The prime rib was delicious. The dinner price was excellent and so was the service. I'd return in the future.
David
Amazing food that came out surprisingly quickly. The converted barn is a great space, very warm despite its size.
Diana
Great dinner! Our first time at Tilly's Table...I'm sure we'll be back! Service was attentive albeit a little slow at times (I appreciate that over servers constantly hanging over your shoulder though). Food was absolutely delicious and we definitely over-ordered and took home extra. Love the ambiance, especially the stone fireplace. Overall a great time!
Julie
Food and service was very good. They have a really nice menu and everything we have ever tried we really liked.
Mark
Good good nice value. Dining room felt like a cafeteria in a ski lodge. Could be nicer at the prices they get
Maryann
My first time there for a dinner and the special on your prime rib was awesome. Service was good , waiter and waitress were pleasant - the only thing that could be improved is the noise level. Tillys needs some sort of material to quiet the level of chatter in the room .
diane
First time we went to the restaurant. We went on a Thursday night to get Prime Rib. It was absolutely delicious. We also had crab cakes and Mozzarella stick appetizers and the Bronzino dinner, again very good. We will be going back for sure!
Denise
Well, Lobster rolls are great, but in October, we went with 4 friends for the Prime Rib special. The service was so slow that we had to devour bread to hold us. The steak was too thin and not very flavorful, and the lobster rolls were good, as usual, but took 20 minutes longer than the rest of the food to come to the table... We've been there a couple other times and it was fine, so maybe it was just that day...hope your experience is better. Beautiful surroundings, great sunset views from top of the hill.
Maritza Quinn
21.50 for a Cosmo, are you kidding me. We're in Brewster not Manhattan, won't be going back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 5
Susan Curry
Went for Happy Hour and sat at the bar. Drinks were fabulous and the Bartender Lauren was not only attentive, but went over and above to make sure each customer was satisfied. I watched her not only take our special drink request with grace but other guests requests as well. We will definitely be back!
Prime Rib was very good but portion size was a bit different. Drinks were excellent. Ambiance was great. We will definitely return.
Bobby S
Decided to try brunch for the first time at tilly's. dinner is always fantastic but the brunch was lacking. Food took a while to come out and everything was cold. Will still return for dinners but not for brunch. Brought it to the attention of the girl at the front desk and she said she will let the manager know.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Meganne
We had a lovely dinner. I had filet and lobster tail. Both perfectly cooked. Husbands prime rib also perfect. Room is open w high ceiling, rustic ambiance but a little noisy, not uncomfortable. Service was ok. Pleasant servers. They were trying but could work on coordinating efforts to keep an eye out for customers needs. We had a great evening
Barb
We went for the $29.99 prime rib special. We also took advantage of the half-price bottles of wine. Our server, Kayle (sp.?) was outstanding!!! The staff here are all well-trained, but Kaylie was super. She answered our questions, made recommendations when asked, was attentive and just charming. She really took care of us. The lobster mac & cheese is a must, and she was so happy we ordered it to share as an appetizer. The prime rib, while well-seasoned, was overcooked. However, we chalked that up to just this one night, and we will definitely be back.
Jumanah Tawil
My daughter got married on sept 13 2025 at Tilly’s table we’ll let me tell you the best decision ever at first I was like we gonna drive an hour my family entire lives local but my daughter insit so we di I will give the most credit to Megan she kept my daughter calm thru out the plan
The prime rib was delicious. The dinner price was excellent and so was the service. I'd return in the future.
Amazing food that came out surprisingly quickly. The converted barn is a great space, very warm despite its size.
Great dinner! Our first time at Tilly's Table...I'm sure we'll be back! Service was attentive albeit a little slow at times (I appreciate that over servers constantly hanging over your shoulder though). Food was absolutely delicious and we definitely over-ordered and took home extra. Love the ambiance, especially the stone fireplace. Overall a great time!
Food and service was very good. They have a really nice menu and everything we have ever tried we really liked.
Good good nice value. Dining room felt like a cafeteria in a ski lodge. Could be nicer at the prices they get
My first time there for a dinner and the special on your prime rib was awesome. Service was good , waiter and waitress were pleasant - the only thing that could be improved is the noise level. Tillys needs some sort of material to quiet the level of chatter in the room .
First time we went to the restaurant. We went on a Thursday night to get Prime Rib. It was absolutely delicious. We also had crab cakes and Mozzarella stick appetizers and the Bronzino dinner, again very good. We will be going back for sure!
Well, Lobster rolls are great, but in October, we went with 4 friends for the Prime Rib special. The service was so slow that we had to devour bread to hold us. The steak was too thin and not very flavorful, and the lobster rolls were good, as usual, but took 20 minutes longer than the rest of the food to come to the table... We've been there a couple other times and it was fine, so maybe it was just that day...hope your experience is better. Beautiful surroundings, great sunset views from top of the hill.
21.50 for a Cosmo, are you kidding me. We're in Brewster not Manhattan, won't be going back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 5
Went for Happy Hour and sat at the bar. Drinks were fabulous and the Bartender Lauren was not only attentive, but went over and above to make sure each customer was satisfied. I watched her not only take our special drink request with grace but other guests requests as well.
We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Prime Rib was very good but portion size was a bit different. Drinks were excellent. Ambiance was great. We will definitely return.
Decided to try brunch for the first time at tilly's. dinner is always fantastic but the brunch was lacking. Food took a while to come out and everything was cold. Will still return for dinners but not for brunch. Brought it to the attention of the girl at the front desk and she said she will let the manager know.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
We had a lovely dinner. I had filet and lobster tail. Both perfectly cooked. Husbands prime rib also perfect. Room is open w high ceiling, rustic ambiance but a little noisy, not uncomfortable. Service was ok. Pleasant servers. They were trying but could work on coordinating efforts to keep an eye out for customers needs. We had a great evening
We went for the $29.99 prime rib special. We also took advantage of the half-price bottles of wine. Our server, Kayle (sp.?) was outstanding!!! The staff here are all well-trained, but Kaylie was super. She answered our questions, made recommendations when asked, was attentive and just charming. She really took care of us. The lobster mac & cheese is a must, and she was so happy we ordered it to share as an appetizer. The prime rib, while well-seasoned, was overcooked. However, we chalked that up to just this one night, and we will definitely be back.
My daughter got married on sept 13 2025 at Tilly’s table we’ll let me tell you the best decision ever at first I was like we gonna drive an hour my family entire lives local but my daughter insit so we di I will give the most credit to Megan she kept my daughter calm thru out the plan
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...