Moscato Bakery & Cafe

546 Stewart Ave, Bethpage
(516) 622-9711

Recent Reviews

Nick F.

Stopped in today for some dessert after a quick, casual dinner in town. Lots of choices of cookies, pastries and cakes.We ordered a Yellow cake with chocolate frosting that was very good. They also offered to customize a message on the cake.Fresh and the icing was not too sweet.Friendly service, Clean.We would stop by again when craving some fresh baked cake, YUM.

Roz Cavallaro

I’m very upset with the quality of my birthday cannoli cake. It was made with boxed cake and frosting from the grocery store. My entire family took one bite and threw it out. Tasted like chemicals.

Food: 1

Suraj Niroula

I am a huge cheesecake fan and have had a lot of cheesecakes but theirs is my favorite.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheesecake

OldSchool4Life

A Gem! I Came here Christmas Eve in the am and saw long lines out the door. I waited patiently it’s an Amazing old school bakery with traditional Italian made specialties. I came for the Italian cheesecake and left with the American style it was out of this world! I dare you to find a better one. It’s serious! Decadent, creamy with a light Graham cracker crust cooked to perfection. My family went wild for it. Everyone ahead of me in line left with one or 2. I also bought a linzer tart and semolina baguette very good. Gabby helped me and she was a doll. I will be back, I highly recommend this place prices are more than fair for the quality. Delicious! A++++++++

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheesecake

Giovanni Castronovo

Everythings fresh and tastes

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anthony Caramanico

Always a pleasure going here....my daughters bday cake over the summer was unbelievable!!!! Go here weekly to get cookies for the kids ! Luv moscato !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cristina R.

A heartfelt thank you to Franco Moscato and the whole team for executing not only one 40th Birthday cakes but two! The Sagittarius vintage heart cake was gluten free due to a family member having celiac disease. It was absolutely delicious and had a hint of lemon taste to the vanilla cake, which was delightful. My brother-in-law asked if he could bring home the leftovers for him to enjoy, which was a compliment in itself! The Union Restaurant in Eisenhower Park took great care of it, while eating dinner for Part I of my 40th Birthday celebration. As for Part II, of the celebrations we enjoyed a tiered carrot cake which was perfectly moist and paired well with a cappuccino at Bijou. Moscato Bakery was well known by the establishment and it lit up their eyes when they saw the gold sticker on the box. Both cakes were made to perfection via images given and were more than enough for the amount of guests at each celebration. I highly recommend Franco and Bakery for all special occasions and baked goods. Cheers, to 40 and fabulous! Thank you again for making my 40th Birthday celebrations memorable and a piece of cake.

A L

We have ordered few cupcakes and had a very pleasant experience. Everyone was nice, professional and diligent.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcake

Christina Karki

I ordered a smash cake for baby’s first birthday and really really happy with it. They made the exact design I gave them and the price was very reasonable compared to other bakeries.

Julia Costigan

Wonderful bakery with fantastic treats!!

Elisha G.

Usually this place is great however the last time I went the owner was berating brand new employees - highly inappropriate.

Nicholas R

Everything is always delicious. Traditional old school Italian bakery. They have saviardi!! Almond cookies are also a must. Try the lard/meat bread!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Patrick Volkommer

Very good. Nice bakery

Thomas Thomas

Fantastic and friendly service. The food I’ve tried there is all excellent. The nonpareil sprinkle cookies are some of the best around. Rainbow cookies are also awesome. I’m from Long Island and this is a must for me to stop and pick up food prior to leaving to head back to my current state of residence.

Jean Marie Chiaramonte

Creamy cannoli cake with choco chips, sliced lightly toasted almonds around the sides, laced with rum flavor & the creamy cannolis with fresh crispy shells? The ladies were so nice as well!

Load More