bakers trading sweets co

2823 Merrick Rd Unit A, Bellmore
(516) 214-5746

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Allan Page

This place is great, they make amazing grilled cheese and breakfast sandwiches. I wish they had tomato soup to go with the grilled cheese, but hey, can't have everything. The cookies and sweets are to die for. Stop in, grab a cookie, have a sandwich. The staff are super awesome. They're closed on Mondays though. The rest of the week though, they open. Limited seating, so maybe do a grab and run. This local business is great. Stop in.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcake, Unicorn Cake, Sheet Cake

Stephanie Rodolico

Fresh and delicious.....beautiful cakes

Michele R

Stopped in here after cashing in my birthday scratch off next store. Never knew this place existed. Lovely friendly owner. Bought a cranberry muffin and a corn muffin. First time in years I had a fresh homemade muffin that I didn’t make myself, except these weren’t dry like mine are. These aren’t your typical commercial mix bakery muffins full of preservatives! I will be back to try more homemade goodies.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Olivia Perillo

Everything is fresh and if you are lucky to get there in time, warm from the oven. Mini cheesecakes? Divine. There was a cobbler that I thought my family would fight over. I have never been disappointed by Meg's baking.

Ashley Sarrantonio

The food is good

Kathy Warner

Delicious birthday cake that was beautiful too-thank you Meg!!

Lauren Pagnani

This bakery is great. I needed last minute cupcakes for my daughter's class. The owner quickly made princess crowns and cars to add to the cupcakes to help make them look even more special. My daughter said the cup cakes were delicious and looked amazing. Thank you BTSC!

Melanie Fiume

Bakers Trading Sweets Co. is amazing. We use them for all of our events!Meg, the owner, is delightful; she is so sweet, and she is so talented at what she does.We recently ordered a batch of custom cookies for our breast cancer fundraiser. The cookies came out more beautiful than I could have imagined, and everyone raved about them!Thank you, Bakers Trading Sweets Co! See you for our next event! :)

Liz Wilk

We purchased a box of cookies to bring with us to our families home after a funeral. The cookies were stale and lacked flavor; the red velvet cookie was so hard and crumbly. My sister ordered an espresso and they charged $5 to brew it from a Keurig machine. I’m not from the area, but I wouldn’t visit again.

Kelly Skinner

Ordered a cake & cupcakes from Meg (the delightful owner) & Ali (her wonderful daughter) for my husbands surprise 30th. Not only was the cake & cupcakes phenomenal looking it was extremely moist & so delicious ? 10/10 recommend! A wonderful experience & definitely will be ordering again!

Elizabeth Wilk

We purchased a box of cookies to bring with us to our families home after a funeral. The cookies were stale and lacked flavor; the red velvet cookie was so hard and crumbly. My sister ordered an espresso and they charged $5 to brew it from a Keurig machine. I’m not from the area, but I wouldn’t visit again.

Kristen Ambrosino

I always stop in for a scone and an iced coffee whenever I am nearby and it never disappoints! Everything is made fresh and so yummy! 10/10 would recommend to anyone

Brandy Campbell

This place is amazing, they have stuffed cookies!

Donna Orlando

Placed a custom cookie order with Meg and was so happy with the final product! The cookies were beautiful and tasted even better. All of our guests loved it. Will definitely be back!

fresca Zzz

Stopped in today on a whim. Met the very nice owner and took home the banana chocolate hazelnut mini cake. It was sooo good. Exactly what I was hoping it would be. Tastes so good, like real homemade cake. Delicious!

Loading...