We stopped by to get a quick cup cake for my son who was having a major cupcake demand. The cupcakes were fresh moist and simply delicious. We wish we had bought more.
Tiffany Huggins
Thanku everytime we come to u . U show out . It was perfect . Everytime we ask for something u go above and beyond and the taste is amazing as well . My son loved his cake .
Melissa de la Torre
Have them make you a custom cake. I’ve ordered numerous with different designs. They integrated photos and personalized themes. The cakes are beautiful and very very delicious. Recently my college roommate from Maryland loved her cake that I traveled with so much that it became breakfast the next day.
Kristi J.
Title: Incredible Beach-Themed Three-Tier Cake - NY Cupcakery ReviewI recently had the pleasure of ordering a custom three-tier cake from NY Cupcakery, and let me tell you, it was absolutely amazing! I chose a beach theme cake for my sister's 50th birthday cake, and it turned out to be a true work of art.The flavors of the cake were an absolute delight. The bottom tier, a decadent chocolate cake with a raspberry cheesecake filling, was an explosion of rich flavors. The combination of the moist chocolate cake and the tangy raspberry cheesecake was simply divine.Moving up to the second tier, I was greeted with a luscious vanilla cake filled with cookies and cream goodness. The smooth vanilla flavor of the cake paired perfectly with the crunchy cookie bits, creating an irresistible blend of textures and tastes.The top tier was a confetti cake, which inside brought a burst of colors to the entire creation. I didn't want all the layers to have a filling for the people that don't like fillings, the confetti was a light and fluffy texture.And let's not forget to mention the outstanding service provided by NY Cupcakery. Joe, the custom cake decorator, went above and beyond to make sure the cake arrived in perfect condition. Considering the challenge of transporting a three-tier cake, I truly appreciated their attention to detail and ensuring that the cake was delivered safely.I can't recommend NY Cupcakery's custom cake services enough. From their attention to detail in crafting a cake that truly captured the beach theme to the outstanding flavors and textures of each tier, this experience was nothing short of exceptional. Whether it's for a special occasion or just to satisfy your sweet tooth, NY Cupcakery is the place to go.
Qiturah Harris
I purchased $40 worth of mini cupcakes for my daughter's sweet 16 party. What I received was an embarrassment and waste of money. No one wanted the cupcakes, they just sat there. Every last one of them were dry, stale, and tasteless, mind you the lady grabbed them freshly out of the oven in the back for me. I truly wished I read the reviews before throwing my money away and they really need to stop selling them until they can give customers a quality product.
Kathy Herman
Cake was moist, not too sweet and delicious. It was a hit at our baby shower. This will be my go to cake bakery
Randy Giovanniello
Makes my birthday better every year with their cupcakes! Can’t live without them! They did amazing with this !
In Wonder
Good cupcakes the owner is nice and options are limited if you stop in and get some spontaneously. I suggest ordering ahead of time.
Lora Webster
Unprofessional and poor quality. When I explained the issue with our order, the employee didn't even apologize. The cupcakes were so smashed into the container that they stuck to the top when I opened it.
paul bargellini
shoved the cupcakes into a container that was way to small for them and destroyed the frosting. complained and they could have cared less. heading someplace else to get new ones...
Cupcakes are awesome and reasonably priced. They have many different options and I've never had bad experience here. Definitely recommend.
Emily
Ordered a dozen s’mores cupcake for my friends bday! Easy ordering process. Cupcakes were great. I forgot to take a pic before we ate them though
Kate B.
I paid a lot for a custom cake expecting high quality and size. I received a tiny, 5" one-layer cake and the design I requested was completely messed up and you could see where items and lettering had been taken off the cake. Looking homemade would be an understatement. The women I spoke with regarding the issues was extremely unprofessional and would not even offer a discount on the messed up cake. In addition, the cake did not take good and was rubbery. Do NOT recommend.
Lori Roman
Stopped in today on my way home from Baldwin because I was driving down Merrick Road and in the mood for dessert. I love cupcakes I decided to get a few mini ones to try different flavors. Every single one I got tasted exactly the same. They were stale and barely had any flavor. I feel like I wasted my money I would never go back!
