Great place! Very good food (lobster roll and oysters), very friendly atmosphere! Highly recommended 😀
James Green
I recently catered a lobster bake. Jim and his crew were fantastic. Very responsive. Flexible. Food was delicious start to finish. All of my guests commented on the food. One of my guests book an event on the spot. Would do it again!
Kelly Hager
Stopped in for lunch as we’re passing through town and I will come back out of my way just to come here again. The food was so fresh and delicious. Service was impeccable. Wish I wasn’t so full to keep ordering.
scott hennelly
A new favorite for our family. Food was excellent. Great service. We will be back.
Sophy
Amazing seafood pasta and ambiance at this Bayville Italian restaurant! Definitely recommend trying their New England clam chowder as well, I will be coming back soon for more of their super fresh seafood and friendly service.
Gina Marie
After driving 12 hours from Tennessee, there is only 1 place we HAD to have dinner, Shultzy’s Restaurant! On a small corner in Bayville, NY, this quaint restaurant is serving up some GIANT flavors of the best seafood around! We started off with a dozen of their raw little neck clams that tasted like they were just caught out back. Being from Florida I didn’t think I’d find them that good ever again. I was delightfully surprised when I found them better! So much better we ordered a second dozen.
Next up was their Lobster and Shrimp bisque which had lumps of seafood with a creamy base. If I could live in the bowl I would’ve!
My mom and I shared a lobster roll that was big enough to share! The lobster was cooked to perfection and was so buttery!
My dad ordered their Fra Divalo Pasta which had more seafood than the bowl could hold. It was overflowing with mussels, clams, calamari, and jumbo shrimp!
This is hands down a 10/10 restaurant where you feel like family and are treated as such! Make sure to say hi to Jimmy and tell him Gina and the family sent you! Be sure to come in hungry because you will leave with your stomach and your heart full!
TC Schmidt
The lunch menu … the pulled pork and the shrimp tacos were delicious..the parking is limited… the atmosphere was quiet …no blaring music or television .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alexis Johnson
Visiting from Dallas! Picked this place because of the high ratings and did not disappoint! You HAVE to stop here on your way through!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Roll
Kate Herbig
Out with my entire family for Thanksgiving Eve!! So happy!! All the seafood and the burger and fries were amazing!! Thank you Schultzy!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Burger
Mike Causarano
Burgers were sour/turned & fries tasted like fish. After giving multiple chances, will never return.
Absolutely loved everything about this place, the food, atmosphere, and especially the service. John and Jimmy were nothing but amazing. We got the lobster roll (Maine and Connecticut), the crispy spicy tuna rice, the lobster Mac and cheese, and the affogato. Everything was phenomenal and could not recommend this place enough!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fire Island Oysters and Little Neck Clams, Mac and Cheese, Lobster Roll
Jun Wu
Literally a hidden gem. Shrimp and grits is a MUST GET YALL LISTEN TO ME NOW. You won’t regret it. Insanely good brunch
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy Angel Germano Daum
Charming and cozy. Absolutely the best seafood in the area! Lovely family owned and local Mussels, raw bar, lobster, and fire roasted oysters are extremely delicious along with everything here! One of my all time favorite restaurants.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fire Roasted Oysters, Scallops, Lobster Roll
Christina Duffy
We had Frank and his guys recently cater a raw bar at our wedding at the Sayville Yacht Club…..people are still raving over it!!! Thank you so much you nailed it!!!!! We will be in to pay you a visit
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fire Island Oysters and Little Neck Clams
Danny F.
You won't find a better seafood restaurant on Long Island and you can include the Jersey Shore. Just go down the menu ..... All Fantastic!!! Don't forget to hear the Specials for the Evening. "Over the Top" Dining Experience. You're will LOVE IT !!
Great place! Very good food (lobster roll and oysters), very friendly atmosphere! Highly recommended 😀
I recently catered a lobster bake. Jim and his crew were fantastic. Very responsive. Flexible. Food was delicious start to finish. All of my guests commented on the food. One of my guests book an event on the spot. Would do it again!
Stopped in for lunch as we’re passing through town and I will come back out of my way just to come here again. The food was so fresh and delicious. Service was impeccable. Wish I wasn’t so full to keep ordering.
A new favorite for our family. Food was excellent. Great service. We will be back.
Amazing seafood pasta and ambiance at this Bayville Italian restaurant! Definitely recommend trying their New England clam chowder as well, I will be coming back soon for more of their super fresh seafood and friendly service.
After driving 12 hours from Tennessee, there is only 1 place we HAD to have dinner, Shultzy’s Restaurant! On a small corner in Bayville, NY, this quaint restaurant is serving up some GIANT flavors of the best seafood around! We started off with a dozen of their raw little neck clams that tasted like they were just caught out back. Being from Florida I didn’t think I’d find them that good ever again. I was delightfully surprised when I found them better! So much better we ordered a second dozen. Next up was their Lobster and Shrimp bisque which had lumps of seafood with a creamy base. If I could live in the bowl I would’ve! My mom and I shared a lobster roll that was big enough to share! The lobster was cooked to perfection and was so buttery! My dad ordered their Fra Divalo Pasta which had more seafood than the bowl could hold. It was overflowing with mussels, clams, calamari, and jumbo shrimp! This is hands down a 10/10 restaurant where you feel like family and are treated as such! Make sure to say hi to Jimmy and tell him Gina and the family sent you! Be sure to come in hungry because you will leave with your stomach and your heart full!
The lunch menu … the pulled pork and the shrimp tacos were delicious..the parking is limited… the atmosphere was quiet …no blaring music or television .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Visiting from Dallas! Picked this place because of the high ratings and did not disappoint! You HAVE to stop here on your way through!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Roll
Out with my entire family for Thanksgiving Eve!! So happy!! All the seafood and the burger and fries were amazing!!
Thank you Schultzy!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Burger
Burgers were sour/turned & fries tasted like fish. After giving multiple chances, will never return.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely loved everything about this place, the food, atmosphere, and especially the service. John and Jimmy were nothing but amazing. We got the lobster roll (Maine and Connecticut), the crispy spicy tuna rice, the lobster Mac and cheese, and the affogato. Everything was phenomenal and could not recommend this place enough!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fire Island Oysters and Little Neck Clams, Mac and Cheese, Lobster Roll
Literally a hidden gem. Shrimp and grits is a MUST GET YALL LISTEN TO ME NOW. You won’t regret it. Insanely good brunch
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charming and cozy.
Absolutely the best seafood in the area! Lovely family owned and local
Mussels, raw bar, lobster, and fire roasted oysters are extremely delicious along with everything here!
One of my all time favorite restaurants.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fire Roasted Oysters, Scallops, Lobster Roll
We had Frank and his guys recently cater a raw bar at our wedding at the Sayville Yacht Club…..people are still raving over it!!! Thank you so much you nailed it!!!!! We will be in to pay you a visit
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fire Island Oysters and Little Neck Clams
You won't find a better seafood restaurant on Long Island and you can include the Jersey Shore. Just go down the menu ..... All Fantastic!!! Don't forget to hear the Specials for the Evening. "Over the Top" Dining Experience. You're will LOVE IT !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...