bakers trading sweets co

2823 Merrick Rd Unit A, Bellmore
(516) 214-5746

Recent Reviews

Seeta K.

This place is the best! Everything is delicious and they are such a pleasure to work with. I put in all my dessert order here.

Olivia Perillo

Everything is fresh and if you are lucky to get there in time, warm from the oven. Mini cheesecakes? Divine. There was a cobbler that I thought my family would fight over. I have never been disappointed by Meg's baking.

Mike M.

Came here and was greeted wby a very friendly lady. Bought a danish and some cookies and dessert with a coffee it was really really good. Service was very nice the place was clean what else could you ask for it had a very nice mom n pop vibe inside. Wish these owners nothing but success.

Ashley Sarrantonio

The food is good

Kathy Warner

Delicious birthday cake that was beautiful too-thank you Meg!!

Frank F.

Definitely delicious! My grandfather owned two bakeries while I was growing up, Charlie's Pastry Shop and the Vienna Bakery, so I always compare bakeries to his. This place compares beyond belief. The Key Lime Pie and cupcakes are some of the best I've ever had and they even have pet pastries so we got our dog a cannoli and he loved it. We highly recommend this bakery, not only were the baked goods scrumptious, but the service was excellent also. If my grandpa were still alive I'd be afraid to tell him how good this bakery is!

Lauren Pagnani

This bakery is great. I needed last minute cupcakes for my daughter's class. The owner quickly made princess crowns and cars to add to the cupcakes to help make them look even more special. My daughter said the cup cakes were delicious and looked amazing. Thank you BTSC!

Melanie Fiume

Bakers Trading Sweets Co. is amazing. We use them for all of our events!Meg, the owner, is delightful; she is so sweet, and she is so talented at what she does.We recently ordered a batch of custom cookies for our breast cancer fundraiser. The cookies came out more beautiful than I could have imagined, and everyone raved about them!Thank you, Bakers Trading Sweets Co! See you for our next event! :)

Liz Wilk

We purchased a box of cookies to bring with us to our families home after a funeral. The cookies were stale and lacked flavor; the red velvet cookie was so hard and crumbly. My sister ordered an espresso and they charged $5 to brew it from a Keurig machine. I’m not from the area, but I wouldn’t visit again.

Kelly Skinner

Ordered a cake & cupcakes from Meg (the delightful owner) & Ali (her wonderful daughter) for my husbands surprise 30th. Not only was the cake & cupcakes phenomenal looking it was extremely moist & so delicious ? 10/10 recommend! A wonderful experience & definitely will be ordering again!

Elizabeth Wilk

We purchased a box of cookies to bring with us to our families home after a funeral. The cookies were stale and lacked flavor; the red velvet cookie was so hard and crumbly. My sister ordered an espresso and they charged $5 to brew it from a Keurig machine. I’m not from the area, but I wouldn’t visit again.

Kristen Ambrosino

I always stop in for a scone and an iced coffee whenever I am nearby and it never disappoints! Everything is made fresh and so yummy! 10/10 would recommend to anyone

Kristen A.

Amazing iced coffee and small dessert bites! They also did custom cookies for my sisters bridal shower and they came out beautifully! Also tasted amazing. The owner cooks everything from scratch daily. I love supporting a small business whenever I can and I recommend this shop to everyone!

Gloria M.

Yasssss! So proud and honored to be the first to review. And judging by the way their scrumptious cookies taste, I won't be the last. I first met Meg in 2020 at the Seaford Farmers Market. She had a table filled with super cute cookies with various designs and colors. I had tried so many other so-called designer cookies in the past but none compare to these. There's an undeniable freshness to these cookies; they're crispy but at the same time so soft. And the flavor is hard to describe- almost like there's a tasty secret ingredient. Whatever it is, I'm hooked. Meg was kind enough to make the cookie party favors for my baby shower (baby Yoda) in 2021 and then again for my baby's christening in 2022 (crosses). Her cookies are always a hit. I've seen the designs she's made for other people and her work is always impeccable. I was so happy to hear there's now a storefront where Meg is able to sell her delicious treats on a grander scale. She deserves all the praise and positive reviews Yelp has to offer!

Brandy Campbell

This place is amazing, they have stuffed cookies!

Load More