Jerry Tuohey
Today sunday oct 9 bought 1 doz mimi cupcakes . Every single one was stale. How could you sell stale products. And if you didn't know shame on you.
We stopped by to get a quick cup cake for my son who was having a major cupcake demand. The cupcakes were fresh moist and simply delicious. We wish we had bought more.
Thanku everytime we come to u . U show out . It was perfect . Everytime we ask for something u go above and beyond and the taste is amazing as well . My son loved his cake .
Have them make you a custom cake. I’ve ordered numerous with different designs. They integrated photos and personalized themes. The cakes are beautiful and very very delicious. Recently my college roommate from Maryland loved her cake that I traveled with so much that it became breakfast the next day.
Title: Incredible Beach-Themed Three-Tier Cake - NY Cupcakery ReviewI recently had the pleasure of ordering a custom three-tier cake from NY Cupcakery, and let me tell you, it was absolutely amazing! I chose a beach theme cake for my sister's 50th birthday cake, and it turned out to be a true work of art.The flavors of the cake were an absolute delight. The bottom tier, a decadent chocolate cake with a raspberry cheesecake filling, was an explosion of rich flavors. The combination of the moist chocolate cake and the tangy raspberry cheesecake was simply divine.Moving up to the second tier, I was greeted with a luscious vanilla cake filled with cookies and cream goodness. The smooth vanilla flavor of the cake paired perfectly with the crunchy cookie bits, creating an irresistible blend of textures and tastes.The top tier was a confetti cake, which inside brought a burst of colors to the entire creation. I didn't want all the layers to have a filling for the people that don't like fillings, the confetti was a light and fluffy texture.And let's not forget to mention the outstanding service provided by NY Cupcakery. Joe, the custom cake decorator, went above and beyond to make sure the cake arrived in perfect condition. Considering the challenge of transporting a three-tier cake, I truly appreciated their attention to detail and ensuring that the cake was delivered safely.I can't recommend NY Cupcakery's custom cake services enough. From their attention to detail in crafting a cake that truly captured the beach theme to the outstanding flavors and textures of each tier, this experience was nothing short of exceptional. Whether it's for a special occasion or just to satisfy your sweet tooth, NY Cupcakery is the place to go.
I purchased $40 worth of mini cupcakes for my daughter's sweet 16 party. What I received was an embarrassment and waste of money. No one wanted the cupcakes, they just sat there. Every last one of them were dry, stale, and tasteless, mind you the lady grabbed them freshly out of the oven in the back for me. I truly wished I read the reviews before throwing my money away and they really need to stop selling them until they can give customers a quality product.
Cake was moist, not too sweet and delicious. It was a hit at our baby shower. This will be my go to cake bakery
Makes my birthday better every year with their cupcakes! Can’t live without them! They did amazing with this !
Good cupcakes the owner is nice and options are limited if you stop in and get some spontaneously. I suggest ordering ahead of time.
Unprofessional and poor quality. When I explained the issue with our order, the employee didn't even apologize. The cupcakes were so smashed into the container that they stuck to the top when I opened it.
shoved the cupcakes into a container that was way to small for them and destroyed the frosting. complained and they could have cared less. heading someplace else to get new ones...
Restaurantji Recommends
Cupcakes are awesome and reasonably priced. They have many different options and I've never had bad experience here. Definitely recommend.
Ordered a dozen s’mores cupcake for my friends bday! Easy ordering process. Cupcakes were great. I forgot to take a pic before we ate them though
I paid a lot for a custom cake expecting high quality and size. I received a tiny, 5" one-layer cake and the design I requested was completely messed up and you could see where items and lettering had been taken off the cake. Looking homemade would be an understatement. The women I spoke with regarding the issues was extremely unprofessional and would not even offer a discount on the messed up cake. In addition, the cake did not take good and was rubbery. Do NOT recommend.
Stopped in today on my way home from Baldwin because I was driving down Merrick Road and in the mood for dessert. I love cupcakes I decided to get a few mini ones to try different flavors. Every single one I got tasted exactly the same. They were stale and barely had any flavor. I feel like I wasted my money I would never go back!
Today sunday oct 9 bought 1 doz mimi cupcakes . Every single one was stale. How could you sell stale products. And if you didn't know shame on you.