My husband and I stopped in for Brunch and definitely will be back. The best grits ever and every thing from the pancakes to the sausages were excellent. Owner very nice too . Friendly service n we gotta try dinner!Worth the drive from Brooklyn!
sam peresechensky
First time here. Food was delicious, the hostess and our waitress were great, and it's a really nice little restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pan Seared Halibut with Spinach, Seafood Fra Diavolo
Chris Tams
Maybe the best restaurant I've ever been to. Not fancy, not pretentious. Just high quality, friendly and awesome. Coming back as soon as I can!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ImageKrafters
Stopped by for lunch and had this simple yet fresh & incredible cheeseburger. Very comfortable restaurant that specializes in seafood, yet happens to also make amazing burgers! High quality food, great atmosphere and very nice people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer R.
Such a cute albeit small spot near the Sound in Bayshore. Everything from the food to the service was on point. The staff was very friendly and helpful (we had difficulty finding parking and the lot across the street was full so they gave us a tip on where we could find parking down the road - too bad it was pouring!). The place is modern and the bar was super packed when we first arrived - we had to push our way through to get to the hostess and be seated in the rear. Still, we had a great time. For starters we shared the fire roasted oysters... they were like heaven! We also shared the shrimp and lobster bisque - delicious. Even the warm rolls with herb butter were delicious. For my main I had the linguini fra diavola and my friend got the lobster roll. Both were superb and the portions plentiful. I didn't have enough room in my belly for dessert, but I'll definitely be back and look forward to trying something then!
Donna B.
Delicious and fun fresh seafood restaurant in the village of Bayville! Thanks for bringing some good food to our little island!
Dee B.
Trust me you will enjoy this small little gem, with good food and people! Reservations a must and most dishes are seafood
Bill Albert
Great food great drinks.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ann T.
We Love Schultz's ! The seafood is so fresh.. they have so many delicious dishes. Also a very comforting atmosphere!
Christine C.
A great destination for a drive out from NYC! Bayville is a quiet seaside village and Schultzy's Restaurant is a wonderful place to enjoy lunch. Cory makes you feel welcome and is prompt with service. The shrimp and lobster bisque and French onion soup were delicious. My husband says the shrimp po' boy is the best he's had since being in New Orleans. Worth the trip! Good quality food and welcoming staff! its a hidden gem!
Everything about this place is great- but you better have reservations & it does get noisy as it is a small restaurant.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nancy H.
Open for lunch! Google maps said closed, (found out later, website had corrrct hours!) but we stopped by anyway thankfully. Beautiful lunch menu. Perfect French onion soup, sandwiches, etc. Excellent service because down to earth, real, friendly. Shall I continue? Totally recommend.
Andrew
We ate at Schultzy’s for dinner on a recent Friday night. Unusually mild for a November evening, but not enough so to eat outside. Had a nice table for two by the window. Service was excellent as was our food and drinks. The duck taco appetizer special and tuna tartare were both great. They had a special entrée of Peconic Bay Scallops – smaller but sweeter than other types – that my wife tried which were really good and something we hadn’t had before. Was a good recommendation by the staff. I had the linguini with white clam sauce which was very tasty. I’d recommend all the above to try. The bread pudding from Cousin’s Bakery was delicious and rounded off a nice meal. The atmosphere is very comfortable and the owners and staff welcoming. It’s a great place to eat or come by for drinks in the Bayville area.Parking: Free street parking in the village near the restaurant. Might have to go a block or two sometimes, but we've never had a problem parking close by.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lisa D
We wandered in on a beautiful fall Sunday for brunch. Two years ago it was a small, too-busy diner- it is now a chic, cozy upscale restaurant with surprisingly reasonable prices for truly beautiful food, a cut above. I had the shrimp and grits special- shrimp were grilled in olive oil and Old Bay, on a bed of sinfully saucy light Gouda cheesy grits, just superb. My husband had French Toast, elegantly served with fresh fruit, and the coffee was also flavorful. We didn't have drinks this time but they are available. At noon a talented guitarist/singer enhanced the already pleasant, mellow vibe. The owner stopped to chat with each table and service was attentive and friendly. We will be back.
David K.
