Tilly's Table

100 NY-312, Brewster
(845) 808-1840

Recent Reviews

Bob Sieber

Went to a comedy night and the setup did not really accommodate the crowd. Long lines to get food and drinks. Comedy was great. Have not tried the restaurant yet.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 3

Frank Saccente Sr

Beautiful and clean

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

LisaR

We had a party of 6 in which case 4 of us had been there already and had good experiences prior. However, this time our experience overall was extremely disappointing. We waited nearly twenty minutes for wait staff to approach our table for a drink order. Upon finishing our appetizers, our table was never cleared of our dirty appetizer plates and then the food runner was approaching our table to drop off our main course; We had to ask for our appetizer plates to be cleared before he went ahead and set down the entrees. With that, we were asked to take our dirty silverware off our appetizer plates and keep them for our main course. To not provide clean utensils is just unacceptable. Additionally, as we were actively eating, a member of the wait staff asked if we were “ still working” and attempted to clear our plates (as if it wasn't obvious we were eating). Lastly, once our check was dropped off no one came back to collect our payment, therefore, we took it upon ourselves and paid at the bar. Not to mention, cleaning off tables with that offensive cleaning agent while people are eating is repulsive. Safe to say we won't be back.

Coach

The service and the food were very good. Was a bit disappointed in how long it took for food to get to the table. Sadly when the entrees were served the vegetables and potatoes were on the cool side. the waitress promptly brought more.

SandraG

First time here and everything was great. Friendly, timely service. Nice ambience - background music was just at the right level and not loud so conversation was easy. Sat by the window for a nice view of the grounds. Bonus was it happened to be restaurant week which i didn't realize when I made the reservation. Food was delicious and plated nicely. Prices were reasonable, quality food. Great time and definitely returning. I imagine it's probably more busy in the evenings, weekends, nicer weather. There are regular, high top tables and bar seating. Reservations recommended. Really no complaints

Kristi Mitchell

My husband and I went for Easter Brunch and we were very disappointed. I want to say very unorganized it was a buffet and the line for the food was on top of people eating the tables were not set up properly and noone was directing anyone. I didn't think the variety was anything special for $55.00 person ..no worth it at all......It was very loud in the barn and I thought they could of had so nice piped in music for atmosphere.

Food: 1

MelodyS

Excellent on every account. From the greeters to the entire staff they were superb. Excellent time and the meal was delicious. Positive experience in every way. Perfect!! Our Valentine's Day dinner was awesome!!

TomM

Fried calamari was not good. We bought it as an appetizer and it made both of us sick the next day. It was the only food that we ate together. I recommend that you investigate why this happened. I would not serve the calamari to guests until you figure out why it made us both sick. I'm sure it happened to others, too.

Carl Winslow

Filet mignon was really really good. Drinks were good as well, so was the atmosphere. Will definitely be visiting again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Diane Arcara

My Husband and I went for dinner to celebrate my Birthday and our wedding anniversary. Corey was our server . The service was impeccable . The food was beyond delicious. We will definitely to back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Absolutely

jaja

We met old friends who we haven't seen in a while and our server was kind and patient. We shared the baked clams and a pot of mussels to start. Best mussels EVER! (other than mine.). I had the lobster Mac n cheese....Outstanding. Def will go back.

TeamTiny Relaxation

They catered a great xmas party.. loved it... another xmas party and another blast.. love this

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Crab Cakes

Michele B

Great holiday party!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

George Le Floch

We had a good

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

NoreenT

Our server, Kayleigh, was outstanding as always. We had drinks and appetizers quickly and the pace of dinner was perfect. The food is delicious and consistently prepared. The lobster Mac and cheese is out of this world. It's a beautiful setting for a fun night out.

Load More