Supreme’s Pizzeria & Ristorante

1906 Newbridge Rd, Bellmore
(516) 781-1100

Recent Reviews

P Buckley

Awesome and delicious food, I liked the character the place has, and the employees were very welcoming. I will surely come back again.

Chris K

Bring back luigi style Sicilian pizza

Jenn M.

Horrible customer service!!!!!! I ordered my $100 Halloween order 48 hours in advance. I called to confirm the day of and all seemed fine. Well, my order didn't arrive until an hour after I expected it to! I had 11 starving guests at my house. I had to call 5 different times to see if it was even out for delivery. I called back to speak to someone in regards to some type of discount and answers and they never got back to me!! There are plenty of other great pizzerias with great customer service that I will be ordering from now on!!!! They should be embarrassed and ashamed!

max outsen

Great service, never disappoints. Will be back again.

Randy Moore

Love the two men behind the counter, and the pizzas dope

Michael B

Tried the cauliflower pizza one night and it was absolutely delicious. Few weeks later ordered 4 meals to take home and one was better than the other. I've tried many places in the area, and I must say this is by FAR the best. They earned themselves a new customer, and I will happily spend my money here for the foreseeable future. Great job.

Michael B.

Pizza is good. But the place is filthy. Everything is run down and old looking. This place needs a cleaning and a renovation. I sat down with my pizza and was skeeved, so I immediately took it to go. Hopefully they address this.

Grace Mary

AMAZING FOOD & a healthy alternative if you get zoodles and the cauliflower thin crust pizza tastes better then pizza! Ask for Greg he's the BEST!!

Heather Thomson

Best tasting pizza plus the most delicious penne ala vodka I've ever had from a pizzeria/restaurant!😋 Yum!😋

Bill K.

5 stars for the food, 2 stars for the service. My mom always raves about this place because they have cauliflower pizza, which she loves. So when I visited her today, we decided to order a few pies. I went to pick them up, as they don't deliver on Sunday, and somehow one of the pies, a plain pizza, was interpreted as a supreme pie. I love supreme pizza, and am in retail management, so I didn't want to make a fuss over something that wasn't a big deal, considering how often I deal with such situations on a regular basis. But the employee on duty could've done a much better job. He argued that the person who placed the order definitely said a supreme pizza, and while he offered to make a new pie, it was clearly going to be an inconvenience for him based on his tone. He also kept referring to the person who placed the order as "he". The person who placed the order was my mother, so he's lucky he didn't get punched in the f****** face. I'll mention again that I'm in retail management, so I know that you have to put up with a lot of s*** in the service industry, which is why I don't like to make waves in these kinds of situations. But I also know that it's part of the job to satisfy the customer. Arguing with the customer over their order, not apologizing, giving a passive aggressive offer to remedy the issue, and then not offering a discount or extending any sort of olive branch to make things right, is absolutely not part of the job. I'd understand a mistake if it was insanely busy, but the guy on duty was sitting in a booth watching baseball when I got to the restaurant, with no other customers around. The pizza was excellent, I can't stress that enough. The experience? I could've done without. The employee in question needs to have service procedures reviewed with him.

Dom C.

Very nice people convenient location great for a quick bite if you live in the area .not the best pizza around but it's good however there cauliflower panini is amazing and the staff is amazing they take care of all the local kids in the area which you really don't see anymore

Bonnie Lee

Always wonderful here. Very polite and accommodating

Amir G

I Work hard for my money so I rarley give new places a chance because I dont want to spend money and the food is terrible but I decided to give supremes a try since the old pizza place that was there was great! I called a few times to place a pick up order but I GOT NO ANSWER! So I drive there and pull in and I see the only worker sitting outside cause its slow ( thats why he didn't hear the phone ring ) SMH . So I ask for a pepperoni slice and a regualr slice and I was charged $7! So $3 for a regular slice but he charges a WHOLE DOLLAR for a few pieces of pepperoni? SAD! So Im given my food and WOW I could not believe HOW SMALL THE SLICES WERE!! and he had the nerve to charge me that $7 ? Then to top it all off a young kid about 10years old wanted to use the bathroom and the worker told him its only for customers --__-- Like let the little kid use the bathroom!! Would you rather him go in back your shop and pee on the wall? Like come on man... Overheard the worker saying he lost money so no wonder he was trying to get the little kid to buy something to use the bathroom and Rip me off!! WELL YOU LOST A CUSTOMER!! and you would of made way more money in the future by giving me a REAL SLICE. And letting that young boy use the bathroom! Now we will both remember the experience you gave us!!

Brooke A.

This is probably my new favorite local spot to eat, and their cauliflower quesadilla is 100% my favorite meal to have anywhere. From that, to the grandma slice, to the garlic knots, to the chicken scarpariello, to the linguini alla nola, to the linguini al fredo, to the mozzarella sticks - everything we've had here has been amazing! The portion sizes are excellent, and the staff is the icing on the cake. Greg and guys in the kitchen are all personable and welcoming and generous. 100% 13/10 recommend.

Pat F.

Great atmosphere great food. First time here, I'll be back next week for sure. I got the wings and a regular pie.

Load More

Supreme’s Pizzeria & Ristorante

1906 Newbridge Rd, Bellmore, NY 11710
(516) 781-1100