Brewster Superette

2586 Carmel Ave, Brewster
(845) 279-3415

Recent Reviews

Sue Roman

They catered a family reunion for 50 people. Delicious food, generous quantity and fair price. Chef Rosa was easy to work with and we developed a crowd-pleasing menu together. She supplied all the serving dishes, kept the food hot, and cleaned up afterwards. I will definitely call her for my next catered event.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anthony Ragaglia

A charming and cozy small-town deli that offers a delightful culinary experience. Their expertise lies in creating delectable Spanish cuisine, but they also present a commendable Italian sandwich. If you happen to be passing through the area, it is highly recommended that you make a stop and savor their culinary offerings.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

brian wieczorek

Great place for quick meal that is prepared with love.... great smiling staff, food is awesome and great portion

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Sweetish Meat Balls and Buttered Noodles, Swedish Meat Balls w Noodles, Chicken Parmigiana, Mashed Potatoes, Extra Meat, Superette Special, Eggs and Cheese on a Roll

Anthony B.

Food is always good and the staff is friendly. Definitely recommend this place for breakfast, lunch or dinner.

An Artist & A Kitchen

All the energy is there! The season in the kitchen bangs with the beat of the Christmas music over its intercom system. The chefs are bright red in a tight sled with their passion for the food they make. All the locals know! This is the “go to” for a lunch work break and or the wine up from the daily grind. You won’t be disappointed here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Al Martucci

Best deli in the area. Food is excellent. Service is fast and friendly plus all the workers are extremely friendly. It has a family atmosphere. I highly recommend them.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer E.

Delicious food! Great selection of hot foods daily. Excellent service and friendly staff. Seating area is always full of people enjoying their food! The new owners are wonderful.

John D

Great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Glassman

Great value. Good food, better than the 24hr deli down the street.

Frank Westervelt

Every day place is all around awesome place

Johnny A.

Good food, service was fast! Had multiple things over the course of a week could say a bad word. Will say it's a bit pricey but you get what you pay for.

James Guerci

Great sandwiches here!

Brian D

I had an amazing Roast beef sandwich here. Best sandwich I've had in many years. Also, incredibly kind staff. Way above average kindness compared to most delis in NY. Thank you, I'll be back!

Cristine Furey

Love this place. The ladies who work here make do a great job. The place is spotless. Thank you.

Sarah Borsari

The Superette recently catered a large graduation/retirement party for over 100 people. Rosa was great to work with, and gave us many helpful suggestions in our planning. She was organized, on time and prepared. We received so many positive comments about the food and the service. I would highly recommend hiring Rosa and the Superette’s services.-Chris and Patti Borsari

Load More