the owner.
Awesome place, awesome people, awesome beer!
Awesome small brewery and dog friendly for our little guy. Tasty beers, good vibes and fun games available to play with your party. The bartender was extremely friendly and even gave treats to our mini bernedoodle. They also gave us one chip per drink we bought and 10 chips gave you a free drink. We will definitely be back!
Great little brewery with a diverse selection of styles. I had the red ale and the Oktoberfest which were both excellent. Crowd was friendly and there was an outdoor band on Saturday. Dog friendly as well.