Bethpage Bagels
442 N Wantagh Ave, Bethpage
(516) 931-8428
Customers' Favorites
Beacon Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Menu
Photos
+23 photos
+22 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I shouldn't have tried this place because I can't stop eating their bagels. Tomorrow will be my fourth consecutive day. My everything bagel is perfectly toasted from the outside and pillow like soft from the inside. The veggie cream cheese is always so fresh n light. People working the counter are so nice,polite, and ready to help with anything. Keep doing the great work. Your bagels make me very happy.
Fantastic bagels. I like my bagels untoasted and this nailed it. It has that nice crunch on the inside and the soft doughiness on the inside. Lastly, the cream cheese is light and fluffy, making it a perfect pairing.
You May Also Like
Fukee Asian Cuisine - 440 N Wantagh Ave
![]()
Sushi Bar, Asian Fusion, Seafood, Japanese
Kitchen Catering Corporation - 430 Hicksville Rd
![]()
Party & Event Planning, Caterers
these are THE BEST BAGELS on long island with the kindest staff that make you feel right at home. kevin and christy are the absolute best! the bagels are baked fresh in-house everyday and pillowy with the perfect amount of chew!! I love getting the everything bagel with their vegetable cream cheese, which is made with fresh scallions, radishes, and more. No one does it like them 😠highly recommend!!!