58 Main BBQ & Brew

58 N Main St, Brockport
(585) 637-2383

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Michael Schultz

young guy that was the host tonight totally ignored us and decided to seat a group of young women 1st even though we were waiting for 10 minutes ahead of them.

Julie Dainotto

I absolutely love this place. My boyfriend took me here 6 months ago .. nothing compares to their wings . NOTHING .

Ann Bialuski

The food is very good but I was very disappointed with my takeout order. I ordered takeout for my husband’s Birthday. 7 order’s, 3 for children. They charged 2.00 for takeout. 9.00 for a boiled hot dog. 9.00 for chicken fingers. Crazy! Never again.

Jeff DeMinck

Took my family to dinner after a basketball tournament at the college. Great food, huge portions and great service on a busy Saturday night.

Susan Mary Boss

I’ve ordered catering a couple of times for family events and always have a great experience. The latest order was Christmas Eve- delivered to my door, portion sizes were plentiful, delivery staff super friendly and the food was a hit with my family. Thank you!

Miles Clyde

Well, we used to go all the time. we moved to Albion.finally got there and was very disappointed, the Ribs "SUCKED" never again,, so sad

Bianca

We just called in and I picked it up.. The food was delicious and the garlic fries OMG the portion 🤯, it fed all 4 of us (more than once)!! The barbeque is as it should be, finger licking, wet nap using scrumptious!

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: BBQ, Baked Apples

Sara Martone

Mediocre. Mid. Would not go back. Waitress messed up our order and forgot food back in the kitchen for half the table. Cheese sauce for pretzels was congealed and disgusting. Best part of the meal was the side of buffalo sauce.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Debra Cowley

One of the best fish Fry around

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ben Miller

Some of the best wings I've had. Service was really slow. Nice atmosphere

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Smoked Wings

Katie Adolph

Big bar/ restaurant with tons of seating and tvs around both rooms! Food is ALWAYS so good and I love love love their corn bread! Can't go wrong with any of the BBQ or Burgers. Had a fun time hanging with friends and having a nice dinner. Lots of drink options too

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Corn Bread, Burger, BBQ, Grilled Wings, Smoked Wings

Carrie Franklin

We have been ordering take-out from here once every month or two for at least the past year. 2 fish fries, Exactly the same: Well Done, extra tartar, coleslaw and fries. Every time, there is Something different about the two fish fries. We even started ordering them separately to see it the problem was in saying "exactly the same as the first" when ordering. They manage to mess something up Every Single Time. Missing tartar, no lemon, coleslaw missing or not well done. The amazing thing is, the oversight is never the same in each box. I am not certain how they manage this magicians trick.

It gets worse though. Despite the inability to get the order straight, a few weeks ago, I decided to get the brisket dinner. What a waste of money. You could taste the re-heated quality of the meat...it literally tasted like week-old leftovers. The side dishes were tiny, or missing all together because God forbid they complete an order in it's entirety.

The baked apples were over-spiced and almost ruined the whole meal if it wasn't for the fact that it was already dismal. The potatoes were lackluster and I couldn't tell you about the broccoli because it wasn't there. The BBQ sauce was decent and the cornbread won the meal.

Overall, I am not impressed in the slightest. I gave it 3s cuz the other 2 seem to still be interested in ordering the fish fry again, but I will not be eating here again. Just not worth it.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Cole

This BBQ restaurant ranks among the best in the Rochester area. The food is outstanding, showcasing clear attention to detail and dedication in each dish. The chicken, in particular, is exceptional, and I’ll definitely be returning for more. The service was friendly and attentive, contributing to a thoroughly enjoyable experience. While the interior is comfortable, it’s the quality of the BBQ that truly stands out. Overall, this restaurant is a must-visit for an incredible meal that will keep you coming back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Corn Bread, Smoked Fried Grilled Wings, Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Jorge Pino

Great place to reconnect with an old army buddy !!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Grilled Wings, Smoked Wings

Daniel Curtin

You can’t classify this as brisket. I’d just call it some dried out sad pieces of meat. No bark, no smoke ring. Doesn’t even resemble brisket. Complete waste of $30. Also waiting up front forever. Mac n cheese is bland. Will never go back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...