Great food. The ham-&-Swiss melt on egg bagel (w/garlic butter) was amazing.
However, one-star off for no spoon provided with yogurt parfait. (Thank goodness there was enough body with the granola to scoop out up — awkwardly — with a fork.)
Another point off for the sliced watermelon: It was abominable, and I ended up just chucking it after a couple samplings. 🤢
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Donald S
Food was very tasty, definitely will come back for more!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gregory Krohn
Always good food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anthony C
Bagels are ok, sometimes hard to make a phone order with language barrier. Just a typical bagel shop slightly overpriced
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Paul Abate
So my daughter had a ton of company at her house today. Three weeks ago, she ordered food from this store for delivery. Delivery was scheduled for noon. 1215 my daughter called, and was told driver just left. 30 minutes later (1245) food finally showed up. I don’t tip for bad customer service. 45 minutes late means no tip. My daughter looks at the sandwich in the house and it was not what she ordered. She called to complain and the girl said I have to call the driver and I’ll call you back. 20 minutes later no one called back. My daughter called again. And they put her on endless hold. My son in law went to the store with the sandwich. They did refund the money but insisted on a tip because they hired the driver to make the delivery (the driver was behind the counter). I’m all for tipping good customer service but insist on a tip and you get nothing. Never going back there again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
James Scavone
the people are nice but i ordered a plain bagel w cream cheese and a sesame flat with a hasbrown bacon and cheese and they put the hashbrown on the cream cheese bagel and the bacon on my bagel was hard as a rock to the point where i had to throw out my whole bagel. my bagel was inedible 5 minutes after my order number was called. gonna go to town bagel from now on smh
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Tony M
Food is good but they really need to get rid of that glass at this point, covid has been over, its like talking to an inmate, basically have to scream your order to get across the glass panels
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anand Seemangal
Great food and great service, but hands down one of the worse coffee cups and lids I have ever had to deal with. It never fits properly, leaks, comes off easily and makes a mess.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
L Odie
Past 4 times I've been there when I get to work and open my sandwich it's wrong! I should not have to open it there to make sure they made it correctly. Very disappointing.
Cute place but they were very rude from the outset. Food was unimpressive. Don’t recommend them at all. And forget it if you have people in your party who are vegan. WAY overpriced for what is offered
Dietary restrictions: No accommodations for dietary restrictions… rude, actually
Parking: Some street parking
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ron
I am a regular customer of Stuff a Bagel Bethpage. I often pick up dozens of bagels from my office staff and buy breakfast for my wife and I a few times a month. Today I went in by myself to get my usual sausage, egg and cheese on an everything bagel which cost around $8. When attempting to pay with a debit card, I was told there was a $10 minimum With no cash on me, they just wouldn’t take my order. I Understand profit margins are probably tight so I can understand a minimum for credit cards, but didn’t think a debit card would be an issue. They would rather not serve a regular customer that spends hundreds of dollars there over one dollar fee on a debit card. Due to their refusal of service, I was forced to go to Orlando deli across the street and my bagel with sausage, egg, and cheese was excellent. Someone should inform the owner that once you change a customer’s buying habits, it’s very difficult to win them back. I hope the one-dollar fee was worth losing a longtime customer.
Tiffany's Good Eats
My go to spot in Long Island to grab bagels. They get orders out quickly and the food is delicious. My usual is their egg everything bagel toasted with 2 eggs and cheese. You could also choose how you would like your egg cooked.
Note they have a $10 minimum for credit cards.
C. M.
Noticed two dark spots in my corn muffin ?, I was concerned at first but they turned out to be chocolate chips. Are things getting cleaned before the next use? Idk.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
E Northport
Sandwich was barely ok; definitely not worth the cost. Careless cashier, clueless deli personnel. Sandwiches posted with no pricing.Paid cash, No receipt offered and forgot to ask for one. Rushed.Will not return.
Great food. The ham-&-Swiss melt on egg bagel (w/garlic butter) was amazing.
However, one-star off for no spoon provided with yogurt parfait. (Thank goodness there was enough body with the granola to scoop out up — awkwardly — with a fork.)
Another point off for the sliced watermelon: It was abominable, and I ended up just chucking it after a couple samplings. 🤢
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Food was very tasty, definitely will come back for more!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always good food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bagels are ok, sometimes hard to make a phone order with language barrier. Just a typical bagel shop slightly overpriced
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
So my daughter had a ton of company at her house today. Three weeks ago, she ordered food from this store for delivery. Delivery was scheduled for noon. 1215 my daughter called, and was told driver just left. 30 minutes later (1245) food finally showed up. I don’t tip for bad customer service. 45 minutes late means no tip.
My daughter looks at the sandwich in the house and it was not what she ordered. She called to complain and the girl said I have to call the driver and I’ll call you back. 20 minutes later no one called back. My daughter called again. And they put her on endless hold. My son in law went to the store with the sandwich. They did refund the money but insisted on a tip because they hired the driver to make the delivery (the driver was behind the counter). I’m all for tipping good customer service but insist on a tip and you get nothing. Never going back there again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
the people are nice but i ordered a plain bagel w cream cheese and a sesame flat with a hasbrown bacon and cheese and they put the hashbrown on the cream cheese bagel and the bacon on my bagel was hard as a rock to the point where i had to throw out my whole bagel. my bagel was inedible 5 minutes after my order number was called. gonna go to town bagel from now on smh
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Food is good but they really need to get rid of that glass at this point, covid has been over, its like talking to an inmate, basically have to scream your order to get across the glass panels
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and great service, but hands down one of the worse coffee cups and lids I have ever had to deal with. It never fits properly, leaks, comes off easily and makes a mess.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Past 4 times I've been there when I get to work and open my sandwich it's wrong! I should not have to open it there to make sure they made it correctly. Very disappointing.
Great Breakfast &
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Cute place but they were very rude from the outset. Food was unimpressive. Don’t recommend them at all. And forget it if you have people in your party who are vegan. WAY overpriced for what is offered
Dietary restrictions: No accommodations for dietary restrictions… rude, actually
Parking: Some street parking
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
I am a regular customer of Stuff a Bagel Bethpage. I often pick up dozens of bagels from my office staff and buy breakfast for my wife and I a few times a month. Today I went in by myself to get my usual sausage, egg and cheese on an everything bagel which cost around $8. When attempting to pay with a debit card, I was told there was a $10 minimum With no cash on me, they just wouldn’t take my order. I Understand profit margins are probably tight so I can understand a minimum for credit cards, but didn’t think a debit card would be an issue. They would rather not serve a regular customer that spends hundreds of dollars there over one dollar fee on a debit card. Due to their refusal of service, I was forced to go to Orlando deli across the street and my bagel with sausage, egg, and cheese was excellent. Someone should inform the owner that once you change a customer’s buying habits, it’s very difficult to win them back. I hope the one-dollar fee was worth losing a longtime customer.
My go to spot in Long Island to grab bagels. They get orders out quickly and the food is delicious. My usual is their egg everything bagel toasted with 2 eggs and cheese. You could also choose how you would like your egg cooked.
Note they have a $10 minimum for credit cards.
Noticed two dark spots in my corn muffin ?, I was concerned at first but they turned out to be chocolate chips. Are things getting cleaned before the next use? Idk.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Sandwich was barely ok; definitely not worth the cost. Careless cashier, clueless deli personnel. Sandwiches posted with no pricing.Paid cash, No receipt offered and forgot to ask for one. Rushed.Will not return.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Loading...