City Island Pizza Company

Great atmosphere. The food is fresh and tastes delicious! The staff is attentive and friendly.

first time delivery here on island. yummy so good. thank you!!

Excellent food. We have been many times and the consistency in the quality is there. Everyone is friendly too. Keep it going.

Vegetarian options: The staff is very helpful in making things work for vegans, etc

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza

No Lie! Best Lobster Roll of my life.
I had just gotten back from Martha's Vineyard, spent time in Maine, and my boys go to school in Rhode Island. I'm no stranger to the warm butter sensation of knuckles on hot bread, but this roll blew me away. I would have never tried a Lobster roll from a pizza joint, but a long time City Island resident said that of all the big sign fish places on City Island, this was the best fish on the strip. I was skeptical, but I went, ordered, and the City Island Lobster roll is the Truth. No lie. Tell Renee I sent you.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

i came here w my bf and his (italian) family on sunday and everyone LOVED the food. the clams appetizer was the best we have ever had. and i dream about the burrata sandwich. pesto was homemade and so much quality prosciutto i’ve only had a comparable sandwich in Florence. you can tell they really put effort into each dish, they were so flavorful and fresh and the server was so kind! gave us pineapple ice cream before we left. will 100 percent come back here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Spaghetti Carbonara, Linguine with Clam Sauce

In the middle of my cycling loop to City Island me and my friend got hungry and wanted some quick grub and just googled nearest pizza not thinking too much but I’m glad we did. In a rush I just ordered a margarita pie but noticed a unique Red Hot Chili Pepper pie, I’m glad I switched. Pizza got devoured before I can even take a picture but most definitely coming back with my friends, not only great pizza but great people. Hands down the best pie I’ve had in the Bronx, right amount of kick from peppers and perfect crust and thinness. While ordering takeout the cashier brought us out cold water while we were waiting for pie which was much appreciated.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

In the middle of my cycling loop to City Island me and my friend got hungry and wanted some quick grub and just googled nearest pizza not thinking too much but I’m glad we did. In a rush I just ordered a margarita pie but noticed a unique Red Hot Chili Pepper pie, I’m glad I switched. Pizza got devoured before I can even take a picture but most definitely coming back with my friends, not only great pizza but great people. Hands down the best pie I’ve had in the Bronx, right amount of kick from peppers and perfect crust and thinness. While ordering takeout the cashier brought us out cold water while we were waiting for pie which was much appreciated.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

wonderful meal! the bread goes so well with the carbonara sauce :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is one of the best restaurants we have been too in a while. We were here a few months ago and it was excellent, we have been asking our friends to come back with us and finally it happened last night. From beginning to end the food and service was outstanding. The manager came and sat with us explained everything on the menu and even gave us a free dessert that was to die for. Make your reservation today, you won't regret it!

The pesto pizza was the best pizza I've had in a long time. And this is coming from a lifelong New Yorker!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Service was great and so was the Pepperoni Pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Recommended dishes: Rice Balls

We had the pepperoni Pizza an it was awesome!

Don't sleep on the vodka pie

Kid-friendliness: Highchair available

Wheelchair accessibility: One level

Love this place! Great food, relaxing ambiance, trendy decor and friendly staff providing wonderful service! It's the perfect place to unwind, have a drink and enjoy a meal. Interesting locally sourced offerings and they make their own bread and sausages! What more can you ask for?!?! Very happy to have such a cool brunch and evening spot on City Island. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Excellent place highly recommended ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5