The Green Door Tavern

4739 NY-430, Bemus Point
(716) 386-3229

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Annamarie Phalen

Casual pub with mostly local patrons. Low prices, food looked good. Poll table & outdoor seating too.

Trav Cav

Great wings

Vanessa Barton

Good food and service

Karl McCall

My wife and I have eaten here many times with success. In February, we visited. After asking for our order ti be taken, they finally did…. Only to have us waiting an extraordinary amount of time then being told our order wasn’t put in so we would have to wait longer. ( we were trying to beat a snowstorm and get to our home in PA) . Our drinks were comped but we never got our food. This evening, we had a table of six. Everyone got their meals except one of us.. they forgot to put her meal order in..( it was on the same ticket as the rest of ours. Three of the other five were finished eating before she got her meal. Oh she was comped $5 ( which was nice but two missed meal orders in a row has really left a sour note with us and had the rest of the table waited out of etiquette, our meals would have been cold ) We have tried to eat there each time we are in the area. Just not sure about the decline in service .

Marcie Berkshire

Great fun and food

Paula Ruprecht

Favorite CHQ location for good wings, good food, and great atmosphere.

Sam Abood

Cozy tavern with plenty of beer options and delicious food. The complimentary popcorn is a nice addition.

Alan Morganti

Waited over an hour for an order of wings, wasn't that crowded, several other tables waited over an too. The owner didn't seem to care either

Val Hemink

What a great place! Always so fun. The food is excellent and the servers are very attentive. Keep doing what you are doing!

Micky J Curtician

Easily a favorite local place to eat and have a few drinks. Service is great and the staff is always friendly.

Shelly Heath McCall

Service was very disorganized. Had to ask for someone to take our order.. we saw five different servers . And after 45 mins and watching three tables around us who came in after us get their food.. we asked. They forgot to put our order in. We had a two hour drive home on bad weather roads so we left without being fed. Yes they comped us our drinks. Food had always been good when we got it . Just didn’t get anything . Disappointed. Bad experience .

Jason Magda

Great place for wings. Visited on a snowmobile ride. Good sled parking.

Victoria Yonkers

Had an awesome buffet style party on the porch with family. Julie had the heaters and firetable going. Cozy and fun on a cold autumn evening!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Orsini

Very good place for food pizza atmosphere great place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Complimentary Popcorn

Emily Hall

A great little tavern, I have never had an issue with people getting too drunk. AMAZING peanut butter pie.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Turkey Bacon Cheddar Wrap, Fried Pickles, Peanut Butter Pie, Complimentary Popcorn

Loading...