Sushi Time 560

560 Stewart Ave, Bethpage
(516) 513-1622

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Court A

Place is great. Love the sushi

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Alyssa Wittenberg

Showed up with a party of 7 at 11:30am for an early lunch. Their door says they open at 11 and their website says 11:15. We were told they needed another 15 minutes to set up so we waited. 15 minutes go by and they very rudely told us again they needed more time, so we left. Won’t be trying again.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Diana Brewster

Visit Date: August 15, 2024

I came here with the guy I'm seeing and some friends for his birthday. He picked it out. It cost us $70 a person but we were also chipping in to cover my guy for his birthday! Basically you fill out what you want on slips of paper the restaurant provides and they bring everything out to you. I like all you can eat buffets but I like these kinds of places where they bring it out to you as well.

They don't serve alcohol but you can bring what you would like to drink and they are fine with you drinking it in the restaurant.

I thought the sushi and food was good and I would definitely come back again!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Zachary Rosenblum

I don’t want to eat sushi anywhere but here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nikhil Tandon

After a long volleyball tournament, my friends and I finally visited this restaurant they had been recommending for a while, and it was definitely worth it. The food was amazing! The service was okay, and since it wasn't busy, they were always checking up on us. We ordered a lot of food, and while some items were occasionally missing, the staff explained the different sushi options and dishes very well. The atmosphere was alright but could be improved with some investment to match the quality of the food. Dessert was fantastic; I tried fried Oreos for the first time, and they were amazing.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Godzilla Roll, Scallion Pancake, Gyoza, California Roll, Chicken Teriyaki, Filet Mignon Roll, Fried Oreo

Sabrina

I came here with my cousin because I had came here once before with a friend. I've raved about this place to so many people for years for them to come here. But I was really disappointed in the treatment from the manager and the waiter. First the manager walked by and took my packaged chopsticks off the table didn't even ask if I was going to use it which I was going to use it for my sushi that I hadn't gotten to yet. Then my cousin asked for extra napkins and they gave literally two small napkins, this is an all you can eat dining so when I asked for another order of the appetizer they give you paper to put how many pieces of food you want in an order I put a certain amount and the manager gave me less then what I asked for he even looked at me weird when I had asked for 1 more order that made me feel very uncomfortable becasue it was like as if he didn't want me to order anything else and then ontop of paying for your food, they charge you for taking out your leftover sushi as well. They were rushing us out and kept asking if we were taking out the sushi so I finally told him yes we'll take it out so they could stop asking and the waiter bough out the containers and the manager bought out the BILL!! We haven't even had dessert yet and I wasn't even done eating yet I had 1 shrimp tempura left on my plate and the waiter grabbed it off the table and I told him I wasn't even done yet and he told me oh you can't take it out. I said I wasn't going to take it out because I wasn't even done yet why are you guys rushing us out? We didn't have dessert yet and you brought the bill to us. They knew we had just a few pieces of food left on the table 2 pieces of green onion pancakes and 2 vegetable gyoza dumplings and the 1 shrimp tempura they quickly grabbed it off the table, they want to make extra money off of you so they rush thier customers as long as they get that extra money from you to take out your leftovers they dont care how they act towards their customers. They walked away and stood by the register and stared at me to see if I was going to eat the 1! Shrimp tempura that really made me uncomfortable and it made my cousin very uncomfortable she was so upset how they were acting and how they rushed us so we will not be coming back here no more unfortunately because I had loved this place but after this treatment I won't be coming back or telling anyone else that I know to come here.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 1

Isabelle Cosgrove

Poor service. Waitress was hovering HEAVILY after we finished our second round; I mean this girl was standing next to the table and staring us down - which made for an uncomfortable last half to the meal. This was not our experience last year when we came, nor the year prior.We don’t order a lot to eat each round because we never want to risk wasting food/filling up fast. Unless there is a time limit, we take our time and enjoy our time together. Each round consisted of 4-5 items; split between two people. We noticed that portions have become smaller over the years, but didn’t mind this as we *thought* we could just order more if we wanted.After a small third round of sashimi; 3 INDIVIDUAL pcs + 1 app, She did not offer us another sushi roll sheet to fill out and purposely left us just the sheet where desserts are stated on the bottom. Asked up 3-4 times in the span of 10 minutes if we wanted dessert while we were still waiting on food to arrive, again, this girl is standing next to us while we were trying to talk. It felt like she was holding our third round of food on purpose because it didn’t come until an almost additional 10 minutes later - well after we politely told her that we’re still deciding.. We were one of three (small) tables there, so this is a stark contrast to how our other rounds came out.It seems that they do not want you to go past the second round - no matter how much your order - and while I understand this attitude if we were wasting food or making a spectacle of engorging ourselves: but we were literally there for *just* over an hour and left hungry. Quality is fine, service is terrible, and the business seems to be going downhill. Again, we’ve been here 3-4 times in the past and things were way better all around - but our experience today showed us that it’s gotten to the point where one cannot justify spending $75 (drinks, meal, tip) for subpar AYCE if it’s not, well … AYCE! Maybe if they went back to $23.95-25.95 per person, but for over 30 dollars each? Come on now. I left regretful, wishing we went to one of our other favorite spots on the island.I guess you can try harder than we did to order more food, but unless you want to spend your entire day off with the staff of Sushi Time 560 waiting on it to arrive, I recommend avoiding here unless you’re looking for a light lunch. Save your money, find a local happy hour and order a bunch of apps for an even better experience.Disappointing.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 2

Adam Cox

Great food and service, sushi is amazing, very fresh, highly recommend ??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Miso Soup, Spring Roll, Seaweed Salad, Spicy Tuna, Tuna, Beef Satay

Victor W

I have been coming here for 10 years now. The best all you can eat sushi on the island hands down.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rietika Patel

Nice casual unlimited sushi place, good food and service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Randomgirl

Everything was good! The servers were extremely nice and very attentive. The Fried Oreos are a must!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Godzilla Roll, Scallion Pancake, Salad

Stephen C

? Outstanding service and a friendly staff make dining here a delight!? The beef satay is a must-try, and the quick service is a bonus.? Highly recommend this spot for all-you-can-eat!#DelightfulDining#TopNotchService

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pete Pull

I have come here a ton of times and always great fresh sushi and starters. It's a true all you can eat sushi place with reasonable prices. Only thing to watch out for is you might notice that they don't bring out all the food that you ask for Besides this great food clean restaurant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Aidan Noble

Great food, great AYCE price-$30 per person, freshest fish in a good while, service is great, but can get a little hectic on crowded evenings. I have never been disappointed with the food here ever since I started coming here when I was 8.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Spider Roll, Assorted Sushi and Sashimi, Miso Soup, Fried Banana, Soup, Seaweed Salad, Gyoza, Spicy Tuna, Godzilla Roll, Salad

Erik Conlon

Best sushi I’ve had in Long

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Godzilla Roll, Special Edamame, Miso Soup, Soup, Salad

Loading...