Great food and service. Our friends want to know when we can go back. Freshest seafood, lobsters and more!
My husband and I stopped in for Brunch and definitely will be back. The best grits ever and every thing from the pancakes to the sausages were excellent. Owner very nice too . Friendly service n we gotta try dinner!Worth the drive from Brooklyn!
First time here. Food was delicious, the hostess and our waitress were great, and it's a really nice little restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pan Seared Halibut with Spinach, Seafood Fra Diavolo
Maybe the best restaurant I've ever been to. Not fancy, not pretentious. Just high quality, friendly and awesome. Coming back as soon as I can!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped by for lunch and had this simple yet fresh & incredible cheeseburger. Very comfortable restaurant that specializes in seafood, yet happens to also make amazing burgers! High quality food, great atmosphere and very nice people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Such a cute albeit small spot near the Sound in Bayshore. Everything from the food to the service was on point. The staff was very friendly and helpful (we had difficulty finding parking and the lot across the street was full so they gave us a tip on where we could find parking down the road - too bad it was pouring!). The place is modern and the bar was super packed when we first arrived - we had to push our way through to get to the hostess and be seated in the rear. Still, we had a great time. For starters we shared the fire roasted oysters... they were like heaven! We also shared the shrimp and lobster bisque - delicious. Even the warm rolls with herb butter were delicious. For my main I had the linguini fra diavola and my friend got the lobster roll. Both were superb and the portions plentiful. I didn't have enough room in my belly for dessert, but I'll definitely be back and look forward to trying something then!
Delicious and fun fresh seafood restaurant in the village of Bayville! Thanks for bringing some good food to our little island!
Trust me you will enjoy this small little gem, with good food and people! Reservations a must and most dishes are seafood
Great food great drinks.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We Love Schultz's ! The seafood is so fresh.. they have so many delicious dishes. Also a very comforting atmosphere!
A great destination for a drive out from NYC! Bayville is a quiet seaside village and Schultzy's Restaurant is a wonderful place to enjoy lunch. Cory makes you feel welcome and is prompt with service. The shrimp and lobster bisque and French onion soup were delicious. My husband says the shrimp po' boy is the best he's had since being in New Orleans. Worth the trip! Good quality food and welcoming staff! its a hidden gem!
Restaurantji Recommends
Everything about this place is great- but you better have reservations & it does get noisy as it is a small restaurant.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Open for lunch! Google maps said closed, (found out later, website had corrrct hours!) but we stopped by anyway thankfully. Beautiful lunch menu. Perfect French onion soup, sandwiches, etc. Excellent service because down to earth, real, friendly. Shall I continue? Totally recommend.
We ate at Schultzy’s for dinner on a recent Friday night. Unusually mild for a November evening, but not enough so to eat outside. Had a nice table for two by the window. Service was excellent as was our food and drinks. The duck taco appetizer special and tuna tartare were both great. They had a special entrée of Peconic Bay Scallops – smaller but sweeter than other types – that my wife tried which were really good and something we hadn’t had before. Was a good recommendation by the staff. I had the linguini with white clam sauce which was very tasty. I’d recommend all the above to try. The bread pudding from Cousin’s Bakery was delicious and rounded off a nice meal. The atmosphere is very comfortable and the owners and staff welcoming. It’s a great place to eat or come by for drinks in the Bayville area.Parking: Free street parking in the village near the restaurant. Might have to go a block or two sometimes, but we've never had a problem parking close by.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We wandered in on a beautiful fall Sunday for brunch. Two years ago it was a small, too-busy diner- it is now a chic, cozy upscale restaurant with surprisingly reasonable prices for truly beautiful food, a cut above. I had the shrimp and grits special- shrimp were grilled in olive oil and Old Bay, on a bed of sinfully saucy light Gouda cheesy grits, just superb. My husband had French Toast, elegantly served with fresh fruit, and the coffee was also flavorful. We didn't have drinks this time but they are available. At noon a talented guitarist/singer enhanced the already pleasant, mellow vibe. The owner stopped to chat with each table and service was attentive and friendly. We will be back.
Great food and service. Our friends want to know when we can go back. Freshest seafood, lobsters and more!