Fantastic food. Freshest fish I’ve had in Hamptons. Food NOT oversalted which means that they use quality ingredients. Spreads all tasty and homemade. Service first rate. Five stars all around.
J F
The food was extraordinary. Fish fresh. None of the food was over-salted (common problem these days). Service fantastic. Simple flavorings which can be a philosophy when the food is high quality and fresh. The feta tasted better than most — again the low salt content allowed for the flavors to surface. Spreads home made and first rate.
Rosanne Hatgipetros
This was always my favorite restaurant until last night and I’ll never go back! The food was okay but the service was terrible! It seemed we were annoying the two male waiters who seemed to be having a bad day!
WFH
I love this place and particularly the bar for a very early dinner with fresh oysters to start. The burger is outstanding and my favorite. Service and staff are excellent.
L B
The guy that seats people is on a power trip, called to see if they had an earlier time, he said no but did say they did walk ins so showed up 20 mins early just to see, 6 open tables ( no joke) and wouldn't sit us till original time, all the tables remained empty, he didn't even offer to sit us at the bar to eat which had open tables, worst hospitality, would pass - not worth with dealing with him.
Nathalie Cookson
Recommended to me by a friend, I had high expectations. The setting is beautiful, and the view of the Acropolis is stunning. However, the food didn’t impress me. We waited a long time first of all. Then, my husband’s chicken souvlaki was served undercooked, with one piece being very pink. I ordered a Cretan salad which arrived looking quite sad. There was a sprinkling of feta, which was unlike other Cretan salads I have had. I’m Greek myself so it was even more disappointing. So I ended up ordering a standard Greek salad, which in itself, wasn’t great.
The waiters were, however, very friendly and smiley and the location/atmosphere is great.
It could’ve just been a one-off, but I felt slightly cheated and won’t be returning.
Nerijus Kviecinskas
Place was very cozy. Food was super fresh and delicious, well balanced not too salty. Getting hungry only by remembering that delicious meal, will definitely return.
Marc G
Great spot for Mediterranean in Bridgehampton. Good food, good specials, quick service and a nice crowd that’s good for an all around dinner. We come back frequently
Dimitrios Koufakos
I’ve ate at some of the best Greek restaurants in NY, this has to be one of the best
Anthony Diaz
Excellent staff and dining. Will definitely return. Chicken dishes were outstanding.
What a great experience!! Food was absolutely delicious, the vibe was very cool. Everything Dennis recommended was outstanding including the greek wine. Thank you for making our dinner so enjoyable. Your an asset to this wonderful hidden gem!! We will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
alexandra hudson
The most authentically delicious Greek food in such a lovely setting. Perfection. Chef Pavlos prepared flawless comfort food and we can’t wait to come back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aaron
Elaia continues to be one of our favorite restaurants on the east end. Attentive service, excellent food, an a pretty diverse menu. Anytime you can combine healthy vegetarian and fish dishes with fried cheese and plenty of meat options is a win for our family. Excellent cocktail/mocktails and interesting wine list. Highly recommend.
Camarena 126
server Marco T was extremely rude! never came back to us a single time, didn’t care about the service at all, would think twice to come back.
Fantastic food. Freshest fish I’ve had in Hamptons. Food NOT oversalted which means that they use quality ingredients. Spreads all tasty and homemade. Service first rate. Five stars all around.
The food was extraordinary. Fish fresh. None of the food was over-salted (common problem these days). Service fantastic. Simple flavorings which can be a philosophy when the food is high quality and fresh. The feta tasted better than most — again the low salt content allowed for the flavors to surface. Spreads home made and first rate.
This was always my favorite restaurant until last night and I’ll never go back! The food was okay but the service was terrible! It seemed we were annoying the two male waiters who seemed to be having a bad day!
I love this place and particularly the bar for a very early dinner with fresh oysters to start. The burger is outstanding and my favorite. Service and staff are excellent.
The guy that seats people is on a power trip, called to see if they had an earlier time, he said no but did say they did walk ins so showed up 20 mins early just to see, 6 open tables ( no joke) and wouldn't sit us till original time, all the tables remained empty, he didn't even offer to sit us at the bar to eat which had open tables, worst hospitality, would pass - not worth with dealing with him.
Recommended to me by a friend, I had high expectations.
The setting is beautiful, and the view of the Acropolis is stunning.
However, the food didn’t impress me. We waited a long time first of all. Then, my husband’s chicken souvlaki was served undercooked, with one piece being very pink. I ordered a Cretan salad which arrived looking quite sad. There was a sprinkling of feta, which was unlike other Cretan salads I have had. I’m Greek myself so it was even more disappointing. So I ended up ordering a standard Greek salad, which in itself, wasn’t great.
The waiters were, however, very friendly and smiley and the location/atmosphere is great.
It could’ve just been a one-off, but I felt slightly cheated and won’t be returning.
Place was very cozy. Food was super fresh and delicious, well balanced not too salty. Getting hungry only by remembering that delicious meal, will definitely return.
Great spot for Mediterranean in Bridgehampton. Good food, good specials, quick service and a nice crowd that’s good for an all around dinner. We come back frequently
I’ve ate at some of the best Greek restaurants in NY, this has to be one of the best
Excellent staff and dining. Will definitely return. Chicken dishes were outstanding.
Restaurantji Recommends
What a great experience!! Food was absolutely delicious, the vibe was very cool. Everything Dennis recommended was outstanding including the greek wine. Thank you for making our dinner so enjoyable. Your an asset to this wonderful hidden gem!! We will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The most authentically delicious Greek food in such a lovely setting. Perfection. Chef Pavlos prepared flawless comfort food and we can’t wait to come back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elaia continues to be one of our favorite restaurants on the east end. Attentive service, excellent food, an a pretty diverse menu. Anytime you can combine healthy vegetarian and fish dishes with fried cheese and plenty of meat options is a win for our family. Excellent cocktail/mocktails and interesting wine list. Highly recommend.
server Marco T was extremely rude! never came back to us a single time, didn’t care about the service at all, would think twice to come back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
My favorite is the loukaniko!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...